The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Estimation of gas hydrate concentration from multi-component seismic data at sites on the continental margins of NW Svalbard and the Storegga region of Norway

Estimation of gas hydrate concentration from multi-component seismic data at sites on the continental margins of NW Svalbard and the Storegga region of Norway
Estimation of gas hydrate concentration from multi-component seismic data at sites on the continental margins of NW Svalbard and the Storegga region of Norway
High-resolution seismic experiments, employing arrays of closely spaced, four-component ocean-bottom seismic recorders, were conducted at a site off western Svalbard and a site on the northern margin of the Storegga slide, off Norway to investigate how well seismic data can be used to determine the concentration of methane hydrate beneath the seabed. Data from P-waves and from S-waves generated by P–S conversion on reflection were inverted for P- and S-wave velocity (Vp and Vs), using 3D travel-time tomography, 2D ray-tracing inversion and 1D waveform inversion. At the NW Svalbard site, positive Vp anomalies above a sea-bottom-simulating reflector (BSR) indicate the presence of gas hydrate. A zone containing free gas up to 150-m thick, lying immediately beneath the BSR, is indicated by a large reduction in Vp without significant reduction in Vs. At the Storegga site, the lateral and vertical variation in Vp and Vs and the variation in amplitude and polarity of reflectors indicate a heterogeneous distribution of hydrate that is related to a stratigraphically mediated distribution of free gas beneath the BSR. Derivation of hydrate content from Vp and Vs was evaluated, using different models for how hydrate affects the seismic properties of the sediment host and different approaches for estimating the background-velocity of the sediment host. The error in the average Vp of an interval of 20-m thickness is about 2.5%, at 95% confidence, and yields a resolution of hydrate concentration of about 3%, if hydrate forms a connected framework, or about 7%, if it is both pore-filling and framework-forming. At NW Svalbard, in a zone about 90-m thick above the BSR, a Biot-theory-based method predicts hydrate concentrations of up to 11% of pore space, and an effective-medium-based method predicts concentrations of up to 6%, if hydrate forms a connected framework, or 12%, if hydrate is both pore-filling and framework-forming. At Storegga, hydrate concentrations of up to 10% or 20% were predicted, depending on the hydrate model, in a zone about 120-m thick above a BSR. With seismic techniques alone, we can only estimate with any confidence the average hydrate content of broad intervals containing more than one layer, not only because of the uncertainty in the layer-by-layer variation in lithology, but also because of the negative correlation in the errors of estimation of velocity between adjacent layers. In this investigation, an interval of about 20-m thickness (equivalent to between 2 and 5 layers in the model used for waveform inversion) was the smallest within which one could sensibly estimate the hydrate content. If lithological layering much thinner than 20-m thickness controls hydrate content, then hydrate concentrations within layers could significantly exceed or fall below the average values derived from seismic data.
p-wave, s-wave, seismic velocity, hydrate concentration, continental margin
0264-8172
744-758
Westbrook, G.K.
ccd95de7-a1a1-4fc9-be37-f1a487bb65ca
Chand, S.
079ed6bb-3458-497e-aa12-815ab79a4df8
Rossi, G.
e55ede28-0f95-4422-b279-1bd9577d3836
Long, C.
0b946773-8b6c-4745-b3ec-245a43320db1
Bünz, S.
32f5b37d-6521-4dcf-b4f8-a3f7096258c5
Camerlenghi, A.
9f084f43-0dd6-43df-9160-07fbcb0b5e39
Carcione, J.M.
4fd9f46d-37ec-4d9e-ba2c-472755a82641
Dean, S.
ed6a0e1e-25bd-4d51-9e62-6cc9bdc83482
Foucher, J-P.
7490eb95-971e-4b76-8953-3801c758b4c9
Flueh, E.
f910c5c7-f0d7-494d-857f-891c9e44ded3
Gei, D.
ab0340e7-2628-4b26-8870-a373e2e1c6e8
Haacke, R.R.
8df6190b-08ec-4c0e-b41d-8f44aa35eabd
Madrussani, G.
0ad3bce4-275f-4f11-803c-9e9fccd70f9e
Mienert, J.
90ba1f28-5249-4663-ad09-b6abc8b46068
Minshull, T.A.
bf413fb5-849e-4389-acd7-0cb0d644e6b8
Nouzé, H.
cc9ec74f-218e-452d-ae72-680caa92cc0c
Peacock, S.
4712a6f2-4f50-47ad-8d36-1c0777e87ee9
Reston, T.J.
0ba75307-667f-4f0e-b4fd-42f80a34b4f7
Vanneste, M.
37b5a71c-888c-4f29-8f7e-62b07b7fd81c
Zillmer, M.
a253aa64-e678-4c35-ba97-0686c281d36c
Westbrook, G.K.
ccd95de7-a1a1-4fc9-be37-f1a487bb65ca
Chand, S.
079ed6bb-3458-497e-aa12-815ab79a4df8
Rossi, G.
e55ede28-0f95-4422-b279-1bd9577d3836
Long, C.
0b946773-8b6c-4745-b3ec-245a43320db1
Bünz, S.
32f5b37d-6521-4dcf-b4f8-a3f7096258c5
Camerlenghi, A.
9f084f43-0dd6-43df-9160-07fbcb0b5e39
Carcione, J.M.
4fd9f46d-37ec-4d9e-ba2c-472755a82641
Dean, S.
ed6a0e1e-25bd-4d51-9e62-6cc9bdc83482
Foucher, J-P.
7490eb95-971e-4b76-8953-3801c758b4c9
Flueh, E.
f910c5c7-f0d7-494d-857f-891c9e44ded3
Gei, D.
ab0340e7-2628-4b26-8870-a373e2e1c6e8
Haacke, R.R.
8df6190b-08ec-4c0e-b41d-8f44aa35eabd
Madrussani, G.
0ad3bce4-275f-4f11-803c-9e9fccd70f9e
Mienert, J.
90ba1f28-5249-4663-ad09-b6abc8b46068
Minshull, T.A.
bf413fb5-849e-4389-acd7-0cb0d644e6b8
Nouzé, H.
cc9ec74f-218e-452d-ae72-680caa92cc0c
Peacock, S.
4712a6f2-4f50-47ad-8d36-1c0777e87ee9
Reston, T.J.
0ba75307-667f-4f0e-b4fd-42f80a34b4f7
Vanneste, M.
37b5a71c-888c-4f29-8f7e-62b07b7fd81c
Zillmer, M.
a253aa64-e678-4c35-ba97-0686c281d36c

Westbrook, G.K., Chand, S., Rossi, G., Long, C., Bünz, S., Camerlenghi, A., Carcione, J.M., Dean, S., Foucher, J-P., Flueh, E., Gei, D., Haacke, R.R., Madrussani, G., Mienert, J., Minshull, T.A., Nouzé, H., Peacock, S., Reston, T.J., Vanneste, M. and Zillmer, M. (2008) Estimation of gas hydrate concentration from multi-component seismic data at sites on the continental margins of NW Svalbard and the Storegga region of Norway. Marine and Petroleum Geology, 25 (8), 744-758. (doi:10.1016/j.marpetgeo.2008.02.003).

Record type: Article

Abstract

High-resolution seismic experiments, employing arrays of closely spaced, four-component ocean-bottom seismic recorders, were conducted at a site off western Svalbard and a site on the northern margin of the Storegga slide, off Norway to investigate how well seismic data can be used to determine the concentration of methane hydrate beneath the seabed. Data from P-waves and from S-waves generated by P–S conversion on reflection were inverted for P- and S-wave velocity (Vp and Vs), using 3D travel-time tomography, 2D ray-tracing inversion and 1D waveform inversion. At the NW Svalbard site, positive Vp anomalies above a sea-bottom-simulating reflector (BSR) indicate the presence of gas hydrate. A zone containing free gas up to 150-m thick, lying immediately beneath the BSR, is indicated by a large reduction in Vp without significant reduction in Vs. At the Storegga site, the lateral and vertical variation in Vp and Vs and the variation in amplitude and polarity of reflectors indicate a heterogeneous distribution of hydrate that is related to a stratigraphically mediated distribution of free gas beneath the BSR. Derivation of hydrate content from Vp and Vs was evaluated, using different models for how hydrate affects the seismic properties of the sediment host and different approaches for estimating the background-velocity of the sediment host. The error in the average Vp of an interval of 20-m thickness is about 2.5%, at 95% confidence, and yields a resolution of hydrate concentration of about 3%, if hydrate forms a connected framework, or about 7%, if it is both pore-filling and framework-forming. At NW Svalbard, in a zone about 90-m thick above the BSR, a Biot-theory-based method predicts hydrate concentrations of up to 11% of pore space, and an effective-medium-based method predicts concentrations of up to 6%, if hydrate forms a connected framework, or 12%, if hydrate is both pore-filling and framework-forming. At Storegga, hydrate concentrations of up to 10% or 20% were predicted, depending on the hydrate model, in a zone about 120-m thick above a BSR. With seismic techniques alone, we can only estimate with any confidence the average hydrate content of broad intervals containing more than one layer, not only because of the uncertainty in the layer-by-layer variation in lithology, but also because of the negative correlation in the errors of estimation of velocity between adjacent layers. In this investigation, an interval of about 20-m thickness (equivalent to between 2 and 5 layers in the model used for waveform inversion) was the smallest within which one could sensibly estimate the hydrate content. If lithological layering much thinner than 20-m thickness controls hydrate content, then hydrate concentrations within layers could significantly exceed or fall below the average values derived from seismic data.

Text
Westbrook_et_al_2008.pdf - Accepted Manuscript
Download (7MB)

More information

Published date: September 2008
Keywords: p-wave, s-wave, seismic velocity, hydrate concentration, continental margin

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 65045
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/65045
ISSN: 0264-8172
PURE UUID: b2888aa9-8cee-4c58-a596-1faf590a9abf
ORCID for T.A. Minshull: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-8202-1379

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 28 Jan 2009
Last modified: 16 Mar 2024 03:11

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: G.K. Westbrook
Author: S. Chand
Author: G. Rossi
Author: C. Long
Author: S. Bünz
Author: A. Camerlenghi
Author: J.M. Carcione
Author: S. Dean
Author: J-P. Foucher
Author: E. Flueh
Author: D. Gei
Author: R.R. Haacke
Author: G. Madrussani
Author: J. Mienert
Author: T.A. Minshull ORCID iD
Author: H. Nouzé
Author: S. Peacock
Author: T.J. Reston
Author: M. Vanneste
Author: M. Zillmer

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×