When confidence in institutions backfires: Power-distance orientation moderates the relationship between institutional trust and civic honesty across eight countries.
When confidence in institutions backfires: Power-distance orientation moderates the relationship between institutional trust and civic honesty across eight countries.
Confidence in institutions is a key predictor of civic honesty, yet evidence shows that this relationship varies across contexts and individuals. This study examined whether power-distance orientation (PDO)—the extent to which individuals accept hierarchical power relations—moderates this association. High-PDO individuals tend to view institutional authorities as entitled to privilege,
inclined to engage in patronage relationships and potentially corrupt. We hypothesised that for individuals high in PDO, confidence in institutions could backfire and be linked to the rejection of civic honesty. Using data from 2088 participants across eight countries, we found support for this hypothesis. Specifically, the positive link between institutional confidence and civic
honesty was reversed among those who strongly endorse PDO. These findings suggest that individual-level variation in the link between confidence in institutions and civic honesty partly reflects broader beliefs about authorities. We discuss implications of this interaction and outline directions for future research.
civic honesty, confidence in institutions, corruption, power-distance orientation
D'Ottone, Silvana
d0edcde5-8b44-4adf-9d74-d28785de48f2
Travaglino, Giovanni
674d67be-b42f-48b6-9b37-93795c167eec
Burgmer, Pascal
c8c43b56-572c-4242-800c-9f44ff648cec
Giammusso, Isabella
a73ac92e-6ddc-4a1f-a85f-c18a8306e55f
Imada, Hirotaka
74ad2bed-1dad-4826-b5fc-9e41f843d7d3
Mao, Yanhui
7c9410d3-ffae-40bd-a774-c021917b499b
Mirisola, Alberto
2b67cb34-1376-4fa8-8688-907e6354a329
Moon, Chanki
7650fda7-16b5-4697-a7b0-e2d975d87985
Nawata, Kengo
d3f9c5d2-7fda-46fa-ba7b-c0e0f8f112fe
Ozeki, Miki
d806f91b-7a16-4f8d-b44f-65732b7318f2
August 2025
D'Ottone, Silvana
d0edcde5-8b44-4adf-9d74-d28785de48f2
Travaglino, Giovanni
674d67be-b42f-48b6-9b37-93795c167eec
Burgmer, Pascal
c8c43b56-572c-4242-800c-9f44ff648cec
Giammusso, Isabella
a73ac92e-6ddc-4a1f-a85f-c18a8306e55f
Imada, Hirotaka
74ad2bed-1dad-4826-b5fc-9e41f843d7d3
Mao, Yanhui
7c9410d3-ffae-40bd-a774-c021917b499b
Mirisola, Alberto
2b67cb34-1376-4fa8-8688-907e6354a329
Moon, Chanki
7650fda7-16b5-4697-a7b0-e2d975d87985
Nawata, Kengo
d3f9c5d2-7fda-46fa-ba7b-c0e0f8f112fe
Ozeki, Miki
d806f91b-7a16-4f8d-b44f-65732b7318f2
D'Ottone, Silvana, Travaglino, Giovanni, Burgmer, Pascal, Giammusso, Isabella, Imada, Hirotaka, Mao, Yanhui, Mirisola, Alberto, Moon, Chanki, Nawata, Kengo and Ozeki, Miki
(2025)
When confidence in institutions backfires: Power-distance orientation moderates the relationship between institutional trust and civic honesty across eight countries.
International Journal of Psychology, 60 (4), [e70059].
(doi:10.1002/ijop.70059).
Abstract
Confidence in institutions is a key predictor of civic honesty, yet evidence shows that this relationship varies across contexts and individuals. This study examined whether power-distance orientation (PDO)—the extent to which individuals accept hierarchical power relations—moderates this association. High-PDO individuals tend to view institutional authorities as entitled to privilege,
inclined to engage in patronage relationships and potentially corrupt. We hypothesised that for individuals high in PDO, confidence in institutions could backfire and be linked to the rejection of civic honesty. Using data from 2088 participants across eight countries, we found support for this hypothesis. Specifically, the positive link between institutional confidence and civic
honesty was reversed among those who strongly endorse PDO. These findings suggest that individual-level variation in the link between confidence in institutions and civic honesty partly reflects broader beliefs about authorities. We discuss implications of this interaction and outline directions for future research.
Text
D’Ottone et al. (2025, IJP) - When Confidence in Institutions Backfires
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 20 May 2025
e-pub ahead of print date: 28 May 2025
Published date: August 2025
Keywords:
civic honesty, confidence in institutions, corruption, power-distance orientation
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 501621
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/501621
ISSN: 0020-7594
PURE UUID: a7d5c8ac-d0af-41d9-9921-ce4c5f152941
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 04 Jun 2025 16:55
Last modified: 02 Sep 2025 17:01
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Silvana D'Ottone
Author:
Giovanni Travaglino
Author:
Pascal Burgmer
Author:
Isabella Giammusso
Author:
Hirotaka Imada
Author:
Yanhui Mao
Author:
Alberto Mirisola
Author:
Chanki Moon
Author:
Kengo Nawata
Author:
Miki Ozeki
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics