Gender differences in the association between anxiety and interoceptive insight
Gender differences in the association between anxiety and interoceptive insight
Anxiety is one of the most common and debilitating mental health disorders, and is related to changes in interoception (perception of bodily states). While anxiety is more prevalent in women than men, gender differences in interoception-anxiety associations are often overlooked. Here, we examined gender-specific relationships between anxiety and interoception in the breathing domain, utilising multicentre data pooled from four study sites (N = 175; 51% women). State anxiety scores were quantified via the Spielberger State–Trait Anxiety Inventory, and breathing-related interoceptive dimensions via an inspiratory load task to quantify sensitivity, decision bias, metacognitive bias (confidence in interoceptive decisions), and metacognitive insight (congruency between performance and confidence). Regression analyses revealed a significant negative relationship between state anxiety and metacognitive bias (β = −0.28; p = 0.01) and insight (β = −0.09; 95% highest density interval [HDI] in a hierarchical Bayesian regression = [−0.18, −0.004]) across the whole sample, while state anxiety did not relate to interoceptive sensitivity nor decision bias. While no mean interoceptive effects relating to gender were observed, the relationship between anxiety and metacognitive insight towards breathing was driven by women (women: β = −0.18; HDI = [−0.31, −0.05]; men: β = 0.02; HDI = [−0.12, 0.15]) with a significant interaction effect (β difference = −0.20; HDI = [−0.37, −0.01]), which did not hold for trait anxiety nor depression measures. In summary, state anxiety was associated with decreased metacognitive bias across all participants, while decreased interoceptive insight was only associated with anxiety in women but not men. Therefore, treatment programmes focusing on interoceptive metacognitive bias may be useful for all anxiety patients, while interoceptive insight might represent a specific treatment target for women with anxiety.
breathing, computational psychiatry, insight, interoception, metacognition
Harrison, Olivia K.
116baaec-2192-417b-a9ca-9fd318e5450a
Köchli, Laura
23ed1efd-6e48-43d6-bfec-1ffbe54270af
Marino, Stephanie
614f6946-ccf1-4ca2-b627-65c59c86dea6
Marlow, Lucy
e06d388e-df70-4635-8a15-16a6fa812a68
Finnegan, Sarah L.
f8f95b01-801c-4440-8741-74e7036df179
Ainsworth, Ben
b02d78c3-aa8b-462d-a534-31f1bf164f81
Talks, Benjamin j.
d50e4997-948f-4cfc-8272-84621e576b39
Russell, Bruce R.
8d139c8c-a61f-46fd-a630-9e2e33683d7a
Harrison, Samuel j.
85e8e276-90b5-46de-aed9-4640d355c882
Pattinson, Kyle T.S.
c3b31506-824a-4221-9e62-019a559ff7d5
Fleming, Stephen M.
a6ee2698-e47e-4a98-9955-35d8d4fe4108
Stephan, Klaas E.
e78cfa7d-3581-4f04-832c-68e765f4ea7f
13 January 2025
Harrison, Olivia K.
116baaec-2192-417b-a9ca-9fd318e5450a
Köchli, Laura
23ed1efd-6e48-43d6-bfec-1ffbe54270af
Marino, Stephanie
614f6946-ccf1-4ca2-b627-65c59c86dea6
Marlow, Lucy
e06d388e-df70-4635-8a15-16a6fa812a68
Finnegan, Sarah L.
f8f95b01-801c-4440-8741-74e7036df179
Ainsworth, Ben
b02d78c3-aa8b-462d-a534-31f1bf164f81
Talks, Benjamin j.
d50e4997-948f-4cfc-8272-84621e576b39
Russell, Bruce R.
8d139c8c-a61f-46fd-a630-9e2e33683d7a
Harrison, Samuel j.
85e8e276-90b5-46de-aed9-4640d355c882
Pattinson, Kyle T.S.
c3b31506-824a-4221-9e62-019a559ff7d5
Fleming, Stephen M.
a6ee2698-e47e-4a98-9955-35d8d4fe4108
Stephan, Klaas E.
e78cfa7d-3581-4f04-832c-68e765f4ea7f
Harrison, Olivia K., Köchli, Laura, Marino, Stephanie, Marlow, Lucy, Finnegan, Sarah L., Ainsworth, Ben, Talks, Benjamin j., Russell, Bruce R., Harrison, Samuel j., Pattinson, Kyle T.S., Fleming, Stephen M. and Stephan, Klaas E.
(2025)
Gender differences in the association between anxiety and interoceptive insight.
European Journal of Neuroscience, 61 (1), [e16672].
(doi:10.1111/ejn.16672).
Abstract
Anxiety is one of the most common and debilitating mental health disorders, and is related to changes in interoception (perception of bodily states). While anxiety is more prevalent in women than men, gender differences in interoception-anxiety associations are often overlooked. Here, we examined gender-specific relationships between anxiety and interoception in the breathing domain, utilising multicentre data pooled from four study sites (N = 175; 51% women). State anxiety scores were quantified via the Spielberger State–Trait Anxiety Inventory, and breathing-related interoceptive dimensions via an inspiratory load task to quantify sensitivity, decision bias, metacognitive bias (confidence in interoceptive decisions), and metacognitive insight (congruency between performance and confidence). Regression analyses revealed a significant negative relationship between state anxiety and metacognitive bias (β = −0.28; p = 0.01) and insight (β = −0.09; 95% highest density interval [HDI] in a hierarchical Bayesian regression = [−0.18, −0.004]) across the whole sample, while state anxiety did not relate to interoceptive sensitivity nor decision bias. While no mean interoceptive effects relating to gender were observed, the relationship between anxiety and metacognitive insight towards breathing was driven by women (women: β = −0.18; HDI = [−0.31, −0.05]; men: β = 0.02; HDI = [−0.12, 0.15]) with a significant interaction effect (β difference = −0.20; HDI = [−0.37, −0.01]), which did not hold for trait anxiety nor depression measures. In summary, state anxiety was associated with decreased metacognitive bias across all participants, while decreased interoceptive insight was only associated with anxiety in women but not men. Therefore, treatment programmes focusing on interoceptive metacognitive bias may be useful for all anxiety patients, while interoceptive insight might represent a specific treatment target for women with anxiety.
Text
Eur J of Neuroscience - 2025 - Harrison - Gender Differences in the Association Between Anxiety and Interoceptive Insight
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 19 December 2024
Published date: 13 January 2025
Keywords:
breathing, computational psychiatry, insight, interoception, metacognition
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 498272
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/498272
ISSN: 0953-816X
PURE UUID: 4a441f96-da5d-4167-a782-cd09fd8c470f
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 13 Feb 2025 17:40
Last modified: 22 Aug 2025 02:01
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Olivia K. Harrison
Author:
Laura Köchli
Author:
Stephanie Marino
Author:
Lucy Marlow
Author:
Sarah L. Finnegan
Author:
Ben Ainsworth
Author:
Benjamin j. Talks
Author:
Bruce R. Russell
Author:
Samuel j. Harrison
Author:
Kyle T.S. Pattinson
Author:
Stephen M. Fleming
Author:
Klaas E. Stephan
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics