"I'm part of the furniture now, innit?": risk governance and moral thwarting among life-sentenced men in English prisons
"I'm part of the furniture now, innit?": risk governance and moral thwarting among life-sentenced men in English prisons
People serving indeterminate prison sentences in England & Wales progress largely based on assessments by officials of how well they have performed against the expectation to ‘reduce their risk’ of harming others in future. Prison scholars have noted that this kind of assessment prompts pains of ‘tightness’. This paper draws on case studies of two life-sentenced men in an open prison, both contemplating the ‘tight’ conditions under which they might be released, and reflecting on their ethical lives in light of these. It describes the moral messages they received through punishment, and how they responded, ethically, to these. The paper argues that both men felt morally thwarted. For one, apparently impressive rehabilitative progress meant little because his licence conditions would make it impossible to fully pursue what he saw as as ‘good’ life; for the other, it felt impossible to mould himself to the complicated expectations risk management measures communicated. Both men were framing their ethical goals mainly in relation to the demands of their sentences rather than the lives they hoped to lead afterwards. This undermined one of the sentence’s supposed aims, to reform and rehabilitate them and restore them to a position of qualified freedom.
penal theory, moral communication, punishment, life imprisonment, murder, risk, risk governance, ethics, anthropology of ethics, moral thwarting
Jarman, Ben
17792bef-9b37-408e-b734-acb707842715
6 July 2022
Jarman, Ben
17792bef-9b37-408e-b734-acb707842715
Jarman, Ben
(2022)
"I'm part of the furniture now, innit?": risk governance and moral thwarting among life-sentenced men in English prisons.
Moral & Ethical Worlds of Confinement, Westminster College, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
06 - 07 Jul 2022.
Record type:
Conference or Workshop Item
(Paper)
Abstract
People serving indeterminate prison sentences in England & Wales progress largely based on assessments by officials of how well they have performed against the expectation to ‘reduce their risk’ of harming others in future. Prison scholars have noted that this kind of assessment prompts pains of ‘tightness’. This paper draws on case studies of two life-sentenced men in an open prison, both contemplating the ‘tight’ conditions under which they might be released, and reflecting on their ethical lives in light of these. It describes the moral messages they received through punishment, and how they responded, ethically, to these. The paper argues that both men felt morally thwarted. For one, apparently impressive rehabilitative progress meant little because his licence conditions would make it impossible to fully pursue what he saw as as ‘good’ life; for the other, it felt impossible to mould himself to the complicated expectations risk management measures communicated. Both men were framing their ethical goals mainly in relation to the demands of their sentences rather than the lives they hoped to lead afterwards. This undermined one of the sentence’s supposed aims, to reform and rehabilitate them and restore them to a position of qualified freedom.
This record has no associated files available for download.
More information
Submitted date: 6 July 2022
Published date: 6 July 2022
Venue - Dates:
Moral & Ethical Worlds of Confinement, Westminster College, Cambridge, United Kingdom, 2022-07-06 - 2022-07-07
Keywords:
penal theory, moral communication, punishment, life imprisonment, murder, risk, risk governance, ethics, anthropology of ethics, moral thwarting
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 496974
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/496974
PURE UUID: ffc57076-33eb-4a2e-be71-73c70d51ca91
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 09 Jan 2025 17:31
Last modified: 10 Jan 2025 03:21
Export record
Contributors
Author:
Ben Jarman
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics