Crystallizing the ncrystallizable: Insights from extensive screening of PROTACs
Crystallizing the ncrystallizable: Insights from extensive screening of PROTACs
PROTACs are new drug molecules in the beyond Rule of Five (bRo5) chemical space with extremely poor aqueous solubility and intrinsically poor crystallizability due to their structure, which comprises two distinct ligands covalently linked by a flexible linker. This makes PROTACs particularly challenging to understand from a solid-state preformulation perspective. While several X-ray structures have been reported of PROTACs in ternary complexes, to date no structures have been published of single component densely packed PROTACs, from which an understanding of PROTACs’ intermolecular interactions, and therefore physical properties, can be developed. An extensive crystallization protocol was applied to grow single crystals of a cereblon-recruiting PROTAC “AZ1” resulting in structures of an anhydrous form and a nonstoichiometric p-xylene solvate using 3D electron diffraction and synchrotron X-ray crystallography, respectively. The lattice energies are dominated by dispersive interactions between AZ1 molecules despite the presence of multiple hydrogen-bond donors and acceptors and planar aromatic groups, and both structures are built on similar intermolecular interactions. Thermal and spectral characterization revealed another solvate form containing dichloromethane. Amorphous solids produced by mechanochemical grinding of anhydrous AZ1 crystals also differed in dissolution characteristics from an amorphous solid produced by desolvating the dichloromethane solvate crystals, indicating that AZ1 may demonstrate pseudo-polyamorphism. This study paves the way for solid form screening and understanding in pharmaceutical systems that are far bRo5.
Crystal structure, Crystallization, Lattices, Molecular Structure, Molecules
28056–28072
Screen, Martin A.
993868bb-c88d-4ac1-bf76-b7c45431f7c9
McCabe, James F.
03d20b83-18b2-49d3-8d55-0a085c128c2c
Askin, Sean
9bbe839a-cabd-4666-b79a-6e9ef6f7f37d
Guest, Jamie L.
ad4d1508-d030-4074-a714-1b9a0cbbbe0f
Hodgkinson, Paul
0ed9abe1-8365-4a54-b479-abdcc561a59b
Cruz-Cabeza, Aurora J.
6992b540-1934-4172-9655-7fcee52439ba
Blundell, Toby J.
7ee01e4f-c9af-40c9-b17b-dcc9c77b2e7e
Rainer, Daniel N.
ece5513b-0f92-4143-bddd-a4ae2802ae6d
Coles, Simon J.
3116f58b-c30c-48cf-bdd5-397d1c1fecf8
Longcake, Alexandra
4c2c231a-f58c-414b-b906-a640180cf597
Probert, Michael R.
a86a95c0-5692-4e4c-9279-a02faf70274c
Mahon, Clare S.
2a37bf75-0f92-43cd-8525-71adb525c78d
Wilson, Mark R.
cff18872-1ead-4e9f-819f-29617fdfc867
Steed, Jonathan W.
97a5b8f6-b374-454d-a0b4-0bcaf37aa962
23 July 2025
Screen, Martin A.
993868bb-c88d-4ac1-bf76-b7c45431f7c9
McCabe, James F.
03d20b83-18b2-49d3-8d55-0a085c128c2c
Askin, Sean
9bbe839a-cabd-4666-b79a-6e9ef6f7f37d
Guest, Jamie L.
ad4d1508-d030-4074-a714-1b9a0cbbbe0f
Hodgkinson, Paul
0ed9abe1-8365-4a54-b479-abdcc561a59b
Cruz-Cabeza, Aurora J.
6992b540-1934-4172-9655-7fcee52439ba
Blundell, Toby J.
7ee01e4f-c9af-40c9-b17b-dcc9c77b2e7e
Rainer, Daniel N.
ece5513b-0f92-4143-bddd-a4ae2802ae6d
Coles, Simon J.
3116f58b-c30c-48cf-bdd5-397d1c1fecf8
Longcake, Alexandra
4c2c231a-f58c-414b-b906-a640180cf597
Probert, Michael R.
a86a95c0-5692-4e4c-9279-a02faf70274c
Mahon, Clare S.
2a37bf75-0f92-43cd-8525-71adb525c78d
Wilson, Mark R.
cff18872-1ead-4e9f-819f-29617fdfc867
Steed, Jonathan W.
97a5b8f6-b374-454d-a0b4-0bcaf37aa962
Screen, Martin A., McCabe, James F., Askin, Sean, Guest, Jamie L., Hodgkinson, Paul, Cruz-Cabeza, Aurora J., Blundell, Toby J., Rainer, Daniel N., Coles, Simon J., Longcake, Alexandra, Probert, Michael R., Mahon, Clare S., Wilson, Mark R. and Steed, Jonathan W.
(2025)
Crystallizing the ncrystallizable: Insights from extensive screening of PROTACs.
JACS AU, 147 (31), .
(doi:10.1021/jacs.5c07977).
Abstract
PROTACs are new drug molecules in the beyond Rule of Five (bRo5) chemical space with extremely poor aqueous solubility and intrinsically poor crystallizability due to their structure, which comprises two distinct ligands covalently linked by a flexible linker. This makes PROTACs particularly challenging to understand from a solid-state preformulation perspective. While several X-ray structures have been reported of PROTACs in ternary complexes, to date no structures have been published of single component densely packed PROTACs, from which an understanding of PROTACs’ intermolecular interactions, and therefore physical properties, can be developed. An extensive crystallization protocol was applied to grow single crystals of a cereblon-recruiting PROTAC “AZ1” resulting in structures of an anhydrous form and a nonstoichiometric p-xylene solvate using 3D electron diffraction and synchrotron X-ray crystallography, respectively. The lattice energies are dominated by dispersive interactions between AZ1 molecules despite the presence of multiple hydrogen-bond donors and acceptors and planar aromatic groups, and both structures are built on similar intermolecular interactions. Thermal and spectral characterization revealed another solvate form containing dichloromethane. Amorphous solids produced by mechanochemical grinding of anhydrous AZ1 crystals also differed in dissolution characteristics from an amorphous solid produced by desolvating the dichloromethane solvate crystals, indicating that AZ1 may demonstrate pseudo-polyamorphism. This study paves the way for solid form screening and understanding in pharmaceutical systems that are far bRo5.
Text
screen-et-al-2025-crystallizing-the-uncrystallizable-insights-from-extensive-screening-of-protacs
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 23 July 2025
Published date: 23 July 2025
Keywords:
Crystal structure, Crystallization, Lattices, Molecular Structure, Molecules
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 503723
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/503723
ISSN: 2691-3704
PURE UUID: 5e111997-2686-4a76-b557-80bb24fca75a
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 11 Aug 2025 16:57
Last modified: 01 Oct 2025 02:13
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Martin A. Screen
Author:
James F. McCabe
Author:
Sean Askin
Author:
Jamie L. Guest
Author:
Paul Hodgkinson
Author:
Aurora J. Cruz-Cabeza
Author:
Toby J. Blundell
Author:
Daniel N. Rainer
Author:
Alexandra Longcake
Author:
Michael R. Probert
Author:
Clare S. Mahon
Author:
Mark R. Wilson
Author:
Jonathan W. Steed
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics