The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Experimental Cancer Medicine Centre (ECMC) network proposal for a consensus gene panel for pan-cancer sequencing: a Delphi methodology

Experimental Cancer Medicine Centre (ECMC) network proposal for a consensus gene panel for pan-cancer sequencing: a Delphi methodology
Experimental Cancer Medicine Centre (ECMC) network proposal for a consensus gene panel for pan-cancer sequencing: a Delphi methodology

Background: the Experimental Cancer Medicine Centre (ECMC) Network supports UK-wide access to experimental cancer therapies, many of which require specific genomic alterations. This study aimed to develop expert consensus on essential genes for a pan-cancer sequencing panel, involving subject matter experts (SMEs) from the ECMC Network and the pharmaceutical industry.

Methods: a pilot with 8 SMEs graded 526 genes, refining the list to 210. A three-round Delphi process was then used, with SMEs iteratively evaluating each gene. In the final round, SMEs also assessed the inclusion of tumour mutational burden (TMB), microsatellite instability (MSI), and mutation types (structural variations, copy number variations, and/or fusions).

Results: consensus was reached on a final panel of 99 genes applicable across multiple cancers. High agreement was also achieved for including TMB, MSI, and screening for structural variations, copy number variants, and fusions. The panel is intended for both adult and paediatric tumour types.

Conclusions: this consensus-based gene panel offers a standardised approach to pan-cancer genomic screening. It supports harmonised diagnostics and could improve patient access to personalised therapies and research trials across clinical and NHS settings.

0007-0920
Phillips, Richard
7a38c8fc-37d8-462c-a240-024b662d850a
Basu, Bristi
705710d2-e56f-49f4-8f7d-8255c84cdc75
Butt, Zohra
cfc6fde5-dd25-4599-9824-8f1c5ed56792
Beloueche, Mounia
8ca6ee3f-2c0f-470f-a24d-dc930810a7b4
Cook, Natalie
77640a65-689e-447f-8591-85456f3ccc00
Crabb, Simon J.
bcd1b566-7677-4f81-8429-3ab0e85f8373
Greystoke, Alastair
cfff98e4-ece7-45c9-9761-1560ad9d4091
Hargrave, Darren
753b0c7b-3008-437c-a02a-59327ebe5b7e
Jones, Robert
3f90d8c7-0a3a-4bf4-8a73-283a9df84c5b
Kureeman, Muhammad Yasin
b13b2ba5-a068-442e-bbda-5cc91333cfe6
Lopez, Juanita
976c092f-33f8-48af-bd9d-47b6ee490194
McKeeve, Claire
26f505e1-64fd-4031-b8b8-a2ae9fca5138
Meissner, Magdalena
12764036-2f3b-4ab0-b971-c21e226fa3ef
O'Carrigan, Brent
5b55f649-acf0-4543-b1c2-4f5f813080b9
Parkes, Eileen E.
5f9e5c11-d997-4104-b561-57b0e82e21ac
Ronghe, Milind
c3c74994-80b6-42e6-9de5-ef3d1a5d1816
Roxburgh, Patricia
b88bb3a5-9f6c-44f1-be6c-ae731abc2c56
Sarker, Debashis
1b3b1b23-092b-4f05-8fe5-7f9922e2d3e7
Savage, Kienan I.
611660d7-4315-4ae7-8511-e81b835cd57b
Shaw, Paul H.S.
91a4c284-902f-4725-890a-9a21e51dc2b0
Symeonides, Stefan
f683db40-0f55-4f6d-91aa-234c664a7095
Tweddle, Deborah A.
b333d6ca-fb4c-4f44-a23d-b42e666256ed
Vedi, Aditi
b00600d1-b328-4523-be71-e12428038bd4
Walter, Harriet S.
2f03f85a-68f3-4bc1-9974-d09e8fcd1be9
Zabkiewicz, Joanna
62169fcd-6ff4-4f5c-9f2f-feb80244f68b
Middleton, Gary W.
4ea6a2a3-ff70-4744-809e-49d25e0b0536
Beggs, Andrew D.
fe399221-77bc-4be2-b45e-739e1d889581
et al.
Phillips, Richard
7a38c8fc-37d8-462c-a240-024b662d850a
Basu, Bristi
705710d2-e56f-49f4-8f7d-8255c84cdc75
Butt, Zohra
cfc6fde5-dd25-4599-9824-8f1c5ed56792
Beloueche, Mounia
8ca6ee3f-2c0f-470f-a24d-dc930810a7b4
Cook, Natalie
77640a65-689e-447f-8591-85456f3ccc00
Crabb, Simon J.
bcd1b566-7677-4f81-8429-3ab0e85f8373
Greystoke, Alastair
cfff98e4-ece7-45c9-9761-1560ad9d4091
Hargrave, Darren
753b0c7b-3008-437c-a02a-59327ebe5b7e
Jones, Robert
3f90d8c7-0a3a-4bf4-8a73-283a9df84c5b
Kureeman, Muhammad Yasin
b13b2ba5-a068-442e-bbda-5cc91333cfe6
Lopez, Juanita
976c092f-33f8-48af-bd9d-47b6ee490194
McKeeve, Claire
26f505e1-64fd-4031-b8b8-a2ae9fca5138
Meissner, Magdalena
12764036-2f3b-4ab0-b971-c21e226fa3ef
O'Carrigan, Brent
5b55f649-acf0-4543-b1c2-4f5f813080b9
Parkes, Eileen E.
5f9e5c11-d997-4104-b561-57b0e82e21ac
Ronghe, Milind
c3c74994-80b6-42e6-9de5-ef3d1a5d1816
Roxburgh, Patricia
b88bb3a5-9f6c-44f1-be6c-ae731abc2c56
Sarker, Debashis
1b3b1b23-092b-4f05-8fe5-7f9922e2d3e7
Savage, Kienan I.
611660d7-4315-4ae7-8511-e81b835cd57b
Shaw, Paul H.S.
91a4c284-902f-4725-890a-9a21e51dc2b0
Symeonides, Stefan
f683db40-0f55-4f6d-91aa-234c664a7095
Tweddle, Deborah A.
b333d6ca-fb4c-4f44-a23d-b42e666256ed
Vedi, Aditi
b00600d1-b328-4523-be71-e12428038bd4
Walter, Harriet S.
2f03f85a-68f3-4bc1-9974-d09e8fcd1be9
Zabkiewicz, Joanna
62169fcd-6ff4-4f5c-9f2f-feb80244f68b
Middleton, Gary W.
4ea6a2a3-ff70-4744-809e-49d25e0b0536
Beggs, Andrew D.
fe399221-77bc-4be2-b45e-739e1d889581

Phillips, Richard, Basu, Bristi and Butt, Zohra , et al. (2025) Experimental Cancer Medicine Centre (ECMC) network proposal for a consensus gene panel for pan-cancer sequencing: a Delphi methodology. British Journal of Cancer. (doi:10.1038/s41416-025-03252-6).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Background: the Experimental Cancer Medicine Centre (ECMC) Network supports UK-wide access to experimental cancer therapies, many of which require specific genomic alterations. This study aimed to develop expert consensus on essential genes for a pan-cancer sequencing panel, involving subject matter experts (SMEs) from the ECMC Network and the pharmaceutical industry.

Methods: a pilot with 8 SMEs graded 526 genes, refining the list to 210. A three-round Delphi process was then used, with SMEs iteratively evaluating each gene. In the final round, SMEs also assessed the inclusion of tumour mutational burden (TMB), microsatellite instability (MSI), and mutation types (structural variations, copy number variations, and/or fusions).

Results: consensus was reached on a final panel of 99 genes applicable across multiple cancers. High agreement was also achieved for including TMB, MSI, and screening for structural variations, copy number variants, and fusions. The panel is intended for both adult and paediatric tumour types.

Conclusions: this consensus-based gene panel offers a standardised approach to pan-cancer genomic screening. It supports harmonised diagnostics and could improve patient access to personalised therapies and research trials across clinical and NHS settings.

Text
s41416-025-03252-6 - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (799kB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 23 October 2025
e-pub ahead of print date: 8 November 2025
Published date: 8 November 2025

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 508360
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/508360
ISSN: 0007-0920
PURE UUID: 5176aa15-6cab-4a1c-a339-ceaddac985cd
ORCID for Simon J. Crabb: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0003-3521-9064

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 20 Jan 2026 17:37
Last modified: 21 Jan 2026 02:38

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Richard Phillips
Author: Bristi Basu
Author: Zohra Butt
Author: Mounia Beloueche
Author: Natalie Cook
Author: Simon J. Crabb ORCID iD
Author: Alastair Greystoke
Author: Darren Hargrave
Author: Robert Jones
Author: Muhammad Yasin Kureeman
Author: Juanita Lopez
Author: Claire McKeeve
Author: Magdalena Meissner
Author: Brent O'Carrigan
Author: Eileen E. Parkes
Author: Milind Ronghe
Author: Patricia Roxburgh
Author: Debashis Sarker
Author: Kienan I. Savage
Author: Paul H.S. Shaw
Author: Stefan Symeonides
Author: Deborah A. Tweddle
Author: Aditi Vedi
Author: Harriet S. Walter
Author: Joanna Zabkiewicz
Author: Gary W. Middleton
Author: Andrew D. Beggs
Corporate Author: et al.

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×