Exploring the cross-cultural acceptability of digital tools for pain self-reporting: qualitative study
Exploring the cross-cultural acceptability of digital tools for pain self-reporting: qualitative study
Background: culture and ethnicity influence how people communicate about their pain. This makes it challenging to develop pain self-report tools that are acceptable across ethnic groups.
Objective: we aimed to inform the development of cross-culturally acceptable digital pain self-report tools by better understanding the similarities and differences between ethnic groups in pain experiences and self-reporting needs.
Methods: three web-based workshops consisting of a focus group and a user requirement exercise with people who self-identified as being of Black African (n=6), South Asian (n=10), or White British (n=7) ethnicity were conducted.
Results: across ethnic groups, participants shared similar lived experiences and challenges in communicating their pain to health care professionals. However, there were differences in beliefs about the causes of pain, attitudes toward pain medication, and experiences of how stigma and gender norms influenced pain-reporting behavior. Despite these differences, they agreed on important aspects for pain self-report, but participants from non-White backgrounds had additional language requirements such as culturally appropriate pain terminologies to reduce self-reporting barriers.
Conclusions: to improve the cross-cultural acceptability and equity of digital pain self-report tools, future developments should address the differences among ethnic groups on pain perceptions and beliefs, factors influencing pain reporting behavior, and language requirements.
Ali, Syed Mustafa
684b2fd7-0f78-40c7-9085-ff633aaa68e9
Lee, Rebecca R.
51b163ba-6141-4804-8e71-22c674bfb373
McBeth, John
98012716-66ba-480b-9e43-ac53b51dce61
James, Ben
5bba1a9f-0277-4814-8f20-d6e8e46d333f
McAlister, Sean
eb53e6c9-97d9-4e40-8bf6-c74daa05ff8d
Chiarotto, Alessandro
ba9f8371-6ced-4c0f-8946-6aa1622d8bc0
Dixon, William G.
8fcb2256-4094-4f58-9777-4248ad245166
van der Veer, Sabine N.
34f20db8-f374-49cf-b1ed-b02b639a9f01
8 February 2023
Ali, Syed Mustafa
684b2fd7-0f78-40c7-9085-ff633aaa68e9
Lee, Rebecca R.
51b163ba-6141-4804-8e71-22c674bfb373
McBeth, John
98012716-66ba-480b-9e43-ac53b51dce61
James, Ben
5bba1a9f-0277-4814-8f20-d6e8e46d333f
McAlister, Sean
eb53e6c9-97d9-4e40-8bf6-c74daa05ff8d
Chiarotto, Alessandro
ba9f8371-6ced-4c0f-8946-6aa1622d8bc0
Dixon, William G.
8fcb2256-4094-4f58-9777-4248ad245166
van der Veer, Sabine N.
34f20db8-f374-49cf-b1ed-b02b639a9f01
Ali, Syed Mustafa, Lee, Rebecca R., McBeth, John, James, Ben, McAlister, Sean, Chiarotto, Alessandro, Dixon, William G. and van der Veer, Sabine N.
(2023)
Exploring the cross-cultural acceptability of digital tools for pain self-reporting: qualitative study.
JMIR Human Factors, [e412177].
(doi:10.2196/42177).
Abstract
Background: culture and ethnicity influence how people communicate about their pain. This makes it challenging to develop pain self-report tools that are acceptable across ethnic groups.
Objective: we aimed to inform the development of cross-culturally acceptable digital pain self-report tools by better understanding the similarities and differences between ethnic groups in pain experiences and self-reporting needs.
Methods: three web-based workshops consisting of a focus group and a user requirement exercise with people who self-identified as being of Black African (n=6), South Asian (n=10), or White British (n=7) ethnicity were conducted.
Results: across ethnic groups, participants shared similar lived experiences and challenges in communicating their pain to health care professionals. However, there were differences in beliefs about the causes of pain, attitudes toward pain medication, and experiences of how stigma and gender norms influenced pain-reporting behavior. Despite these differences, they agreed on important aspects for pain self-report, but participants from non-White backgrounds had additional language requirements such as culturally appropriate pain terminologies to reduce self-reporting barriers.
Conclusions: to improve the cross-cultural acceptability and equity of digital pain self-report tools, future developments should address the differences among ethnic groups on pain perceptions and beliefs, factors influencing pain reporting behavior, and language requirements.
Text
humanfactors-2023-1-e42177
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 8 November 2022
Published date: 8 February 2023
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 491496
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/491496
ISSN: 2292-9495
PURE UUID: a93593c2-a01a-4429-a337-2b4cfabc72fe
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 25 Jun 2024 16:42
Last modified: 26 Jun 2024 02:11
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Syed Mustafa Ali
Author:
Rebecca R. Lee
Author:
John McBeth
Author:
Ben James
Author:
Sean McAlister
Author:
Alessandro Chiarotto
Author:
William G. Dixon
Author:
Sabine N. van der Veer
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics