Advancing policy makers' expertise in evidence-use: A new approach to enhancing the role research can have in aiding educational policy development
Advancing policy makers' expertise in evidence-use: A new approach to enhancing the role research can have in aiding educational policy development
This paper explores the notion of evidence-informed policy making and the factors that have hindered its development in the UK to date. It then explores Flyvbjerg's notion of phronetic expertise and hypothesises that the learning that accrues from engaging with multiple cases could also lead to policy-makers developing competency in relation to evidence use. As a result, I contend that, given the issues that abound with current attempts to embed and enact evidence informed policy making, the phronetic approach presents an alternative and viable way of establishing enhanced levels of evidence use within educational policy development. As such, the paper not only proposes educational change but as a consequence, it also puts forward suggestions for ways of facilitating more effective educational change in terms of the development of educational policy. In particular, the paper spotlights a need for current thought in this area to move away from rational and linear perspectives, to ones where policy makers are continuously incorporating the most up to date evidence into their thinking, enabling it to be intuitively conjoined with other pertinent and salient factors in order to provide a holistic and well-rounded decision in relation to given issues. I argue that this could occur most effectively via the establishment of policy learning communities and processes to facilitate the creation of knowledge within them. I also suggest that expectations of individuals and organizational cultures will need to change to accommodate participation by policy officials within such communities.
Evidence informed policy making, Evidence use, Expertise, Flyvbjerg, Knowledge adoption, Knowledge mobilisation
19-36
Brown, Chris
42bbe788-54bf-4081-8c18-ead8b554f0fd
February 2014
Brown, Chris
42bbe788-54bf-4081-8c18-ead8b554f0fd
Brown, Chris
(2014)
Advancing policy makers' expertise in evidence-use: A new approach to enhancing the role research can have in aiding educational policy development.
Journal of Educational Change, 15 (1), .
(doi:10.1007/s10833-013-9224-7).
Abstract
This paper explores the notion of evidence-informed policy making and the factors that have hindered its development in the UK to date. It then explores Flyvbjerg's notion of phronetic expertise and hypothesises that the learning that accrues from engaging with multiple cases could also lead to policy-makers developing competency in relation to evidence use. As a result, I contend that, given the issues that abound with current attempts to embed and enact evidence informed policy making, the phronetic approach presents an alternative and viable way of establishing enhanced levels of evidence use within educational policy development. As such, the paper not only proposes educational change but as a consequence, it also puts forward suggestions for ways of facilitating more effective educational change in terms of the development of educational policy. In particular, the paper spotlights a need for current thought in this area to move away from rational and linear perspectives, to ones where policy makers are continuously incorporating the most up to date evidence into their thinking, enabling it to be intuitively conjoined with other pertinent and salient factors in order to provide a holistic and well-rounded decision in relation to given issues. I argue that this could occur most effectively via the establishment of policy learning communities and processes to facilitate the creation of knowledge within them. I also suggest that expectations of individuals and organizational cultures will need to change to accommodate participation by policy officials within such communities.
This record has no associated files available for download.
More information
Published date: February 2014
Keywords:
Evidence informed policy making, Evidence use, Expertise, Flyvbjerg, Knowledge adoption, Knowledge mobilisation
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 494573
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/494573
ISSN: 1389-2843
PURE UUID: 57b14762-edec-4a06-a182-b21bd543d3c3
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 10 Oct 2024 16:49
Last modified: 11 Oct 2024 02:08
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Chris Brown
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics