No such thing as a free lunch?
No such thing as a free lunch?
BACKGROUND: High-quality, out-of-classroom interactions between students and teachers help to develop communities of learning. In medicine, they contribute to the professionalisation of students.
METHODS: We designed a novel student-faculty member lunch scheme for first-year medical students at our institution. Students received a free lunch in groups of six with a faculty member 'hosting' and paying for lunch, with the cost reimbursed by the medical school. Focus groups with students were used to evaluate the impact of the intervention.
RESULTS: Approximately half of all Year-1 students signed up for the scheme (n = 153). Twenty faculty members hosted one or more lunches. Focus group analysis revealed that attendees felt more positively about individual faculty members and the institution as a result of participation, and that it helped the process of induction and transition into medical school, but that it suffered from a lack of continuing contact. Out-of-classroom interactions between students and teachers help to develop communities of learning CONCLUSIONS: This intervention encouraged positive student-faculty member interactions, albeit with a relatively small group of students. It did not seem to encourage longitudinal staff-student relationships, however, which is a key limitation.
Faculty, Medical/psychology, Focus Groups, Humans, Interpersonal Relations, Learning, Lunch, Mentors, Qualitative Research, Students, Medical/psychology
138-141
McKechnie, Douglas G J
769d65ce-f47e-45ad-92f5-9ef3823f0703
Shashidhara, Anush
19883ad0-9016-46a1-b74b-b12943bb04e3
Houston, Pam
e536f8f2-5972-496e-a470-36f779caa04a
Gill, Deborah
7efe669f-45e8-45d3-ab30-8717653353ca
Dilworth, Paul
6b937c56-57fa-46c9-b410-3b7d321c0599
April 2019
McKechnie, Douglas G J
769d65ce-f47e-45ad-92f5-9ef3823f0703
Shashidhara, Anush
19883ad0-9016-46a1-b74b-b12943bb04e3
Houston, Pam
e536f8f2-5972-496e-a470-36f779caa04a
Gill, Deborah
7efe669f-45e8-45d3-ab30-8717653353ca
Dilworth, Paul
6b937c56-57fa-46c9-b410-3b7d321c0599
McKechnie, Douglas G J, Shashidhara, Anush, Houston, Pam, Gill, Deborah and Dilworth, Paul
(2019)
No such thing as a free lunch?
The Clinical Teacher, 16 (2), .
(doi:10.1111/tct.12788).
Abstract
BACKGROUND: High-quality, out-of-classroom interactions between students and teachers help to develop communities of learning. In medicine, they contribute to the professionalisation of students.
METHODS: We designed a novel student-faculty member lunch scheme for first-year medical students at our institution. Students received a free lunch in groups of six with a faculty member 'hosting' and paying for lunch, with the cost reimbursed by the medical school. Focus groups with students were used to evaluate the impact of the intervention.
RESULTS: Approximately half of all Year-1 students signed up for the scheme (n = 153). Twenty faculty members hosted one or more lunches. Focus group analysis revealed that attendees felt more positively about individual faculty members and the institution as a result of participation, and that it helped the process of induction and transition into medical school, but that it suffered from a lack of continuing contact. Out-of-classroom interactions between students and teachers help to develop communities of learning CONCLUSIONS: This intervention encouraged positive student-faculty member interactions, albeit with a relatively small group of students. It did not seem to encourage longitudinal staff-student relationships, however, which is a key limitation.
This record has no associated files available for download.
More information
Published date: April 2019
Additional Information:
© 2018 John Wiley & Sons Ltd and The Association for the Study of Medical Education.
Keywords:
Faculty, Medical/psychology, Focus Groups, Humans, Interpersonal Relations, Learning, Lunch, Mentors, Qualitative Research, Students, Medical/psychology
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 502813
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/502813
ISSN: 1743-4971
PURE UUID: 88cfcd16-4b81-4307-a78f-834bd35b704d
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 08 Jul 2025 16:55
Last modified: 09 Jul 2025 02:04
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Douglas G J McKechnie
Author:
Anush Shashidhara
Author:
Pam Houston
Author:
Deborah Gill
Author:
Paul Dilworth
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics