The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Local antibody feedback enforces a checkpoint on affinity maturation in the germinal center and promotes epitope spreading

Local antibody feedback enforces a checkpoint on affinity maturation in the germinal center and promotes epitope spreading
Local antibody feedback enforces a checkpoint on affinity maturation in the germinal center and promotes epitope spreading

Circulating antibodies from previous immune encounters impact subsequent humoral responses. Here, we investigated how local epitope-specific competition shapes ongoing germinal center (GC) responses by delivering an mRNA-LNP-encoded membrane-bound immunogen displaying three conserved HIV-1 envelope (Env) epitopes to mouse models bearing B cell receptors (BCRs) of defined affinities. High-affinity B cells exhibited shorter GC residency than lower-affinity counterparts. B cells engaged GC reactions at equivalent rates in the presence or absence of clonal lineages binding the same epitope with similar affinities; however, higher-affinity clones suppressed lower-affinity counterparts targeting the same epitope. Spatial transcriptomics revealed plasma-like cells within and adjacent to the GC, and early immunoglobulin G (IgG) was detectable in draining lymph nodes. Our findings suggest that a self-modulating local antibody feedback loop limits epitope-specific recognition-dampening selection for higher-affinity B cells and facilitating epitope spreading by redirecting the response toward alternative epitopes.

Animals, Antibody Affinity/immunology, B-Lymphocytes/immunology, Epitopes, B-Lymphocyte/immunology, Epitopes/immunology, Feedback, Physiological, Germinal Center/immunology, HIV Antibodies/immunology, HIV-1/immunology, Humans, Immunoglobulin G/immunology, Mice, Mice, Inbred C57BL, Receptors, Antigen, B-Cell/immunology, sequential immunization, germinal center, antibody feedback, plasma cells, local antibody pool, B cell, vaccine, HIV, affinity maturation
1097-4180
746-767
Yan, Yu
6b2d256a-2c75-405c-a7a7-3486f0df0b6c
Wang, Xuesong
44aca578-9852-4f90-b000-a0e4097982d2
Xie, Zhenfei
e247ca96-531b-4714-ad7d-ee7ef3115bba
Bader, Daniel L.V.
9884d4f6-2607-4d48-bf0c-62bdcc0d1dbf
Lim, Ryan H.
d431ad12-fb72-4e5d-9b02-14e8ff0b29c8
Ma, Krystal M.
4d74c64f-c2c8-46f8-a413-dd17bf7bf161
Cottrell, Christopher A.
942bfa7b-c09e-459d-a6c2-0d64d55fa230
Steichen, Jon M.
53e5c7c4-5a1e-4f4e-8d03-1486b670b425
Xu, Liling
13c24661-b471-42c0-bbec-e365776ad546
Villavicencio, Paula M.
bc0bec4a-05a4-4bae-9c88-2da0ace4bb6b
Akauliya, Madhav
2024d51a-4c1a-4b46-86c1-53d1e724ca0c
Koo, Ja-Hyun
0c742333-1992-40aa-8a98-77f972a6d8d4
Shen, Jacqueline Ming
1550fe1a-cbc1-41a0-8524-d3a549a918d6
Vernich, Alexandra
6b191e21-b8ad-4010-803d-9f16699bb721
Kalyuzhniy, Oleksandr
f5b932fd-de1f-49a1-95a4-ea985a8153cd
Allen, Joel D.
c89d5569-7659-4835-b535-c9586e956b3a
Albowaidey, Ali A.
9ccecaac-96d2-4fc2-a201-5b2e61a029a4
Alicea, Anthony
a3c263d3-3171-4045-ad74-ce1e92513932
Chen, Bingxian
46c22bb4-61a6-4317-9e04-78028925106e
Georgeson, Erik
ffaa8487-b29b-4ebf-a132-a9e12892887c
Ellis-Pugh, Jordan Renae
6890403b-fcd3-42b9-805e-1531b812769d
Alavi, Nushin
a9c8b0b1-d089-4b83-875d-2442b9db2f23
Esposito, Abigail
20417d8e-d916-4d94-ad45-717a83b84e5e
Naili, Hannah
995d5364-7f4b-4206-88c3-8f0d39a37c0a
Phelps, Nicole
e984ceba-5a50-49b8-b264-ce5d498a56e7
Kelley, Brendon
ac6b73c8-9a71-4258-acd8-4bc3b5543352
Kubitz, Michael
13dece81-6982-42a0-a7dc-378a29382130
Phan, Quynh Anh
6e2c2b73-43bb-4b32-a122-bc452df99c1d
Liguori, Alessia
a2ba24a9-ef50-43de-b095-a59eee87f260
Prum, Thavaleak
b69fc6fe-68ce-40bc-8300-71addbab2916
Tingle, Ryan
a0b39b69-fd81-467c-bbdf-4eaced0a313c
Lu, Danny
19de67c2-1272-495e-892d-3423fd337c2c
Eskandarzadeh, Saman
adc1dd12-75a0-4ee3-9818-c9f6bf495976
Liu, Xiaotie
7b1cfd7a-434e-4dcb-aa3a-9fda1bc601cb
Warner, John E.
08ec7f71-ef96-42f1-a5be-b05893bf1c2b
Weldon, Stephanie R.
9727798d-424f-40f3-bc10-53dd443cf56e
Himansu, Sunny
5f5c72f8-ebd0-470f-b1c1-a1c9255dc10a
Crispin, Max
cd980957-0943-4b89-b2b2-710f01f33bc9
Nair, Usha
129b83ef-c874-4d00-9bdc-9b4d56f15e5c
Liu, Sophia
ee41b4ac-c179-4b1f-8a28-46053c22b34f
Schief, William R.
f7dacd3e-5479-4d93-b7a4-50403827285b
Batista, Facundo D.
4b2e1e73-d3b5-41bf-9381-180cdbd45db2
et al.
Yan, Yu
6b2d256a-2c75-405c-a7a7-3486f0df0b6c
Wang, Xuesong
44aca578-9852-4f90-b000-a0e4097982d2
Xie, Zhenfei
e247ca96-531b-4714-ad7d-ee7ef3115bba
Bader, Daniel L.V.
9884d4f6-2607-4d48-bf0c-62bdcc0d1dbf
Lim, Ryan H.
d431ad12-fb72-4e5d-9b02-14e8ff0b29c8
Ma, Krystal M.
4d74c64f-c2c8-46f8-a413-dd17bf7bf161
Cottrell, Christopher A.
942bfa7b-c09e-459d-a6c2-0d64d55fa230
Steichen, Jon M.
53e5c7c4-5a1e-4f4e-8d03-1486b670b425
Xu, Liling
13c24661-b471-42c0-bbec-e365776ad546
Villavicencio, Paula M.
bc0bec4a-05a4-4bae-9c88-2da0ace4bb6b
Akauliya, Madhav
2024d51a-4c1a-4b46-86c1-53d1e724ca0c
Koo, Ja-Hyun
0c742333-1992-40aa-8a98-77f972a6d8d4
Shen, Jacqueline Ming
1550fe1a-cbc1-41a0-8524-d3a549a918d6
Vernich, Alexandra
6b191e21-b8ad-4010-803d-9f16699bb721
Kalyuzhniy, Oleksandr
f5b932fd-de1f-49a1-95a4-ea985a8153cd
Allen, Joel D.
c89d5569-7659-4835-b535-c9586e956b3a
Albowaidey, Ali A.
9ccecaac-96d2-4fc2-a201-5b2e61a029a4
Alicea, Anthony
a3c263d3-3171-4045-ad74-ce1e92513932
Chen, Bingxian
46c22bb4-61a6-4317-9e04-78028925106e
Georgeson, Erik
ffaa8487-b29b-4ebf-a132-a9e12892887c
Ellis-Pugh, Jordan Renae
6890403b-fcd3-42b9-805e-1531b812769d
Alavi, Nushin
a9c8b0b1-d089-4b83-875d-2442b9db2f23
Esposito, Abigail
20417d8e-d916-4d94-ad45-717a83b84e5e
Naili, Hannah
995d5364-7f4b-4206-88c3-8f0d39a37c0a
Phelps, Nicole
e984ceba-5a50-49b8-b264-ce5d498a56e7
Kelley, Brendon
ac6b73c8-9a71-4258-acd8-4bc3b5543352
Kubitz, Michael
13dece81-6982-42a0-a7dc-378a29382130
Phan, Quynh Anh
6e2c2b73-43bb-4b32-a122-bc452df99c1d
Liguori, Alessia
a2ba24a9-ef50-43de-b095-a59eee87f260
Prum, Thavaleak
b69fc6fe-68ce-40bc-8300-71addbab2916
Tingle, Ryan
a0b39b69-fd81-467c-bbdf-4eaced0a313c
Lu, Danny
19de67c2-1272-495e-892d-3423fd337c2c
Eskandarzadeh, Saman
adc1dd12-75a0-4ee3-9818-c9f6bf495976
Liu, Xiaotie
7b1cfd7a-434e-4dcb-aa3a-9fda1bc601cb
Warner, John E.
08ec7f71-ef96-42f1-a5be-b05893bf1c2b
Weldon, Stephanie R.
9727798d-424f-40f3-bc10-53dd443cf56e
Himansu, Sunny
5f5c72f8-ebd0-470f-b1c1-a1c9255dc10a
Crispin, Max
cd980957-0943-4b89-b2b2-710f01f33bc9
Nair, Usha
129b83ef-c874-4d00-9bdc-9b4d56f15e5c
Liu, Sophia
ee41b4ac-c179-4b1f-8a28-46053c22b34f
Schief, William R.
f7dacd3e-5479-4d93-b7a4-50403827285b
Batista, Facundo D.
4b2e1e73-d3b5-41bf-9381-180cdbd45db2

Yan, Yu, Wang, Xuesong and Xie, Zhenfei , et al. (2026) Local antibody feedback enforces a checkpoint on affinity maturation in the germinal center and promotes epitope spreading. Immunity, 59 (3), 746-767, [e9]. (doi:10.1016/j.immuni.2026.01.011).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Circulating antibodies from previous immune encounters impact subsequent humoral responses. Here, we investigated how local epitope-specific competition shapes ongoing germinal center (GC) responses by delivering an mRNA-LNP-encoded membrane-bound immunogen displaying three conserved HIV-1 envelope (Env) epitopes to mouse models bearing B cell receptors (BCRs) of defined affinities. High-affinity B cells exhibited shorter GC residency than lower-affinity counterparts. B cells engaged GC reactions at equivalent rates in the presence or absence of clonal lineages binding the same epitope with similar affinities; however, higher-affinity clones suppressed lower-affinity counterparts targeting the same epitope. Spatial transcriptomics revealed plasma-like cells within and adjacent to the GC, and early immunoglobulin G (IgG) was detectable in draining lymph nodes. Our findings suggest that a self-modulating local antibody feedback loop limits epitope-specific recognition-dampening selection for higher-affinity B cells and facilitating epitope spreading by redirecting the response toward alternative epitopes.

Text
1-s2.0-S1074761326000324-main - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (11MB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 7 January 2026
e-pub ahead of print date: 13 February 2026
Published date: 10 March 2026
Keywords: Animals, Antibody Affinity/immunology, B-Lymphocytes/immunology, Epitopes, B-Lymphocyte/immunology, Epitopes/immunology, Feedback, Physiological, Germinal Center/immunology, HIV Antibodies/immunology, HIV-1/immunology, Humans, Immunoglobulin G/immunology, Mice, Mice, Inbred C57BL, Receptors, Antigen, B-Cell/immunology, sequential immunization, germinal center, antibody feedback, plasma cells, local antibody pool, B cell, vaccine, HIV, affinity maturation

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 510979
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/510979
ISSN: 1097-4180
PURE UUID: 32c8f091-7cea-4c59-9fbe-52a1d579e99c
ORCID for Daniel L.V. Bader: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-1208-3507
ORCID for Joel D. Allen: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0003-2547-968X
ORCID for Max Crispin: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-1072-2694

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 28 Apr 2026 16:45
Last modified: 29 Apr 2026 02:05

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Yu Yan
Author: Xuesong Wang
Author: Zhenfei Xie
Author: Ryan H. Lim
Author: Krystal M. Ma
Author: Christopher A. Cottrell
Author: Jon M. Steichen
Author: Liling Xu
Author: Paula M. Villavicencio
Author: Madhav Akauliya
Author: Ja-Hyun Koo
Author: Jacqueline Ming Shen
Author: Alexandra Vernich
Author: Oleksandr Kalyuzhniy
Author: Joel D. Allen ORCID iD
Author: Ali A. Albowaidey
Author: Anthony Alicea
Author: Bingxian Chen
Author: Erik Georgeson
Author: Jordan Renae Ellis-Pugh
Author: Nushin Alavi
Author: Abigail Esposito
Author: Hannah Naili
Author: Nicole Phelps
Author: Brendon Kelley
Author: Michael Kubitz
Author: Quynh Anh Phan
Author: Alessia Liguori
Author: Thavaleak Prum
Author: Ryan Tingle
Author: Danny Lu
Author: Saman Eskandarzadeh
Author: Xiaotie Liu
Author: John E. Warner
Author: Stephanie R. Weldon
Author: Sunny Himansu
Author: Max Crispin ORCID iD
Author: Usha Nair
Author: Sophia Liu
Author: William R. Schief
Author: Facundo D. Batista
Corporate Author: et al.

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×