Establishing requirements for breast centers in low- and middle-income countries: a South African perspective
Establishing requirements for breast centers in low- and middle-income countries: a South African perspective
Purpose: in South Africa, breast care lacks governance and standardization, necessitating urgent improvements in patient outcomes. Quality improvement initiatives are urgently needed in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), but requirements for breast centers in lower resource settings remain undefined and must be tailored to local environments. This consensus document outlines the role and requirements of breast centers in LMICs and presents a step-by-step implementation plan.
Methods: the literature was systematically reviewed, and the primary review team tabulated international accreditation standards alongside the 2018 South African Clinical Guidelines for Breast Cancer Control and Management from the South African National Department of Health, along with proposed South African standards. The broader consensus panel consisted of 29 clinical experts and representatives from societies, advocacy, and funders.
Results: we categorized requirements into eight broader categories and achieved unanimous consensus on all requirement components, except for 1 abstention in the general specialist and expertise category. We were unable to reach consensus on the patient volume requirements for radiologists as well as for medical and clinical/radiation oncologists. Volume requirements for clinical and radiation oncologists were later provided by the South African Society of Clinical and Radiation Oncology (SASCRO), along with the volume requirements submitted by the participating radiologists. We also achieved unanimous consensus for the Breast Interest Group of Southern Africa (BIGOSA) to house the initial project implementation. This consensus document is endorsed by BIGOSA, SASCRO, and the Cancer Association of South Africa.
Conclusion: we emphasize the importance and necessity of breast centers in resource-constrained environments, outline the first set of requirements for breast centers tailored to LMICs in sub-Saharan Africa, and present a feasible and detailed plan for initial implementation.
Nietz, Sarah
125138c5-1c1d-4801-8701-c6cd30a1219d
Edge, Jenny
20d0b245-a244-4a97-a337-236296c170e0
Buccimazza, Ines
29ed1fa1-5368-4ef1-9d0d-e6b9b29c6554
Demetriou, Georgia
c3912382-3067-4821-a41c-6269fe70a018
Tunmer, Mariza
028fa979-42b6-45bf-be48-1f1d2055eba6
Smilg, Jacqueline
66a5800a-df07-4946-89cd-0e1a77f5345e
Ramiah, Duvern
bae3c506-26f3-4c5d-97cf-1c50afaa34a7
Schoub, Peter
4ae8eeb6-4aeb-404a-a423-d4083a46294b
Norris, Shane A.
1d346f1b-6d5f-4bca-ac87-7589851b75a4
Ruff, Paul
916fe057-374c-4a7d-821c-52a54b32ffc4
18 June 2025
Nietz, Sarah
125138c5-1c1d-4801-8701-c6cd30a1219d
Edge, Jenny
20d0b245-a244-4a97-a337-236296c170e0
Buccimazza, Ines
29ed1fa1-5368-4ef1-9d0d-e6b9b29c6554
Demetriou, Georgia
c3912382-3067-4821-a41c-6269fe70a018
Tunmer, Mariza
028fa979-42b6-45bf-be48-1f1d2055eba6
Smilg, Jacqueline
66a5800a-df07-4946-89cd-0e1a77f5345e
Ramiah, Duvern
bae3c506-26f3-4c5d-97cf-1c50afaa34a7
Schoub, Peter
4ae8eeb6-4aeb-404a-a423-d4083a46294b
Norris, Shane A.
1d346f1b-6d5f-4bca-ac87-7589851b75a4
Ruff, Paul
916fe057-374c-4a7d-821c-52a54b32ffc4
Nietz, Sarah, Edge, Jenny, Buccimazza, Ines, Demetriou, Georgia, Tunmer, Mariza, Smilg, Jacqueline, Ramiah, Duvern, Schoub, Peter, Norris, Shane A. and Ruff, Paul
(2025)
Establishing requirements for breast centers in low- and middle-income countries: a South African perspective.
JCO Global Oncology, 11, [e2500168].
(doi:10.1200/GO-25-00168).
Abstract
Purpose: in South Africa, breast care lacks governance and standardization, necessitating urgent improvements in patient outcomes. Quality improvement initiatives are urgently needed in low- and middle-income countries (LMICs), but requirements for breast centers in lower resource settings remain undefined and must be tailored to local environments. This consensus document outlines the role and requirements of breast centers in LMICs and presents a step-by-step implementation plan.
Methods: the literature was systematically reviewed, and the primary review team tabulated international accreditation standards alongside the 2018 South African Clinical Guidelines for Breast Cancer Control and Management from the South African National Department of Health, along with proposed South African standards. The broader consensus panel consisted of 29 clinical experts and representatives from societies, advocacy, and funders.
Results: we categorized requirements into eight broader categories and achieved unanimous consensus on all requirement components, except for 1 abstention in the general specialist and expertise category. We were unable to reach consensus on the patient volume requirements for radiologists as well as for medical and clinical/radiation oncologists. Volume requirements for clinical and radiation oncologists were later provided by the South African Society of Clinical and Radiation Oncology (SASCRO), along with the volume requirements submitted by the participating radiologists. We also achieved unanimous consensus for the Breast Interest Group of Southern Africa (BIGOSA) to house the initial project implementation. This consensus document is endorsed by BIGOSA, SASCRO, and the Cancer Association of South Africa.
Conclusion: we emphasize the importance and necessity of breast centers in resource-constrained environments, outline the first set of requirements for breast centers tailored to LMICs in sub-Saharan Africa, and present a feasible and detailed plan for initial implementation.
Text
nietz-et-al-2025-establishing-requirements-for-breast-centers-in-low-and-middle-income-countries-a-south-african
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 21 May 2025
Published date: 18 June 2025
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 504881
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/504881
ISSN: 2687-8941
PURE UUID: c0384ee4-aa79-4878-89ef-6e95916e42c9
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 19 Sep 2025 17:02
Last modified: 20 Sep 2025 02:09
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Sarah Nietz
Author:
Jenny Edge
Author:
Ines Buccimazza
Author:
Georgia Demetriou
Author:
Mariza Tunmer
Author:
Jacqueline Smilg
Author:
Duvern Ramiah
Author:
Peter Schoub
Author:
Paul Ruff
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics