Inter- and intra-bacterial strain diversity remains the "elephant in the (living) room"
Inter- and intra-bacterial strain diversity remains the "elephant in the (living) room"
Acinetobacter baumannii is an opportunistic Gram-negative bacterial pathogen responsible for severe nosocomial infections worldwide. Resistance to last-resort antibiotics causes A. baumannii to be ranked as a top priority for the research and development of new antibiotics by the WHO and an urgent threat to public health by the CDC. It is also a member of the ESKAPE group comprising the most problematic antibiotic-resistant nosocomial pathogens. Resistance towards desiccation, disinfectants, reactive oxygen species, and the host immune system helps A. baumannii thrive in hospital settings and infect individuals compromised by lines, tubes, and indwelling devices. A. baumannii displays extensive genomic heterogeneity, yet recent studies show that this level of plasticity is also prevalent in lab strains widely used to study A. baumannii biology. Successive subculturing of widely used strains and spontaneous genetic variations results in significantly altered genotypes and phenotypes, often not recognized by the scientific community. In addition, the current strain designation methods do not allow efficient communication about such differences. Even presumably identical strains from established culture collections have been found to demonstrate genetic heterogeneity. The “elephant in the (living) room” refers to the risk but also the potential of the bi-partite problem concerning the high diversity amongst A. baumannii isolates (inter-strain variability), and the universal issue of microevolution (intra-strain variability). This is generally ignored as it is not referenced adequately in scientific publications. We aim to raise awareness about the current issues and the problematic consequences generated by intra- and inter-strain diversity based on modern examples of A. baumannii isolates. Therefore, this review provides cases of broadly used A. baumannii strains and their genetic and phenotypic differences.
Valcek, Adam
940908cc-5d19-458c-87d5-68de0b6f6c42
Kröger, Carsten
9ee35ea6-aa57-42f8-ada5-659b97fd9385
de Dios, Rubén
f8fffd7b-f295-418a-b96f-f14192995961
McCarthy, Ronan R.
0b2cf2e0-b0ff-4c92-aa04-92d91182d1f2
Coenye, Tom
de2d4149-c84c-4dbb-a7ae-c5da5dc29c7f
Trent, M. Stephen
e520c9ec-0930-490a-8a4d-d81f15afc47d
Karah, Nabil
01695ef9-0a41-4d1d-8513-1a9a1b16c651
Uhlin, Bernt Eric
c8d0e291-2fb4-4498-b37c-c7cde003da20
Classen, Annika Y.
9b981a97-b388-4590-871f-0300671b5605
Higgins, Paul G.
8ee7b1cf-ead3-4ca7-9551-0a6dd67ebde8
Ebersberger, Ingo
fc5af190-6698-4103-85bb-482dcad1456c
Laaberki, Maria-Halima
045ef339-edb8-4752-958d-db76da8e768b
Charpentier, Xavier
89a15fd6-ab8e-44b6-aa88-a4c1c2337bb4
Visca, Paolo
1b678a90-7be8-411a-a0bc-c01de387c8cc
Rather, Philip N.
294b36dc-1b2d-4f1e-b2ee-036aa988780d
Van der Henst, Charles
9f1b780d-cb6c-4d31-8a03-c07a9a5350be
25 July 2025
Valcek, Adam
940908cc-5d19-458c-87d5-68de0b6f6c42
Kröger, Carsten
9ee35ea6-aa57-42f8-ada5-659b97fd9385
de Dios, Rubén
f8fffd7b-f295-418a-b96f-f14192995961
McCarthy, Ronan R.
0b2cf2e0-b0ff-4c92-aa04-92d91182d1f2
Coenye, Tom
de2d4149-c84c-4dbb-a7ae-c5da5dc29c7f
Trent, M. Stephen
e520c9ec-0930-490a-8a4d-d81f15afc47d
Karah, Nabil
01695ef9-0a41-4d1d-8513-1a9a1b16c651
Uhlin, Bernt Eric
c8d0e291-2fb4-4498-b37c-c7cde003da20
Classen, Annika Y.
9b981a97-b388-4590-871f-0300671b5605
Higgins, Paul G.
8ee7b1cf-ead3-4ca7-9551-0a6dd67ebde8
Ebersberger, Ingo
fc5af190-6698-4103-85bb-482dcad1456c
Laaberki, Maria-Halima
045ef339-edb8-4752-958d-db76da8e768b
Charpentier, Xavier
89a15fd6-ab8e-44b6-aa88-a4c1c2337bb4
Visca, Paolo
1b678a90-7be8-411a-a0bc-c01de387c8cc
Rather, Philip N.
294b36dc-1b2d-4f1e-b2ee-036aa988780d
Van der Henst, Charles
9f1b780d-cb6c-4d31-8a03-c07a9a5350be
Valcek, Adam, Kröger, Carsten, de Dios, Rubén, McCarthy, Ronan R., Coenye, Tom, Trent, M. Stephen, Karah, Nabil, Uhlin, Bernt Eric, Classen, Annika Y., Higgins, Paul G., Ebersberger, Ingo, Laaberki, Maria-Halima, Charpentier, Xavier, Visca, Paolo, Rather, Philip N. and Van der Henst, Charles
(2025)
Inter- and intra-bacterial strain diversity remains the "elephant in the (living) room".
NPJ Antimicrobials and Resistance, 3 (1), [67].
(doi:10.1038/s44259-025-00138-8).
Abstract
Acinetobacter baumannii is an opportunistic Gram-negative bacterial pathogen responsible for severe nosocomial infections worldwide. Resistance to last-resort antibiotics causes A. baumannii to be ranked as a top priority for the research and development of new antibiotics by the WHO and an urgent threat to public health by the CDC. It is also a member of the ESKAPE group comprising the most problematic antibiotic-resistant nosocomial pathogens. Resistance towards desiccation, disinfectants, reactive oxygen species, and the host immune system helps A. baumannii thrive in hospital settings and infect individuals compromised by lines, tubes, and indwelling devices. A. baumannii displays extensive genomic heterogeneity, yet recent studies show that this level of plasticity is also prevalent in lab strains widely used to study A. baumannii biology. Successive subculturing of widely used strains and spontaneous genetic variations results in significantly altered genotypes and phenotypes, often not recognized by the scientific community. In addition, the current strain designation methods do not allow efficient communication about such differences. Even presumably identical strains from established culture collections have been found to demonstrate genetic heterogeneity. The “elephant in the (living) room” refers to the risk but also the potential of the bi-partite problem concerning the high diversity amongst A. baumannii isolates (inter-strain variability), and the universal issue of microevolution (intra-strain variability). This is generally ignored as it is not referenced adequately in scientific publications. We aim to raise awareness about the current issues and the problematic consequences generated by intra- and inter-strain diversity based on modern examples of A. baumannii isolates. Therefore, this review provides cases of broadly used A. baumannii strains and their genetic and phenotypic differences.
Text
s44259-025-00138-8
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 7 July 2025
Published date: 25 July 2025
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 506445
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/506445
ISSN: 2731-8745
PURE UUID: f6c4670a-dd38-4c3a-a7af-65a6460bfbaa
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 07 Nov 2025 17:36
Last modified: 15 Nov 2025 03:27
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Adam Valcek
Author:
Carsten Kröger
Author:
Rubén de Dios
Author:
Ronan R. McCarthy
Author:
Tom Coenye
Author:
M. Stephen Trent
Author:
Nabil Karah
Author:
Bernt Eric Uhlin
Author:
Annika Y. Classen
Author:
Paul G. Higgins
Author:
Ingo Ebersberger
Author:
Maria-Halima Laaberki
Author:
Xavier Charpentier
Author:
Paolo Visca
Author:
Philip N. Rather
Author:
Charles Van der Henst
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics