The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Long-term impact and biological recovery in a deep-sea mining track

Long-term impact and biological recovery in a deep-sea mining track
Long-term impact and biological recovery in a deep-sea mining track

Deep-sea polymetallic nodule mining is in the exploration phase at present with some groups proposing a move towards extraction within years1. Management of this industry requires evidence of the long-term effects on deep-sea ecosystems2, but the ability of seafloor ecosystems to recover from impacts over decadal scales is poorly understood3. Here we show that, four decades after a test mining experiment that removed nodules, the biological impacts in many groups of organisms are persistent, although populations of several organisms, including sediment macrofauna, mobile deposit feeders and even large-sized sessile fauna, have begun to re-establish despite persistent physical changes at the seafloor. We also reveal that areas affected by plumes from this small-scale test have limited detectable residual sedimentation impacts with some biological assemblages similar in abundance compared to control areas after 44 years. Although some aspects of the modern collector design may cause reduced physical impact compared to this test mining experiment, our results show that mining impacts in the abyssal ocean will be persistent over at least decadal timeframes and communities will remain altered in directly disturbed areas, despite some recolonization. The long-term effects seen in our study provide critical data for effective management of mining activities, if they occur, including minimizing direct impacts and setting aside an effective network of protected areas4,5.

0028-0836
112-118
Jones, Daniel O.B.
44fc07b3-5fb7-4bf5-9cec-78c78022613a
Arias, Maria Belen
edef423c-c0e7-4ec2-9c15-3f7182e95fdd
Van Audenhaege, Loïc
df223178-8175-4741-a673-aecf9fe976dc
Blackbird, Sabena
7d07eab9-5745-4697-920e-de1ea0e972c0
Boolukos, Corie
d7f751c1-7d5b-498e-86b0-2b1918996dc8
Bribiesca-Contreras, Guadalupe
feb06280-2c3f-44de-a356-19e8de31e533
Copley, Jonathan T.
5f30e2a6-76c1-4150-9a42-dcfb8f5788ef
Dale, Andrew
e0a3502b-170c-4d93-a92e-6053287269a6
Evans, Susan
3dd365b3-ef39-41fa-97a5-6fb16ed2e040
Fleming, Bethany F.M.
d5a5c1de-ec0b-4bcd-9a30-f6fe8fd3ac26
Gates, Andrew R.
327a3cc6-2e53-4090-9f96-219461087be9
Grant, Hannah
6d196568-3621-45b2-b324-5b556fac902c
Hartl, Mark G.J.
808e6ded-5052-4c69-bc06-a7426cbcf7a1
Huvenne, Veerle A.I.
f22be3e2-708c-491b-b985-a438470fa053
Jeffreys, Rachel M.
00be4640-1d07-4f82-964a-0a61b50322c4
Josso, Pierre
7da4acf5-b481-49df-931e-160d4ed199e5
King, Lucas D.
999dc66c-5b74-42ca-aac2-d8b8ca4cd819
Simon-Lledó, Erik
80f67b3a-44e7-466e-aed5-06b0ba788ca2
Le Bas, Tim
4128286d-8730-4ee8-ba45-2d55b3962701
Norman, Louisa
c1f09347-fd75-4554-8d83-f3711afc2a14
O’Malley, Bryan
a1799b66-2cc0-4647-8b6f-59017600f95d
Peacock, Thomas
6d419f35-7424-4ee5-98db-f5a7c19a6b2e
Shimmield, Tracy
0ac1d79b-d334-4db7-97e5-d9d7f15a6902
Stewart, Eva C.D.
e33676c3-5ece-406b-91fd-dbd65912079d
Sweetman, Andrew K.
5304cde0-8e83-4a68-8249-fa2d9e70d8bb
Wardell, Catherine
ebf797ae-291e-4db9-90aa-e686097d8c18
Aleynik, Dmitry
07ad3616-ffc3-4631-a8c4-660587594635
Glover, Adrian G.
a89301ae-be5d-4d66-a537-a1b3b7274bde
Jones, Daniel O.B.
44fc07b3-5fb7-4bf5-9cec-78c78022613a
Arias, Maria Belen
edef423c-c0e7-4ec2-9c15-3f7182e95fdd
Van Audenhaege, Loïc
df223178-8175-4741-a673-aecf9fe976dc
Blackbird, Sabena
7d07eab9-5745-4697-920e-de1ea0e972c0
Boolukos, Corie
d7f751c1-7d5b-498e-86b0-2b1918996dc8
Bribiesca-Contreras, Guadalupe
feb06280-2c3f-44de-a356-19e8de31e533
Copley, Jonathan T.
5f30e2a6-76c1-4150-9a42-dcfb8f5788ef
Dale, Andrew
e0a3502b-170c-4d93-a92e-6053287269a6
Evans, Susan
3dd365b3-ef39-41fa-97a5-6fb16ed2e040
Fleming, Bethany F.M.
d5a5c1de-ec0b-4bcd-9a30-f6fe8fd3ac26
Gates, Andrew R.
327a3cc6-2e53-4090-9f96-219461087be9
Grant, Hannah
6d196568-3621-45b2-b324-5b556fac902c
Hartl, Mark G.J.
808e6ded-5052-4c69-bc06-a7426cbcf7a1
Huvenne, Veerle A.I.
f22be3e2-708c-491b-b985-a438470fa053
Jeffreys, Rachel M.
00be4640-1d07-4f82-964a-0a61b50322c4
Josso, Pierre
7da4acf5-b481-49df-931e-160d4ed199e5
King, Lucas D.
999dc66c-5b74-42ca-aac2-d8b8ca4cd819
Simon-Lledó, Erik
80f67b3a-44e7-466e-aed5-06b0ba788ca2
Le Bas, Tim
4128286d-8730-4ee8-ba45-2d55b3962701
Norman, Louisa
c1f09347-fd75-4554-8d83-f3711afc2a14
O’Malley, Bryan
a1799b66-2cc0-4647-8b6f-59017600f95d
Peacock, Thomas
6d419f35-7424-4ee5-98db-f5a7c19a6b2e
Shimmield, Tracy
0ac1d79b-d334-4db7-97e5-d9d7f15a6902
Stewart, Eva C.D.
e33676c3-5ece-406b-91fd-dbd65912079d
Sweetman, Andrew K.
5304cde0-8e83-4a68-8249-fa2d9e70d8bb
Wardell, Catherine
ebf797ae-291e-4db9-90aa-e686097d8c18
Aleynik, Dmitry
07ad3616-ffc3-4631-a8c4-660587594635
Glover, Adrian G.
a89301ae-be5d-4d66-a537-a1b3b7274bde

Jones, Daniel O.B., Arias, Maria Belen, Van Audenhaege, Loïc, Blackbird, Sabena, Boolukos, Corie, Bribiesca-Contreras, Guadalupe, Copley, Jonathan T., Dale, Andrew, Evans, Susan, Fleming, Bethany F.M., Gates, Andrew R., Grant, Hannah, Hartl, Mark G.J., Huvenne, Veerle A.I., Jeffreys, Rachel M., Josso, Pierre, King, Lucas D., Simon-Lledó, Erik, Le Bas, Tim, Norman, Louisa, O’Malley, Bryan, Peacock, Thomas, Shimmield, Tracy, Stewart, Eva C.D., Sweetman, Andrew K., Wardell, Catherine, Aleynik, Dmitry and Glover, Adrian G. (2025) Long-term impact and biological recovery in a deep-sea mining track. Nature, 642 (8066), 112-118, [26808]. (doi:10.1038/s41586-025-08921-3).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Deep-sea polymetallic nodule mining is in the exploration phase at present with some groups proposing a move towards extraction within years1. Management of this industry requires evidence of the long-term effects on deep-sea ecosystems2, but the ability of seafloor ecosystems to recover from impacts over decadal scales is poorly understood3. Here we show that, four decades after a test mining experiment that removed nodules, the biological impacts in many groups of organisms are persistent, although populations of several organisms, including sediment macrofauna, mobile deposit feeders and even large-sized sessile fauna, have begun to re-establish despite persistent physical changes at the seafloor. We also reveal that areas affected by plumes from this small-scale test have limited detectable residual sedimentation impacts with some biological assemblages similar in abundance compared to control areas after 44 years. Although some aspects of the modern collector design may cause reduced physical impact compared to this test mining experiment, our results show that mining impacts in the abyssal ocean will be persistent over at least decadal timeframes and communities will remain altered in directly disturbed areas, despite some recolonization. The long-term effects seen in our study provide critical data for effective management of mining activities, if they occur, including minimizing direct impacts and setting aside an effective network of protected areas4,5.

Text
s41586-025-08921-3 - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (37MB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 20 March 2025
Published date: 26 March 2025

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 502785
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/502785
ISSN: 0028-0836
PURE UUID: 701dfdc9-d404-41b0-9885-93a6dae27137
ORCID for Jonathan T. Copley: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0003-3333-4325
ORCID for Veerle A.I. Huvenne: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0001-7135-6360
ORCID for Eva C.D. Stewart: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0001-8383-5705

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 08 Jul 2025 16:43
Last modified: 22 Aug 2025 02:32

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Daniel O.B. Jones
Author: Maria Belen Arias
Author: Loïc Van Audenhaege
Author: Sabena Blackbird
Author: Corie Boolukos
Author: Guadalupe Bribiesca-Contreras
Author: Andrew Dale
Author: Susan Evans
Author: Andrew R. Gates
Author: Hannah Grant
Author: Mark G.J. Hartl
Author: Veerle A.I. Huvenne ORCID iD
Author: Rachel M. Jeffreys
Author: Pierre Josso
Author: Lucas D. King
Author: Erik Simon-Lledó
Author: Tim Le Bas
Author: Louisa Norman
Author: Bryan O’Malley
Author: Thomas Peacock
Author: Tracy Shimmield
Author: Andrew K. Sweetman
Author: Catherine Wardell
Author: Dmitry Aleynik
Author: Adrian G. Glover

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×