Natural induction: spontaneous adaptive organisation without natural selection
Natural induction: spontaneous adaptive organisation without natural selection
Evolution by natural selection is believed to be the only possible source of spontaneous adaptive organisation in the natural world. This places strict limits on the kinds of systems that can exhibit adaptation spontaneously, i.e., without design. Physical systems can show some properties relevant to adaptation without natural selection or design. (1) The relaxation, or local energy minimisation, of a physical system constitutes a natural form of optimisation insomuch as it finds locally optimal solutions to the frustrated forces acting on it or between its components. (2) When internal structure 'gives way' or accommodates a pattern of forcing on a system, this constitutes learning insomuch, as it can store, recall, and generalise past configurations. Both these effects are quite natural and general, but in themselves insufficient to constitute non-trivial adaptation. However, here we show that the recurrent interaction of physical optimisation and physical learning together results in significant spontaneous adaptive organisation. We call this adaptation by natural induction. The effect occurs in dynamical systems described by a network of viscoelastic connections subject to occasional disturbances. When the internal structure of such a system accommodates slowly across many disturbances and relaxations, it spontaneously learns to preferentially visit solutions of increasingly greater quality (exceptionally low energy). We show that adaptation by natural induction thus produces network organisations that improve problem-solving competency with experience (without supervised training or system-level reward). We note that the conditions for adaptation by natural induction, and its adaptive competency, are different from those of natural selection. We therefore suggest that natural selection is not the only possible source of spontaneous adaptive organisation in the natural world.
Buckley, Christopher L.
9e178676-0a7f-4351-94b8-2583a7090c95
Lewens, Tim
705e05b8-5803-4f0c-a2ab-c98f1492dd61
Levin, Michael
6d5972ec-9c46-4603-b7e0-c811137f69ed
Millidge, Beren
285f41d6-d46d-4495-a780-95ec92f23cd1
Tschantz, Alexander
e6499b82-4dd2-42b1-96c6-324fc5f9ff3e
Watson, Richard A.
ce199dfc-d5d4-4edf-bd7b-f9e224c96c75
6 September 2024
Buckley, Christopher L.
9e178676-0a7f-4351-94b8-2583a7090c95
Lewens, Tim
705e05b8-5803-4f0c-a2ab-c98f1492dd61
Levin, Michael
6d5972ec-9c46-4603-b7e0-c811137f69ed
Millidge, Beren
285f41d6-d46d-4495-a780-95ec92f23cd1
Tschantz, Alexander
e6499b82-4dd2-42b1-96c6-324fc5f9ff3e
Watson, Richard A.
ce199dfc-d5d4-4edf-bd7b-f9e224c96c75
Buckley, Christopher L., Lewens, Tim, Levin, Michael, Millidge, Beren, Tschantz, Alexander and Watson, Richard A.
(2024)
Natural induction: spontaneous adaptive organisation without natural selection.
Entropy, 26 (9), [765].
(doi:10.3390/e26090765).
Abstract
Evolution by natural selection is believed to be the only possible source of spontaneous adaptive organisation in the natural world. This places strict limits on the kinds of systems that can exhibit adaptation spontaneously, i.e., without design. Physical systems can show some properties relevant to adaptation without natural selection or design. (1) The relaxation, or local energy minimisation, of a physical system constitutes a natural form of optimisation insomuch as it finds locally optimal solutions to the frustrated forces acting on it or between its components. (2) When internal structure 'gives way' or accommodates a pattern of forcing on a system, this constitutes learning insomuch, as it can store, recall, and generalise past configurations. Both these effects are quite natural and general, but in themselves insufficient to constitute non-trivial adaptation. However, here we show that the recurrent interaction of physical optimisation and physical learning together results in significant spontaneous adaptive organisation. We call this adaptation by natural induction. The effect occurs in dynamical systems described by a network of viscoelastic connections subject to occasional disturbances. When the internal structure of such a system accommodates slowly across many disturbances and relaxations, it spontaneously learns to preferentially visit solutions of increasingly greater quality (exceptionally low energy). We show that adaptation by natural induction thus produces network organisations that improve problem-solving competency with experience (without supervised training or system-level reward). We note that the conditions for adaptation by natural induction, and its adaptive competency, are different from those of natural selection. We therefore suggest that natural selection is not the only possible source of spontaneous adaptive organisation in the natural world.
Text
entropy-26-00765-v2
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 27 August 2024
Published date: 6 September 2024
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 502119
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/502119
ISSN: 1099-4300
PURE UUID: f2a92d2e-35ab-4c87-8fae-6546dcda6d2b
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 17 Jun 2025 16:33
Last modified: 22 Aug 2025 01:53
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Christopher L. Buckley
Author:
Tim Lewens
Author:
Michael Levin
Author:
Beren Millidge
Author:
Alexander Tschantz
Author:
Richard A. Watson
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics