Is the fulfilment of objective wellbeing reflected in subjective wellbeing? A case study of vulnerable communities in Volta Delta, Ghana

Abstract

There is growing interest in the measurement and conceptualisation of wellbeing
due to its increasing importance within policy outcomes; however, the understanding of how
different wellbeing outcomes associate within sustainability research is limited. This paper
uses household survey data from the vulnerable Volta Delta, South Ghana, as a case study to
illustrate the different philosophical approaches and measures of wellbeing, and the potential
impact upon policy interventions. The frequent use of objective wellbeing measures, such as
monetary poverty, within development policy is challenged as to whether it sufficiently
reflects overall wellbeing. For example, objective monetary measures may not incorporate the
intangible components of wellbeing, which can alternatively be captured within individuals’
self-evaluated, subjective wellbeing.
This study first outlines the conceptual and methodological choices required when
measuring wellbeing, before drawing on ideas of objective and subjective wellbeing to
examine whether these concepts from different disciplines align or oppose one another.
Contrasting theories within the literature justify this focus. By testing for associations between
objective and subjective wellbeing outcomes, this study highlights how the methodological
and conceptual choices made when measuring wellbeing can result in differing conclusions.
Despite statistically significant associations being found amongst some wellbeing measures,
results which show opposing outcomes highlight how subjective and objective wellbeing are
not entirely interchangeable. Our study concludes there is a benefit to incorporating both
objective and subjective measures in research and development targets across multiple scales
to more-comprehensibly capture, and improve our understanding of, human wellbeing in
vulnerable locations.

More information

Identifiers

ORCID for Craig W. Hutton: orcid.org/0000-0002-5896-756X

ORCID for Kristine Nilsen: orcid.org/0000-0003-2009-4019

Catalogue record

Export record

Altmetrics