The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

The physical origin of extreme emission line galaxies at high redshifts: strong [OIII] emission lines produced by obscured AGNs

The physical origin of extreme emission line galaxies at high redshifts: strong [OIII] emission lines produced by obscured AGNs
The physical origin of extreme emission line galaxies at high redshifts: strong [OIII] emission lines produced by obscured AGNs
We present deep Subaru/FOCAS spectra for two extreme emission line galaxies (EELGs) at z ∼ 1 with strong[O III] λ5007 emission lines, exhibiting equivalent widths (EWs) of -+ 2905 578946 Å and -+ 2000 159188 Å, comparable tothose of EELGs at high redshifts that are now routinely identified with JWST spectroscopy. Adding a similarlylarge [O III] EW ( -+ 2508 6891487 Å) EELG found at z ∼ 2 in the JWST CEERS survey to our sample, we explore thephysical origins of the large [O III] EWs of these three galaxies with the Subaru spectra and various public dataincluding JWST/NIRSpec, NIRCam, and MIRI data. While there are no clear signatures of active galactic nuclei(AGNs) identified by the optical line diagnostics, we find that two out of two galaxies covered by the MIRI datashow strong near-infrared excess in the spectral energy distributions (SEDs), indicating obscured AGNs. Becausenone of the three galaxies show clear broad Hβ lines, the upper limits on the flux ratios of broad Hβ to [O III] linesare small, 0.15 that are comparable with Seyfert 1.8–2.0 galaxies. We conduct Cloudy modeling with the stellarand AGN incident spectra, allowing a wide range of parameters, including metallicities and ionization parameters.We find that the large [O III] EWs are not self-consistently reproduced by the spectra of stars or unobscured AGNs,but obscured AGNs that efficiently produce O++ ionizing photons with weak nuclear and stellar continua that areconsistent with the SED shapes.
astro-ph.GA
1538-4357
Zhu, Chenghao
36742c9d-1df5-4f7b-9868-82bd1a4c63be
Harikane, Yuichi
db05f5ce-f0b1-49a3-9ca6-2e1685836291
Ouchi, Masami
35f08cb2-64d1-4bf6-8668-21ef495de8a9
Ono, Yoshiaki
8ab19251-dbb9-4681-ba1b-008516ef0a25
Onodera, Masato
ebc6175d-8036-47ae-b9af-8a1189d39df6
Tang, Shenli
bf5e61b2-648a-46a7-a45e-7ce79c411259
Isobe, Yuki
b100a97a-0ff9-4fea-97d2-3c3fffa5fa4d
Matsuoka, Yoshiki
1522809a-dfe4-44ca-8678-085c63f6d586
Kawaguchi, Toshihiro
7ee2dd88-687c-4b23-b3dc-c3309957b5d5
Umeda, Hiroya
672d7ec6-d082-482c-9312-d667ca6d7432
Nakajima, Kimihiko
f612154e-0874-493e-949b-f6759e953d1d
Liang, Yongming
2e19dc1c-d292-44a5-acce-5e8cadfccf42
Xu, Yi
2981c7dc-5bfd-43ea-9a73-4d44d79d3951
Zhang, Yechi
800ae9cd-1f1d-41a0-84e4-cc90dd963699
Sun, Dongsheng
688d4277-287e-4606-be5d-28a9c285205a
Shimasaku, Kazuhiro
b76d7bbc-d294-44e9-a0fa-de3e904c4109
Greene, Jenny
ec2cb383-2ce8-49f0-9350-455c886e585b
Iwasawa, Kazushi
8464ef6d-f4ec-4d40-bcc8-d26db6b90020
Kohno, Kotaro
54423e47-4918-4fed-9319-67676098af68
Nagao, Tohru
51810782-2947-46a8-860c-0787cb722689
Schulze, Andreas
26067632-cd16-405d-991a-41080510005e
Shibuya, Takatoshi
13dedcad-8271-435c-8cb6-52aee4401d1b
Hilmi, Miftahul
778a99bb-7f69-44c0-a44c-654c7399f8a6
Schramm, Malte
b087c973-8762-4eb0-9331-a92908a89489
et al.
Zhu, Chenghao
36742c9d-1df5-4f7b-9868-82bd1a4c63be
Harikane, Yuichi
db05f5ce-f0b1-49a3-9ca6-2e1685836291
Ouchi, Masami
35f08cb2-64d1-4bf6-8668-21ef495de8a9
Ono, Yoshiaki
8ab19251-dbb9-4681-ba1b-008516ef0a25
Onodera, Masato
ebc6175d-8036-47ae-b9af-8a1189d39df6
Tang, Shenli
bf5e61b2-648a-46a7-a45e-7ce79c411259
Isobe, Yuki
b100a97a-0ff9-4fea-97d2-3c3fffa5fa4d
Matsuoka, Yoshiki
1522809a-dfe4-44ca-8678-085c63f6d586
Kawaguchi, Toshihiro
7ee2dd88-687c-4b23-b3dc-c3309957b5d5
Umeda, Hiroya
672d7ec6-d082-482c-9312-d667ca6d7432
Nakajima, Kimihiko
f612154e-0874-493e-949b-f6759e953d1d
Liang, Yongming
2e19dc1c-d292-44a5-acce-5e8cadfccf42
Xu, Yi
2981c7dc-5bfd-43ea-9a73-4d44d79d3951
Zhang, Yechi
800ae9cd-1f1d-41a0-84e4-cc90dd963699
Sun, Dongsheng
688d4277-287e-4606-be5d-28a9c285205a
Shimasaku, Kazuhiro
b76d7bbc-d294-44e9-a0fa-de3e904c4109
Greene, Jenny
ec2cb383-2ce8-49f0-9350-455c886e585b
Iwasawa, Kazushi
8464ef6d-f4ec-4d40-bcc8-d26db6b90020
Kohno, Kotaro
54423e47-4918-4fed-9319-67676098af68
Nagao, Tohru
51810782-2947-46a8-860c-0787cb722689
Schulze, Andreas
26067632-cd16-405d-991a-41080510005e
Shibuya, Takatoshi
13dedcad-8271-435c-8cb6-52aee4401d1b
Hilmi, Miftahul
778a99bb-7f69-44c0-a44c-654c7399f8a6
Schramm, Malte
b087c973-8762-4eb0-9331-a92908a89489

Zhu, Chenghao, Harikane, Yuichi and Ouchi, Masami , et al. (2025) The physical origin of extreme emission line galaxies at high redshifts: strong [OIII] emission lines produced by obscured AGNs. The Astrophysical Journal, 982 (1), [27]. (doi:10.3847/1538-4357/adaf1b).

Record type: Article

Abstract

We present deep Subaru/FOCAS spectra for two extreme emission line galaxies (EELGs) at z ∼ 1 with strong[O III] λ5007 emission lines, exhibiting equivalent widths (EWs) of -+ 2905 578946 Å and -+ 2000 159188 Å, comparable tothose of EELGs at high redshifts that are now routinely identified with JWST spectroscopy. Adding a similarlylarge [O III] EW ( -+ 2508 6891487 Å) EELG found at z ∼ 2 in the JWST CEERS survey to our sample, we explore thephysical origins of the large [O III] EWs of these three galaxies with the Subaru spectra and various public dataincluding JWST/NIRSpec, NIRCam, and MIRI data. While there are no clear signatures of active galactic nuclei(AGNs) identified by the optical line diagnostics, we find that two out of two galaxies covered by the MIRI datashow strong near-infrared excess in the spectral energy distributions (SEDs), indicating obscured AGNs. Becausenone of the three galaxies show clear broad Hβ lines, the upper limits on the flux ratios of broad Hβ to [O III] linesare small, 0.15 that are comparable with Seyfert 1.8–2.0 galaxies. We conduct Cloudy modeling with the stellarand AGN incident spectra, allowing a wide range of parameters, including metallicities and ionization parameters.We find that the large [O III] EWs are not self-consistently reproduced by the spectra of stars or unobscured AGNs,but obscured AGNs that efficiently produce O++ ionizing photons with weak nuclear and stellar continua that areconsistent with the SED shapes.

Text
2410.12198v2 - Author's Original
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (2MB)
Text
Zhu_2025_ApJ_982_27 - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (1MB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 26 January 2024
Published date: 12 March 2025
Keywords: astro-ph.GA

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 501056
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/501056
ISSN: 1538-4357
PURE UUID: 089a0923-7eba-4be7-b78f-7f2a1739ea92

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 21 May 2025 16:46
Last modified: 29 Aug 2025 16:57

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Chenghao Zhu
Author: Yuichi Harikane
Author: Masami Ouchi
Author: Yoshiaki Ono
Author: Masato Onodera
Author: Shenli Tang
Author: Yuki Isobe
Author: Yoshiki Matsuoka
Author: Toshihiro Kawaguchi
Author: Hiroya Umeda
Author: Kimihiko Nakajima
Author: Yongming Liang
Author: Yi Xu
Author: Yechi Zhang
Author: Dongsheng Sun
Author: Kazuhiro Shimasaku
Author: Jenny Greene
Author: Kazushi Iwasawa
Author: Kotaro Kohno
Author: Tohru Nagao
Author: Andreas Schulze
Author: Takatoshi Shibuya
Author: Miftahul Hilmi
Author: Malte Schramm
Corporate Author: et al.

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×