The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Extent of investigation and management of cases of ‘unexplained’ mismatch repair deficiency (u-dMMR): a UK Cancer Genetics Group consensus

Extent of investigation and management of cases of ‘unexplained’ mismatch repair deficiency (u-dMMR): a UK Cancer Genetics Group consensus
Extent of investigation and management of cases of ‘unexplained’ mismatch repair deficiency (u-dMMR): a UK Cancer Genetics Group consensus

Background: mismatch repair deficiency (dMMR) is a characteristic feature of cancers linked to Lynch syndrome. However, in most cases, it results from sporadic somatic events rather than hereditary factors. The term’Lynch-like syndrome’ (LLS) has been used to guide colorectal cancer surveillance for relatives of individuals with a dMMR tumour when somatic and germline genomic testing is uninformative. As the assessment of mismatch repair through immunohistochemistry and/or microsatellite instability is increasingly applied across various tumour types for treatment planning, dMMR is increasingly detected in tumours where suspicion of hereditary aetiology is low. Our objective was to establish current practices and develop national guidance for investigating, and managing relatives of, patients with cancers demonstrating unexplained dMMR.

Methods: this was achieved through a virtual consensus meeting involving key stakeholders from the UK, through premeeting surveys, structured discussions and in-meeting polling to formulate best practice guidance.

Results: we identified variability in the availability of diagnostic technologies across specialist centres. It was agreed that equitable access to baseline testing is required, acknowledging the need for a pragmatic approach to investigating dMMR cancers not traditionally associated with Lynch syndrome. Factors such as family history, age, tumour type, protein loss pattern and extent of the investigation were deemed crucial in guiding family management. The term’unexplained dMMR’ was recommended over LLS.

Conclusion: decisions regarding investigations and future cancer risk management in patients and relatives should be nuanced, considering factors like clinical suspicion of hereditary predisposition to allocate limited resources efficiently and avoid unnecessary investigations in low-suspicion families.

0022-2593
707-715
McVeigh, Terri Patricia
1abe28dc-7945-4cf3-8f15-3a50ba4dc49e
Monahan, Kevin J.
e477b15c-9465-4e0c-9225-52b70ac647d0
Christopher, Joseph
b7f09c40-167b-4132-8ef7-922744c753c7
West, Nick
3b2ba9a9-0160-4573-91c3-7ea13b0e3850
Scott, Malcolm
3abe7b3e-961b-4f91-8b55-8b90791c62a8
Murray, Jennie
b5971302-dc74-41b4-90eb-001743066be7
Hanson, Helen
fe4a8065-8b0d-4b30-a658-cd433570c2ec
Armstrong, Ruth
0c65f453-64c2-427d-b3fb-a2500591adf8
Beggs, Andrew
6d48ef1a-53b3-4eb9-82c2-c62ed231a380
Berlin, Cheryl
bd07d03c-3565-4d27-945a-31c97443e37a
Boyde, Adam
37177d8f-b253-427c-88e8-8d21359531fc
Brady, Angela
4fc55761-1e51-4e04-8463-73b72ea202e9
Bulmer, Jeremy
a0edc54e-4e88-47c2-a191-5580245f17d6
Burghel, George
135440aa-da7b-4c37-998f-f46bef2f2c79
Burn, John
455f5bd0-3b49-4784-a924-de7861508290
Catherwood, Mark
e1463147-a7b4-4e0b-b99f-62941f81144c
Christopher, Joseph
b7f09c40-167b-4132-8ef7-922744c753c7
Cleaver, Ruth
59105614-b9da-4a64-b436-6203ca096b6a
Coad, Beth
57c85fe1-90a9-4c32-b694-84ac10ddc241
Conti, Hector
2f124146-1e54-4ea4-b66e-ed43810994a3
Cook, Jacqueline
9a7489ff-abec-4979-ae21-333475133037
Cope, Wei
24be348f-e3ea-44ca-b6d4-0e42c93edc27
Corbett, Gemma
e430781d-82e0-4fe9-b5b3-8a746a568da3
Crosbie, Emma
ee31bba5-659e-4165-a707-aaee00f040e0
Davidson, Rosemarie
81692cd9-0a70-4a01-a68f-8eb623f0fbe0
DeSouza, Bianca
6a24ad3a-8963-4329-a1b1-47b337915cb0
Donaldson, Alan
8bd5454f-be4c-4b7a-ae31-c602f391920e
Durkie, Miranda
7caca497-e12f-4f13-99e0-f40e767f0163
Eccles, Diana
5b59bc73-11c9-4cf0-a9d5-7a8e523eee23
Foot, Nicola
e2ba0e57-85ec-4859-bb97-2eea70622179
Frayling, Ian
95840ec6-9078-4bd6-85b0-99f0c822f823
George, Andrew
f81f35e5-5723-40b5-b79c-250eb9a299ef
Gerrard, Gareth
89840fdd-6955-4565-9c75-e6ca296cce30
Gibson, Sarah
febf09cf-4171-4a68-8129-4dcff60048ac
Green, Andrew
cf06816c-8716-409c-b111-24fe4d179901
Greville-Heygate, Stephanie
a952c82d-8775-45a5-9c60-478348fb02f2
Hamilton, Sarah
91b05bda-33c1-4d71-8c9f-7b7cee56ba56
Hanson, Helen
fe4a8065-8b0d-4b30-a658-cd433570c2ec
Hart, Rachel
d94da143-77ec-4dbc-8abd-a8f1d84b3d51
Hodgson, Shirley
a9f6b2c4-f329-40b5-8b07-a74b3fdd1a0c
Holliday, Debbie
98d0a6d9-e62c-465c-9ec9-977e02d111e0
Hoyle, Jacqui
81e5af57-01d9-4d50-a59e-b42b901c3323
Jewell, Rosalyn
07e29ba9-2c5e-40a7-b8d1-23936772a088
Kemp, Zoe
6d96320b-c976-4ea6-9b87-536deb9bb0c9
Kiely, Louise
ce346108-f3c9-4af4-bede-b6b2822529c0
Kiesel, Vicki
5c933d93-1e57-42ac-8da1-87d96184ba67
Kohut, Kelly
b3854433-1b0a-42bf-ad47-3ca65415bf22
Kristeleit, Rebecca
3a77d119-c2ba-4e39-88fd-d93461204829
Kumar, Ajith
f57d39b6-093b-4026-8a86-f9c96f247150
Lee, Natalie
52821b60-182b-44db-8ff1-b3e67c5c553b
UKCGG dMMR Consensus Meeting Attendees
McVeigh, Terri Patricia
1abe28dc-7945-4cf3-8f15-3a50ba4dc49e
Monahan, Kevin J.
e477b15c-9465-4e0c-9225-52b70ac647d0
Christopher, Joseph
b7f09c40-167b-4132-8ef7-922744c753c7
West, Nick
3b2ba9a9-0160-4573-91c3-7ea13b0e3850
Scott, Malcolm
3abe7b3e-961b-4f91-8b55-8b90791c62a8
Murray, Jennie
b5971302-dc74-41b4-90eb-001743066be7
Hanson, Helen
fe4a8065-8b0d-4b30-a658-cd433570c2ec
Armstrong, Ruth
0c65f453-64c2-427d-b3fb-a2500591adf8
Beggs, Andrew
6d48ef1a-53b3-4eb9-82c2-c62ed231a380
Berlin, Cheryl
bd07d03c-3565-4d27-945a-31c97443e37a
Boyde, Adam
37177d8f-b253-427c-88e8-8d21359531fc
Brady, Angela
4fc55761-1e51-4e04-8463-73b72ea202e9
Bulmer, Jeremy
a0edc54e-4e88-47c2-a191-5580245f17d6
Burghel, George
135440aa-da7b-4c37-998f-f46bef2f2c79
Burn, John
455f5bd0-3b49-4784-a924-de7861508290
Catherwood, Mark
e1463147-a7b4-4e0b-b99f-62941f81144c
Christopher, Joseph
b7f09c40-167b-4132-8ef7-922744c753c7
Cleaver, Ruth
59105614-b9da-4a64-b436-6203ca096b6a
Coad, Beth
57c85fe1-90a9-4c32-b694-84ac10ddc241
Conti, Hector
2f124146-1e54-4ea4-b66e-ed43810994a3
Cook, Jacqueline
9a7489ff-abec-4979-ae21-333475133037
Cope, Wei
24be348f-e3ea-44ca-b6d4-0e42c93edc27
Corbett, Gemma
e430781d-82e0-4fe9-b5b3-8a746a568da3
Crosbie, Emma
ee31bba5-659e-4165-a707-aaee00f040e0
Davidson, Rosemarie
81692cd9-0a70-4a01-a68f-8eb623f0fbe0
DeSouza, Bianca
6a24ad3a-8963-4329-a1b1-47b337915cb0
Donaldson, Alan
8bd5454f-be4c-4b7a-ae31-c602f391920e
Durkie, Miranda
7caca497-e12f-4f13-99e0-f40e767f0163
Eccles, Diana
5b59bc73-11c9-4cf0-a9d5-7a8e523eee23
Foot, Nicola
e2ba0e57-85ec-4859-bb97-2eea70622179
Frayling, Ian
95840ec6-9078-4bd6-85b0-99f0c822f823
George, Andrew
f81f35e5-5723-40b5-b79c-250eb9a299ef
Gerrard, Gareth
89840fdd-6955-4565-9c75-e6ca296cce30
Gibson, Sarah
febf09cf-4171-4a68-8129-4dcff60048ac
Green, Andrew
cf06816c-8716-409c-b111-24fe4d179901
Greville-Heygate, Stephanie
a952c82d-8775-45a5-9c60-478348fb02f2
Hamilton, Sarah
91b05bda-33c1-4d71-8c9f-7b7cee56ba56
Hanson, Helen
fe4a8065-8b0d-4b30-a658-cd433570c2ec
Hart, Rachel
d94da143-77ec-4dbc-8abd-a8f1d84b3d51
Hodgson, Shirley
a9f6b2c4-f329-40b5-8b07-a74b3fdd1a0c
Holliday, Debbie
98d0a6d9-e62c-465c-9ec9-977e02d111e0
Hoyle, Jacqui
81e5af57-01d9-4d50-a59e-b42b901c3323
Jewell, Rosalyn
07e29ba9-2c5e-40a7-b8d1-23936772a088
Kemp, Zoe
6d96320b-c976-4ea6-9b87-536deb9bb0c9
Kiely, Louise
ce346108-f3c9-4af4-bede-b6b2822529c0
Kiesel, Vicki
5c933d93-1e57-42ac-8da1-87d96184ba67
Kohut, Kelly
b3854433-1b0a-42bf-ad47-3ca65415bf22
Kristeleit, Rebecca
3a77d119-c2ba-4e39-88fd-d93461204829
Kumar, Ajith
f57d39b6-093b-4026-8a86-f9c96f247150
Lee, Natalie
52821b60-182b-44db-8ff1-b3e67c5c553b

McVeigh, Terri Patricia, Monahan, Kevin J., Christopher, Joseph, West, Nick, Scott, Malcolm, Murray, Jennie and Hanson, Helen , UKCGG dMMR Consensus Meeting Attendees (2024) Extent of investigation and management of cases of ‘unexplained’ mismatch repair deficiency (u-dMMR): a UK Cancer Genetics Group consensus. Journal of Medical Genetics, 61 (7), 707-715, [24109886]. (doi:10.1136/jmg-2024-109886).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Background: mismatch repair deficiency (dMMR) is a characteristic feature of cancers linked to Lynch syndrome. However, in most cases, it results from sporadic somatic events rather than hereditary factors. The term’Lynch-like syndrome’ (LLS) has been used to guide colorectal cancer surveillance for relatives of individuals with a dMMR tumour when somatic and germline genomic testing is uninformative. As the assessment of mismatch repair through immunohistochemistry and/or microsatellite instability is increasingly applied across various tumour types for treatment planning, dMMR is increasingly detected in tumours where suspicion of hereditary aetiology is low. Our objective was to establish current practices and develop national guidance for investigating, and managing relatives of, patients with cancers demonstrating unexplained dMMR.

Methods: this was achieved through a virtual consensus meeting involving key stakeholders from the UK, through premeeting surveys, structured discussions and in-meeting polling to formulate best practice guidance.

Results: we identified variability in the availability of diagnostic technologies across specialist centres. It was agreed that equitable access to baseline testing is required, acknowledging the need for a pragmatic approach to investigating dMMR cancers not traditionally associated with Lynch syndrome. Factors such as family history, age, tumour type, protein loss pattern and extent of the investigation were deemed crucial in guiding family management. The term’unexplained dMMR’ was recommended over LLS.

Conclusion: decisions regarding investigations and future cancer risk management in patients and relatives should be nuanced, considering factors like clinical suspicion of hereditary predisposition to allocate limited resources efficiently and avoid unnecessary investigations in low-suspicion families.

Text
jmg-2024-109886.full - Version of Record
Download (520kB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 9 March 2024
e-pub ahead of print date: 26 December 2024
Additional Information: © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2024. Re-use permitted under CC BY-NC. No commercial re-use. See rights and permissions. Published by BMJ. Publisher Copyright: © Author(s) (or their employer(s)) 2024.

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 489482
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/489482
ISSN: 0022-2593
PURE UUID: 51b4febc-1908-421d-af52-0d61eabd8eae
ORCID for Diana Eccles: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-9935-3169

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 25 Apr 2024 16:32
Last modified: 30 Jul 2024 01:32

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Terri Patricia McVeigh
Author: Kevin J. Monahan
Author: Joseph Christopher
Author: Nick West
Author: Malcolm Scott
Author: Jennie Murray
Author: Helen Hanson
Author: Ruth Armstrong
Author: Andrew Beggs
Author: Cheryl Berlin
Author: Adam Boyde
Author: Angela Brady
Author: Jeremy Bulmer
Author: George Burghel
Author: John Burn
Author: Mark Catherwood
Author: Joseph Christopher
Author: Ruth Cleaver
Author: Beth Coad
Author: Hector Conti
Author: Jacqueline Cook
Author: Wei Cope
Author: Gemma Corbett
Author: Emma Crosbie
Author: Rosemarie Davidson
Author: Bianca DeSouza
Author: Alan Donaldson
Author: Miranda Durkie
Author: Diana Eccles ORCID iD
Author: Nicola Foot
Author: Ian Frayling
Author: Andrew George
Author: Gareth Gerrard
Author: Sarah Gibson
Author: Andrew Green
Author: Stephanie Greville-Heygate
Author: Sarah Hamilton
Author: Helen Hanson
Author: Rachel Hart
Author: Shirley Hodgson
Author: Debbie Holliday
Author: Jacqui Hoyle
Author: Rosalyn Jewell
Author: Zoe Kemp
Author: Louise Kiely
Author: Vicki Kiesel
Author: Kelly Kohut
Author: Rebecca Kristeleit
Author: Ajith Kumar
Author: Natalie Lee
Corporate Author: UKCGG dMMR Consensus Meeting Attendees

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×