“You go an extra mile”: a qualitative study of community health worker perspectives in a health promotion intervention in urban South Africa
“You go an extra mile”: a qualitative study of community health worker perspectives in a health promotion intervention in urban South Africa
Background: as part of the Healthy Life Trajectories Initiative in South Africa, the Bukhali health promotion intervention is being implemented by community health workers (CHW’s) with young women in urban Soweto. The perspectives of these CHW’s have not been fully explored.
Methods: a qualitative study was conducted to describe CHW’s perspectives and experiences of delivering the Bukhali intervention. Three focus groups were conducted with the 13 CHWs employed at the time of the study, and a thematic approach was taken to data analysis.
Results: themes identified included: contextual realities for participants and CHWs, building relationships with participants, workload, emotional toll, and learning and development. Since they are recruited from Soweto, CHWs experienced similar contextual challenges to participants, and have to manage multiple roles, including health promotion and education, referral and support within the health system, counselling (although out of their scope of work), and data recording. The findings indicate the critical role CHWs play in building relationships with participants, especially establishing trust. Many CHWs spoke about going beyond what was expected in their role, which sometimes involved taking participants to medical facilities, and sharing resources with their participants. They spoke about the emotional toll of managing these relationships, their workload, and particularly the need for resilience and boundaries. CHWs experienced learning and development in their role as positive.
Conclusions: these findings provide a voice for these CHWs, but they also offer important learning of the implementation of the Bukhali intervention within the context of Soweto, as well as, future potential scale-up of CHW-delivered interventions in South Africa and other low- and middle-income countries.
Draper, Catherine E.
5032d1f5-0c2a-44be-8bdb-6e4967d49e14
Soepnel, Larske
e342b0a4-2e1d-4ae0-b0cf-9f7c274ebad0
Mabetha, Khuthala
6b05becb-751a-4c79-b95f-8413ee0c17b1
Motlhatlhedi, Molebogeng
b882c6ed-b0ac-42be-8e69-6897d7fa3c9c
Nkosi, Nokuthula
fcc3d315-f5b4-4010-aa9c-d1274ceb6dbd
Lye, Stephen J.
43a401cb-f979-40aa-a1c7-4583190d3414
Norris, Shane A.
1d346f1b-6d5f-4bca-ac87-7589851b75a4
23 December 2024
Draper, Catherine E.
5032d1f5-0c2a-44be-8bdb-6e4967d49e14
Soepnel, Larske
e342b0a4-2e1d-4ae0-b0cf-9f7c274ebad0
Mabetha, Khuthala
6b05becb-751a-4c79-b95f-8413ee0c17b1
Motlhatlhedi, Molebogeng
b882c6ed-b0ac-42be-8e69-6897d7fa3c9c
Nkosi, Nokuthula
fcc3d315-f5b4-4010-aa9c-d1274ceb6dbd
Lye, Stephen J.
43a401cb-f979-40aa-a1c7-4583190d3414
Norris, Shane A.
1d346f1b-6d5f-4bca-ac87-7589851b75a4
Draper, Catherine E., Soepnel, Larske, Mabetha, Khuthala, Motlhatlhedi, Molebogeng, Nkosi, Nokuthula, Lye, Stephen J. and Norris, Shane A.
(2024)
“You go an extra mile”: a qualitative study of community health worker perspectives in a health promotion intervention in urban South Africa.
BMC Health Services Research, 24, [1641].
(doi:10.1186/s12913-024-12127-0).
Abstract
Background: as part of the Healthy Life Trajectories Initiative in South Africa, the Bukhali health promotion intervention is being implemented by community health workers (CHW’s) with young women in urban Soweto. The perspectives of these CHW’s have not been fully explored.
Methods: a qualitative study was conducted to describe CHW’s perspectives and experiences of delivering the Bukhali intervention. Three focus groups were conducted with the 13 CHWs employed at the time of the study, and a thematic approach was taken to data analysis.
Results: themes identified included: contextual realities for participants and CHWs, building relationships with participants, workload, emotional toll, and learning and development. Since they are recruited from Soweto, CHWs experienced similar contextual challenges to participants, and have to manage multiple roles, including health promotion and education, referral and support within the health system, counselling (although out of their scope of work), and data recording. The findings indicate the critical role CHWs play in building relationships with participants, especially establishing trust. Many CHWs spoke about going beyond what was expected in their role, which sometimes involved taking participants to medical facilities, and sharing resources with their participants. They spoke about the emotional toll of managing these relationships, their workload, and particularly the need for resilience and boundaries. CHWs experienced learning and development in their role as positive.
Conclusions: these findings provide a voice for these CHWs, but they also offer important learning of the implementation of the Bukhali intervention within the context of Soweto, as well as, future potential scale-up of CHW-delivered interventions in South Africa and other low- and middle-income countries.
Text
s12913-024-12127-0
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 17 December 2024
Published date: 23 December 2024
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 504805
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/504805
ISSN: 1472-6963
PURE UUID: 7fc1dd0c-c185-4a07-95e2-e66f485f4142
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 18 Sep 2025 17:17
Last modified: 19 Sep 2025 02:02
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Catherine E. Draper
Author:
Larske Soepnel
Author:
Khuthala Mabetha
Author:
Molebogeng Motlhatlhedi
Author:
Nokuthula Nkosi
Author:
Stephen J. Lye
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics