Measuring the effects of COVID-19-related disruption on dengue transmission in southeast Asia and Latin America: a statistical modelling study
Measuring the effects of COVID-19-related disruption on dengue transmission in southeast Asia and Latin America: a statistical modelling study
Background: the COVID-19 pandemic has resulted in unprecedented disruption to society, which indirectly affects infectious disease dynamics. We aimed to assess the effects of COVID-19-related disruption on dengue, a major expanding acute public health threat, in southeast Asia and Latin America.
Methods: we assembled data on monthly dengue incidence from WHO weekly reports, climatic data from ERA5, and population variables from WorldPop for 23 countries between January, 2014 and December, 2019 and fit a Bayesian regression model to explain and predict seasonal and multi-year dengue cycles. We compared model predictions with reported dengue data January to December, 2020, and assessed if deviations from projected incidence since March, 2020 are associated with specific public health and social measures (from the Oxford Coronavirus Government Response Tracer database) or human movement behaviours (as measured by Google mobility reports).
Findings: we found a consistent, prolonged decline in dengue incidence across many dengue-endemic regions that began in March, 2020 (2·28 million cases in 2020 vs 4·08 million cases in 2019; a 44·1% decrease). We found a strong association between COVID-19-related disruption (as measured independently by public health and social measures and human movement behaviours) and reduced dengue risk, even after taking into account other drivers of dengue cycles including climatic and host immunity (relative risk 0·01–0·17, p
657-667
Chen, Yuyang
08e38c4f-83ef-40c0-b173-b591e7a31f4c
Li, Naizhe
e43bce85-890f-48d7-ac92-7439d1db3402
Lourenço, José
d292f004-d459-4da0-9ef5-489a44d6144f
Wang, Lin
82527212-6487-4bb9-85d2-5e186ac79df1
Cazelles, Bernard
fd500deb-8ae9-4ee9-aef9-7c963800699a
Dong, Lu
5e8e0fd1-b1e2-4c48-9601-5acfa959ad8c
Li, Bingying
7c7e8778-959f-40b2-b8cd-b8cfa79f0889
Liu, Yang
ab0553ee-c6fe-4942-9d70-fd2af580646c
Jit, Mark
c99d1e17-a445-4ac7-8b56-ba179ebf5190
Bosse, Nikos I.
3eee16f4-087b-45ee-92c7-b7edcc7db1f3
Abbott, Sam
e8d25152-b481-40b4-b429-82c93d21c26e
Velayudhan, Raman
7ecd70af-4ccf-4cfa-8e59-8d0bf3e1327a
Wilder-Smith, Annelies
766123ae-528e-4532-8679-0bbb8784d263
Tian, Huaiyu
3b949cee-848a-41dd-9270-4e0a5b61f82e
Brady, Oliver J.
2acbd374-26d3-4e56-9e19-558eef1d4f9b
Procter, Simon R.
ac6bc704-455f-4801-afe5-4a01b6475e95
Wong, Kerry LM
9e3df502-e2c6-429f-ab71-310baf9911a2
Hellewell, Joel
e2203422-4e86-4de4-8768-55e969275030
Davies, Nicholas G.
25184305-5278-41d4-9654-8da0ca1cf51d
Jarvis, Christopher I.
c8c1f5a6-e077-4d0e-b79f-d12e21bac3c0
McCarthy, Ciara V.
6c1cab5b-e570-401c-9ede-869384d5f4e4
Medley, Graham
6cb3010d-7d2b-4bc9-b8c1-b4d9ce031372
Meakin, Sophie R.
a9a0d844-d609-461a-ad1b-be906ae338e3
Rosello, Alicia
18be3a96-acab-4888-900f-ef3865226340
Finch, Emilie
178db10b-0dca-43f8-bc47-1b0156adf9ab
Lowe, Rachel
8b9eb87e-6ef9-452c-b5dc-650cc467da12
Pearson, Carl A.B.
b9f67ec0-ab59-4537-9aa5-45eb62f8e523
Clifford, Samuel
fa51f8cb-b11b-4099-a994-2a0c96eb1e0f
Quilty, Billy J.
7fc8c6b4-2740-45d6-96b1-70a0553cf339
Flasche, Stefan
3499af0a-c722-4ae2-90ba-4ce6401389f5
Gibbs, Hamish P.
a7c68116-c71c-4df2-87c3-2f209f1f203e
Chapman, Lloyd A.C.
4c7ad8dd-ae52-4c1e-bb49-f1f49b6e460d
Atkins, Katherine E.
e396359b-6346-44fc-be90-41824d4050ea
Hodgson, David
66bdbcf1-7c85-4d1c-90bc-af5381fbbe01
Barnard, Rosanna C.
e2d26b50-3e89-4970-917b-86be72ab922e
Russell, Timothy W.
461139c6-6cb1-4289-8aba-7f09f1bd6c0a
Klepac, Petra
c0c57afb-f2f5-4675-a18b-e5a0d5ee0c7b
Jafari, Yalda
54e9870d-ba49-49ce-a9b7-0d0e19708f14
Eggo, Rosalind M.
150c61b4-762d-4356-9924-1cdb75126db6
Mee, Paul
6bd96e3d-8560-4c55-9f32-5326c32c16e6
Quaife, Matthew
f6139761-9d82-4a81-b2ef-e750977ab8f4
Endo, Akira
24b58000-1eff-4fa8-a64a-b3cd9a727314
Funk, Sebastian
99328474-b245-47ab-8bc1-d2854032a577
Hué, Stéphane
49f3897a-9fba-4693-a216-09307eaa718f
Kucharski, Adam J.
19975425-144e-4e68-9bcd-25e50cc7ad31
Edmunds, W. John
478db96b-7b72-416e-82b1-6ce9f0f8c8c2
O'Reilly, Kathleen
0f4bb69e-a3b2-4055-93e8-bf7b4cd50da9
Pung, Rachael
ce2d32be-f67b-412c-bf9b-1b275472b2a4
Waites, William
a069e5ff-f440-4b89-ae81-3b58c2ae2afd
CMMID COVID-19 Working Group
20 April 2022
Chen, Yuyang
08e38c4f-83ef-40c0-b173-b591e7a31f4c
Li, Naizhe
e43bce85-890f-48d7-ac92-7439d1db3402
Lourenço, José
d292f004-d459-4da0-9ef5-489a44d6144f
Wang, Lin
82527212-6487-4bb9-85d2-5e186ac79df1
Cazelles, Bernard
fd500deb-8ae9-4ee9-aef9-7c963800699a
Dong, Lu
5e8e0fd1-b1e2-4c48-9601-5acfa959ad8c
Li, Bingying
7c7e8778-959f-40b2-b8cd-b8cfa79f0889
Liu, Yang
ab0553ee-c6fe-4942-9d70-fd2af580646c
Jit, Mark
c99d1e17-a445-4ac7-8b56-ba179ebf5190
Bosse, Nikos I.
3eee16f4-087b-45ee-92c7-b7edcc7db1f3
Abbott, Sam
e8d25152-b481-40b4-b429-82c93d21c26e
Velayudhan, Raman
7ecd70af-4ccf-4cfa-8e59-8d0bf3e1327a
Wilder-Smith, Annelies
766123ae-528e-4532-8679-0bbb8784d263
Tian, Huaiyu
3b949cee-848a-41dd-9270-4e0a5b61f82e
Brady, Oliver J.
2acbd374-26d3-4e56-9e19-558eef1d4f9b
Procter, Simon R.
ac6bc704-455f-4801-afe5-4a01b6475e95
Wong, Kerry LM
9e3df502-e2c6-429f-ab71-310baf9911a2
Hellewell, Joel
e2203422-4e86-4de4-8768-55e969275030
Davies, Nicholas G.
25184305-5278-41d4-9654-8da0ca1cf51d
Jarvis, Christopher I.
c8c1f5a6-e077-4d0e-b79f-d12e21bac3c0
McCarthy, Ciara V.
6c1cab5b-e570-401c-9ede-869384d5f4e4
Medley, Graham
6cb3010d-7d2b-4bc9-b8c1-b4d9ce031372
Meakin, Sophie R.
a9a0d844-d609-461a-ad1b-be906ae338e3
Rosello, Alicia
18be3a96-acab-4888-900f-ef3865226340
Finch, Emilie
178db10b-0dca-43f8-bc47-1b0156adf9ab
Lowe, Rachel
8b9eb87e-6ef9-452c-b5dc-650cc467da12
Pearson, Carl A.B.
b9f67ec0-ab59-4537-9aa5-45eb62f8e523
Clifford, Samuel
fa51f8cb-b11b-4099-a994-2a0c96eb1e0f
Quilty, Billy J.
7fc8c6b4-2740-45d6-96b1-70a0553cf339
Flasche, Stefan
3499af0a-c722-4ae2-90ba-4ce6401389f5
Gibbs, Hamish P.
a7c68116-c71c-4df2-87c3-2f209f1f203e
Chapman, Lloyd A.C.
4c7ad8dd-ae52-4c1e-bb49-f1f49b6e460d
Atkins, Katherine E.
e396359b-6346-44fc-be90-41824d4050ea
Hodgson, David
66bdbcf1-7c85-4d1c-90bc-af5381fbbe01
Barnard, Rosanna C.
e2d26b50-3e89-4970-917b-86be72ab922e
Russell, Timothy W.
461139c6-6cb1-4289-8aba-7f09f1bd6c0a
Klepac, Petra
c0c57afb-f2f5-4675-a18b-e5a0d5ee0c7b
Jafari, Yalda
54e9870d-ba49-49ce-a9b7-0d0e19708f14
Eggo, Rosalind M.
150c61b4-762d-4356-9924-1cdb75126db6
Mee, Paul
6bd96e3d-8560-4c55-9f32-5326c32c16e6
Quaife, Matthew
f6139761-9d82-4a81-b2ef-e750977ab8f4
Endo, Akira
24b58000-1eff-4fa8-a64a-b3cd9a727314
Funk, Sebastian
99328474-b245-47ab-8bc1-d2854032a577
Hué, Stéphane
49f3897a-9fba-4693-a216-09307eaa718f
Kucharski, Adam J.
19975425-144e-4e68-9bcd-25e50cc7ad31
Edmunds, W. John
478db96b-7b72-416e-82b1-6ce9f0f8c8c2
O'Reilly, Kathleen
0f4bb69e-a3b2-4055-93e8-bf7b4cd50da9
Pung, Rachael
ce2d32be-f67b-412c-bf9b-1b275472b2a4
Waites, William
a069e5ff-f440-4b89-ae81-3b58c2ae2afd