Recommendations for transitioning young people with primary immunodeficiency disorders and autoinflammatory diseases to adult care
Recommendations for transitioning young people with primary immunodeficiency disorders and autoinflammatory diseases to adult care
Purpose: significant improvements in the prognosis for young patients with Primary Immunodeficiency Diseases (PID) and Autoinflammatory Disorders (AID), which together make up the majority of Inborn Errors of Immunity (IEI), have resulted in the need for optimisation of transition and transfer of care to adult services. Effective transition is crucial to improve health outcomes and treatment compliance among patients. Evaluations of existing transition programmes in European health centres identified the absence of disease-specific transition guidelines for PID and AID, as a challenge to the transition process. This research aimed to establish expert consensus statements for the transition of young patients with PID and AID to adult services.
Methods: this project used the Delphi method to establish mutual agreement for the proposed recommendations. A draft set of statements was developed following a literature review of existing transition programmes. Then the ERN RITA Transition Working Group convened to review the drafted recommendations and develop them into a survey. This survey was circulated among healthcare professionals to determine consensus using a five-point Likert scale, with the level of agreement set to 80% or greater. Statements that did not reach consensus were revised by the Working Group and recirculated among respondents.
Results: the initial survey received 93 responses from 68 centres across 23 countries, while the following survey outlining revised recommendations received 66 responses. The respondents agreed upon recommendations detailing the structure and administration of transition programmes, collaborative working with social systems, and contraindications to transfer of care.
Conclusion: this paper sets out a comprehensive set of recommendations to optimise transitional care for PID and AID.
autoinflammatory diseases, inborn errors of immunity, primary immunodeficiency disorders, recommendations, Transition
Israni, Muskan
267e2ab9-5600-41b2-a95f-68c914bf62da
Alderson, Eliska
ad476ac7-c8e9-433a-b45a-b57105ac52e1
Mahlaoui, Nizar
e53e9a39-b604-4ff6-a178-f8b8d8c0a9f9
Obici, Laura
0268af4a-6673-464e-b4dc-2dbe28b97db7
Rossi-Semerano, Linda
c8d8694a-0fa9-4d02-b92b-b1b402b74731
Lachmann, Helen
f4048af8-bc05-46ce-b651-9138ef7059fd
Avramovič, Mojca Zajc
b290c3c2-dfbb-4c7e-98b6-5e4a4f5f99a0
Guffroy, Aurelien
618afc9b-d5a6-4ee3-820d-04ed5df3a383
Dalm, Virgil
be9c4734-cb4f-4425-b0de-d97cb2ba895d
Rimmer, Rachel
f7b36b27-edfd-4cf8-8c65-65eb6cee0452
Solis, Leire
7d3eac90-8a2b-4c89-9e88-07152fcf21eb
Villar, Carlota
0dab56b3-d665-41de-a2ab-4140966bfecc
Gennery, Andrew R.
170e9fd1-c65e-4beb-b39f-345d288b3ca8
Skeffington, Stephanie
de78fcc6-2c65-4581-b421-968235be838d
Nordin, Julia
5ddbf19c-baf1-42d5-b7a5-16a5fd8b57d8
Warnatz, Klaus
080f4e56-7e34-40f4-a218-c3a39b3a1d8d
Korganow, Anne Sophie
4851146b-5142-4e48-b93c-9d17ab6c2711
Antón, Jordi
6dac8341-ea9d-4d1b-9b6b-367fc47128e1
Cattalini, Marco
8707f8b1-af54-437a-918b-9d2a227d164c
Berg, Stefan
910fc942-f21d-46c6-8a62-ac3d6122d8f5
Soler-Palacin, Pere
b45d06ae-2ce2-4d49-a1d2-d6641ea344ca
Campbell, Mari
f3371415-c8c2-4e93-b0af-dfb6788b9025
Burns, Siobhan O.
bd9e978a-96a1-4916-86c9-9d9dc45aa831
Neven, Bénédicte
9f2a2ba4-722d-4d87-8a62-b83055012aad
Carrabba, Maria
e2a18c45-81bb-4f24-8a97-a409044b71bf
Pergent, Martine
920e419d-9b8c-4df7-8ac5-3546b8f318c6
Jandus, Peter
344c3ce0-19c7-4933-b780-3e2a40305a3b
Velcheva, Margarita
87f9482f-9da0-4a6a-8dcf-d50b5af71681
Pac, Malgorzata
9ed61047-d048-45e9-b1cd-ea4d9909ced0
Haerynck, Filomeen
49074e26-7cb6-458a-8be1-59daa09fe6b3
Meyts, Isabelle
16488133-7e62-43e0-99fc-0e7d2d1776c4
Hauck, Fabian
44ec07bb-dd1d-4c9c-b2da-60743cf7700c
Soler-Palacín, Pere
a0534b9b-44cb-4c14-9078-2095700cfe45
Sediva, Anna
cc157653-0f09-40fb-8c58-deb8d1206528
Gardulf, Ann
502de37e-c769-4ecd-bdd8-daa2924a7580
Hayward, Georgia
b5c797a5-683a-40d3-8636-7a44238476e4
Amin, Tania
640b4ecf-a87a-4c46-821e-d076e973fbd1
Dehoorne, Joke
2fd443f0-4d4e-44ed-896c-65e177e0ece6
Neth, Olaf
3a88236a-b4dc-4397-93de-0273610909ad
Masmas, Tania Nicole
11a44c3a-5a70-4406-bf82-540e2710354e
Katzenstein, Terese
1b0d1e60-006f-4a7f-953e-cc4868da00e3
da Silva, Susana Lopes
fe63a08b-776c-473a-94e3-3043fbb46837
Marquart, Hanne
349f1c62-5c34-41c1-ab5d-827d991c0894
Hentgen, Véronique
47179948-f197-4d9d-9157-23381a0572eb
Fabio, Giovanna
e69a10cc-69dd-47ee-b70f-6579158e67fc
von Bernuth, Horst
cea9dfa6-32d1-4e9c-b414-e17fb92ef73e
Herlin, Troels
bed3feae-5f15-4719-98e9-dac1b2250016
Brogan, Paul
be9ab028-25f3-43ac-a460-ba28b345ef32
Hanitsch, Leif
6204b54a-2d33-406a-a789-b42276fdaf1f
Faust, Saul
f97df780-9f9b-418e-b349-7adf63e150c1
on behalf of the ESID Clinical Working Party
the ERN RITA Transition Working Group Consortium
17 December 2024
Israni, Muskan
267e2ab9-5600-41b2-a95f-68c914bf62da
Alderson, Eliska
ad476ac7-c8e9-433a-b45a-b57105ac52e1
Mahlaoui, Nizar
e53e9a39-b604-4ff6-a178-f8b8d8c0a9f9
Obici, Laura
0268af4a-6673-464e-b4dc-2dbe28b97db7
Rossi-Semerano, Linda
c8d8694a-0fa9-4d02-b92b-b1b402b74731
Lachmann, Helen
f4048af8-bc05-46ce-b651-9138ef7059fd
Avramovič, Mojca Zajc
b290c3c2-dfbb-4c7e-98b6-5e4a4f5f99a0
Guffroy, Aurelien
618afc9b-d5a6-4ee3-820d-04ed5df3a383
Dalm, Virgil
be9c4734-cb4f-4425-b0de-d97cb2ba895d
Rimmer, Rachel
f7b36b27-edfd-4cf8-8c65-65eb6cee0452
Solis, Leire
7d3eac90-8a2b-4c89-9e88-07152fcf21eb
Villar, Carlota
0dab56b3-d665-41de-a2ab-4140966bfecc
Gennery, Andrew R.
170e9fd1-c65e-4beb-b39f-345d288b3ca8
Skeffington, Stephanie
de78fcc6-2c65-4581-b421-968235be838d
Nordin, Julia
5ddbf19c-baf1-42d5-b7a5-16a5fd8b57d8
Warnatz, Klaus
080f4e56-7e34-40f4-a218-c3a39b3a1d8d
Korganow, Anne Sophie
4851146b-5142-4e48-b93c-9d17ab6c2711
Antón, Jordi
6dac8341-ea9d-4d1b-9b6b-367fc47128e1
Cattalini, Marco
8707f8b1-af54-437a-918b-9d2a227d164c
Berg, Stefan
910fc942-f21d-46c6-8a62-ac3d6122d8f5
Soler-Palacin, Pere
b45d06ae-2ce2-4d49-a1d2-d6641ea344ca
Campbell, Mari
f3371415-c8c2-4e93-b0af-dfb6788b9025
Burns, Siobhan O.
bd9e978a-96a1-4916-86c9-9d9dc45aa831
Neven, Bénédicte
9f2a2ba4-722d-4d87-8a62-b83055012aad
Carrabba, Maria
e2a18c45-81bb-4f24-8a97-a409044b71bf
Pergent, Martine
920e419d-9b8c-4df7-8ac5-3546b8f318c6
Jandus, Peter
344c3ce0-19c7-4933-b780-3e2a40305a3b
Velcheva, Margarita
87f9482f-9da0-4a6a-8dcf-d50b5af71681
Pac, Malgorzata
9ed61047-d048-45e9-b1cd-ea4d9909ced0
Haerynck, Filomeen
49074e26-7cb6-458a-8be1-59daa09fe6b3
Meyts, Isabelle
16488133-7e62-43e0-99fc-0e7d2d1776c4
Hauck, Fabian
44ec07bb-dd1d-4c9c-b2da-60743cf7700c
Soler-Palacín, Pere
a0534b9b-44cb-4c14-9078-2095700cfe45
Sediva, Anna
cc157653-0f09-40fb-8c58-deb8d1206528
Gardulf, Ann
502de37e-c769-4ecd-bdd8-daa2924a7580
Hayward, Georgia
b5c797a5-683a-40d3-8636-7a44238476e4
Amin, Tania
640b4ecf-a87a-4c46-821e-d076e973fbd1
Dehoorne, Joke
2fd443f0-4d4e-44ed-896c-65e177e0ece6
Neth, Olaf
3a88236a-b4dc-4397-93de-0273610909ad
Masmas, Tania Nicole
11a44c3a-5a70-4406-bf82-540e2710354e
Katzenstein, Terese
1b0d1e60-006f-4a7f-953e-cc4868da00e3
da Silva, Susana Lopes
fe63a08b-776c-473a-94e3-3043fbb46837
Marquart, Hanne
349f1c62-5c34-41c1-ab5d-827d991c0894
Hentgen, Véronique
47179948-f197-4d9d-9157-23381a0572eb
Fabio, Giovanna
e69a10cc-69dd-47ee-b70f-6579158e67fc
von Bernuth, Horst
cea9dfa6-32d1-4e9c-b414-e17fb92ef73e
Herlin, Troels
bed3feae-5f15-4719-98e9-dac1b2250016
Brogan, Paul
be9ab028-25f3-43ac-a460-ba28b345ef32
Hanitsch, Leif
6204b54a-2d33-406a-a789-b42276fdaf1f
Faust, Saul
f97df780-9f9b-418e-b349-7adf63e150c1