The Evolution of the SCOPUS Title Evaluation Platform (STEP), 2010 to 2025
The Evolution of the SCOPUS Title Evaluation Platform (STEP), 2010 to 2025
The SCOPUS Title Evaluation Platform (STEP) has had a significant global influence on academic publishing. It is the portal through which peer reviewed academic journals apply for listing in the SCOPUS database. Listings of journals in SCOPUS brought status and reputational gain to a journal, attractiveness to authors, and major profitability to their publishers.
STEP was developed as a unique computer based decision assistance tool for the academic journal assessors who comprised the newly formed SCOPUS Content Selection Advisory Board (CSAB) from 2010 onwards. It combined quantitative measurements with systematic qualitative evaluations of submitted journals against a set of agreed and published criteria, and it was based on trustworthiness across the academic ecosystem.
Over the past three decades, there has been an explosion in the numbers of academic journals and their publishers. This has been a consequence of huge global growth in academic activity, and it has been made possible by digital and internet systems; by open access publishing; and by the shift from subscription based financing to Article Publishing Charge (APC) based financing.
In parallel, there has been an explosion in publication fraud on a global scale in diverse forms and at high levels of sophistication.
In this essay, I aim to describe the creation, implementation and adaptation of STEP in a rapidly changing world to advance the processes of academic quality assurance, and the incremental addition of powerful functions to help assessors recognise and address the malign forms of fraud. These in turn are a perverse testimony to the importance that is attached globally to a SCOPUS listing
The SCOPUS Title Evaluation Platform (STEP), SCOPUS Content Selection Advisory Board (CSAB), Journal Bibliometrics, Publication Fraud Malpractice, SCOPUS Radar, Ulrichs Catalogue, Citescore, Virtual Citescore and Quasi-Citescore
University of Southampton
Rew, David
36dcc3ad-2379-4b61-a468-5c623d796887
18 December 2025
Rew, David
36dcc3ad-2379-4b61-a468-5c623d796887
Rew, David
(2025)
The Evolution of the SCOPUS Title Evaluation Platform (STEP), 2010 to 2025
(Essays on the Adjudication of Quality in the Global Academic Literature)
University of Southampton
39pp.
Record type:
Monograph
(Working Paper)
Abstract
The SCOPUS Title Evaluation Platform (STEP) has had a significant global influence on academic publishing. It is the portal through which peer reviewed academic journals apply for listing in the SCOPUS database. Listings of journals in SCOPUS brought status and reputational gain to a journal, attractiveness to authors, and major profitability to their publishers.
STEP was developed as a unique computer based decision assistance tool for the academic journal assessors who comprised the newly formed SCOPUS Content Selection Advisory Board (CSAB) from 2010 onwards. It combined quantitative measurements with systematic qualitative evaluations of submitted journals against a set of agreed and published criteria, and it was based on trustworthiness across the academic ecosystem.
Over the past three decades, there has been an explosion in the numbers of academic journals and their publishers. This has been a consequence of huge global growth in academic activity, and it has been made possible by digital and internet systems; by open access publishing; and by the shift from subscription based financing to Article Publishing Charge (APC) based financing.
In parallel, there has been an explosion in publication fraud on a global scale in diverse forms and at high levels of sophistication.
In this essay, I aim to describe the creation, implementation and adaptation of STEP in a rapidly changing world to advance the processes of academic quality assurance, and the incremental addition of powerful functions to help assessors recognise and address the malign forms of fraud. These in turn are a perverse testimony to the importance that is attached globally to a SCOPUS listing
Text
David Rew The Evolution of the SCOPUS Title Evaluation Platform, 2010-2025 18.12.2025
- Author's Original
More information
Published date: 18 December 2025
Additional Information:
David Rew, MA MB MChir (Cambridge) FRCS (London)
Honorary Consultant Surgeon to the Faculty of Medicine, University of Southampton, UK
And to the Clinical Informatics Research Unit.
Former Editor in Chief of the EJSO, The European Journal of Surgical Oncology, 2003-2009
Subject Chair for Medicine to the SCOPUS Content Selection Advisory Board, Elsevier BV,
The Netherlands, 2009 to the Present
Keywords:
The SCOPUS Title Evaluation Platform (STEP), SCOPUS Content Selection Advisory Board (CSAB), Journal Bibliometrics, Publication Fraud Malpractice, SCOPUS Radar, Ulrichs Catalogue, Citescore, Virtual Citescore and Quasi-Citescore
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 507702
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/507702
PURE UUID: 4e159f46-e092-4e3e-aff8-262bf521dfc8
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 18 Dec 2025 17:50
Last modified: 19 Dec 2025 02:56
Export record
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics
