Rapid respiratory microbiological point-of-care-testing and antibiotic prescribing in primary care: Protocol for the RAPID-TEST randomised controlled trial
Rapid respiratory microbiological point-of-care-testing and antibiotic prescribing in primary care: Protocol for the RAPID-TEST randomised controlled trial
BACKGROUND: Antibiotics are prescribed for over 50% of respiratory tract infections in primary care, despite good evidence of there being no benefit to the patient, and evidence of over prescribing driving microbial resistance. The high treatment rates are attributed to uncertainty regarding microbiological cause and clinical prognosis. Point-of-care-tests have been proposed as potential antibiotic stewardship tools, with some providing microbiological results in 15 minutes. However, there is little research on their impact on antibiotic use and clinical outcomes in primary care.
METHODS: This is a multi-centre, individually randomised controlled trial with mixed-methods investigation of microbial, behavioural and antibiotic mechanisms on outcomes in patients aged 12 months and over presenting to primary care in the UK with a suspected respiratory tract infection, where the clinician and/or patient thinks antibiotic treatment may be, or is, necessary. Once consented, all participants are asked to provide a combined nose and throat swab sample and randomised to have a rapid microbiological point-of-care-test or no point-of-care-test. For intervention patients, clinicians review the result of the test, before contacting the patient to finalise treatment. Treatment decisions are made as per usual care in control group patients. The primary outcome is whether an antibiotic is prescribed at this point. All swab samples are sent to the central laboratory for further testing. Patients are asked to complete a diary to record the severity and duration of symptoms until resolution or day 28, and questionnaires at 2 months about their beliefs and intention to consult for similar future illnesses. Primary care medical records are also reviewed at 6-months to collect further infection consultations, antibiotic prescribing and hospital admissions. The trial aims to recruit 514 patients to achieve 90% power with 5% significance to detect a 15% absolute reduction in antibiotic prescribing. Qualitative interviews are being conducted with approximately 20 clinicians and 30 participants to understand any changes in beliefs and behaviour resulting from the point-of-care-test and generate attributes for clinician and patient discrete choice experiments.
DISCUSSION: This trial will provide evidence of efficacy, acceptability and mechanisms of action of a rapid microbiological point-of-care test on antibiotic prescribing and patient symptoms in primary care.
TRIAL REGISTRATION: ISRCTN16039192, prospectively registered on 08/11/2022.
Point-of-care test, RCT, antibiotic stewardship, protocol
Abbs, Samantha Elizabeth
00650d36-e554-4e10-b955-5dbbcc861eba
Armstrong-Buisseret, Lindsay
dcdb1453-05fa-4a5e-818e-2c9c8a0afc7d
Eastwood, Kathy
bebb88a0-9790-41e3-8364-e9662429751f
Granier, Stephen
dc15b6bc-5a24-47c1-bdbc-ac46f4d5872c
Lane, Athene
6683aef1-075d-471f-9c9f-b561a2a3902e
Lui, Mandy
94f324c2-2278-43f3-9443-e71bafd22e3e
Metcalfe, Chris
516c7009-41ad-4913-b7cd-5f9dffe792b1
Mitchell, Paul
bfea7dec-d8f1-40de-8703-d933d6f83799
Muir, Peter
60ee4901-6b63-4744-a4b5-54eb38519121
Ridd, Matthew
2f15120c-d5fa-4f5d-bb86-21356e034df7
Taylor, Jodi
875cc40a-d428-4a7d-9ee0-710051549a88
Yardley, Lucy
64be42c4-511d-484d-abaa-f8813452a22e
Young, Grace
34e6c6a3-80ca-4a55-b0c8-1b3f51093f21
Hay, Alastair D.
39c85dd1-4294-4345-987f-07888de3d522
20 May 2024
Abbs, Samantha Elizabeth
00650d36-e554-4e10-b955-5dbbcc861eba
Armstrong-Buisseret, Lindsay
dcdb1453-05fa-4a5e-818e-2c9c8a0afc7d
Eastwood, Kathy
bebb88a0-9790-41e3-8364-e9662429751f
Granier, Stephen
dc15b6bc-5a24-47c1-bdbc-ac46f4d5872c
Lane, Athene
6683aef1-075d-471f-9c9f-b561a2a3902e
Lui, Mandy
94f324c2-2278-43f3-9443-e71bafd22e3e
Metcalfe, Chris
516c7009-41ad-4913-b7cd-5f9dffe792b1
Mitchell, Paul
bfea7dec-d8f1-40de-8703-d933d6f83799
Muir, Peter
60ee4901-6b63-4744-a4b5-54eb38519121
Ridd, Matthew
2f15120c-d5fa-4f5d-bb86-21356e034df7
Taylor, Jodi
875cc40a-d428-4a7d-9ee0-710051549a88
Yardley, Lucy
64be42c4-511d-484d-abaa-f8813452a22e
Young, Grace
34e6c6a3-80ca-4a55-b0c8-1b3f51093f21
Hay, Alastair D.
39c85dd1-4294-4345-987f-07888de3d522
Abbs, Samantha Elizabeth, Armstrong-Buisseret, Lindsay, Eastwood, Kathy, Granier, Stephen, Lane, Athene, Lui, Mandy, Metcalfe, Chris, Mitchell, Paul, Muir, Peter, Ridd, Matthew, Taylor, Jodi, Yardley, Lucy, Young, Grace and Hay, Alastair D.
(2024)
Rapid respiratory microbiological point-of-care-testing and antibiotic prescribing in primary care: Protocol for the RAPID-TEST randomised controlled trial.
PLoS ONE, 19 (5 May), [e0302302].
(doi:10.1371/journal.pone.0302302).
Abstract
BACKGROUND: Antibiotics are prescribed for over 50% of respiratory tract infections in primary care, despite good evidence of there being no benefit to the patient, and evidence of over prescribing driving microbial resistance. The high treatment rates are attributed to uncertainty regarding microbiological cause and clinical prognosis. Point-of-care-tests have been proposed as potential antibiotic stewardship tools, with some providing microbiological results in 15 minutes. However, there is little research on their impact on antibiotic use and clinical outcomes in primary care.
METHODS: This is a multi-centre, individually randomised controlled trial with mixed-methods investigation of microbial, behavioural and antibiotic mechanisms on outcomes in patients aged 12 months and over presenting to primary care in the UK with a suspected respiratory tract infection, where the clinician and/or patient thinks antibiotic treatment may be, or is, necessary. Once consented, all participants are asked to provide a combined nose and throat swab sample and randomised to have a rapid microbiological point-of-care-test or no point-of-care-test. For intervention patients, clinicians review the result of the test, before contacting the patient to finalise treatment. Treatment decisions are made as per usual care in control group patients. The primary outcome is whether an antibiotic is prescribed at this point. All swab samples are sent to the central laboratory for further testing. Patients are asked to complete a diary to record the severity and duration of symptoms until resolution or day 28, and questionnaires at 2 months about their beliefs and intention to consult for similar future illnesses. Primary care medical records are also reviewed at 6-months to collect further infection consultations, antibiotic prescribing and hospital admissions. The trial aims to recruit 514 patients to achieve 90% power with 5% significance to detect a 15% absolute reduction in antibiotic prescribing. Qualitative interviews are being conducted with approximately 20 clinicians and 30 participants to understand any changes in beliefs and behaviour resulting from the point-of-care-test and generate attributes for clinician and patient discrete choice experiments.
DISCUSSION: This trial will provide evidence of efficacy, acceptability and mechanisms of action of a rapid microbiological point-of-care test on antibiotic prescribing and patient symptoms in primary care.
TRIAL REGISTRATION: ISRCTN16039192, prospectively registered on 08/11/2022.
Text
journal.pone.0302302
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 28 March 2024
Published date: 20 May 2024
Additional Information:
Publisher Copyright:
Copyright: © 2024 Abbs et al. This is an open access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License, which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited.
Keywords:
Point-of-care test, RCT, antibiotic stewardship, protocol
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 490286
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/490286
ISSN: 1932-6203
PURE UUID: 35241ec7-b72f-461c-a1b3-cd79c460a345
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 23 May 2024 16:38
Last modified: 11 Jun 2024 01:35
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Samantha Elizabeth Abbs
Author:
Lindsay Armstrong-Buisseret
Author:
Kathy Eastwood
Author:
Stephen Granier
Author:
Athene Lane
Author:
Mandy Lui
Author:
Chris Metcalfe
Author:
Paul Mitchell
Author:
Peter Muir
Author:
Matthew Ridd
Author:
Jodi Taylor
Author:
Grace Young
Author:
Alastair D. Hay
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics