Unique aspects of herbal whole system research
Unique aspects of herbal whole system research
INTRODUCTION: whole systems of healthcare offer unique methodological and theoretical challenges for researchers. Herbalism has its own set of methodological and philosophical research issues that are beyond those presented for whole system research in general. It was our objective to explore various conceptual and methodological issues surrounding whole system herbal research.
METHODS: an International Society for Complementary Medicine Research workshop, Challenges in Herbal Whole System Research, was presented. Starting from a definition of herbalism, the most important challenges to herbal whole system research were elicited with inputs from both the workshop presenters and the audience.
RESULTS: five major challenges unique to herbal whole system research were identified: (1) defining herbalists and herbalism, (2) the role of the natural products industry in herbal research, (3) designing placebos and delivering active herbal treatments as given by herbalists, (4) researching the herb as a living entity, and (5) designing trials to investigate and develop multicomponent herbal therapies.
CONCLUSIONS: unique methods and theoretical frameworks are required to design studies of herbalism. Solutions to these methodological challenges need to be addressed to conduct research that examines herbal systems of medicine versus conducting trials on individual herbs given out of their original therapeutic context
whole systems, herbalism, research methodology
97-103
Zick, Suzanna M.
532d42a8-e725-408f-8aa2-36a0118439a4
Schwabl, Herbert
8655cb5c-aa5d-4d29-98cf-707c51bf7545
Flower, Andrew
191c478b-64fd-458f-875c-a32ebdaf3b6e
Chakraborty, Bibhas
d3eaa3de-b4f7-443f-bc81-e94415bbb7a1
Hirschkorn, Kristine
0957f0c9-6366-446e-8b84-27e6b3c118d4
March 2009
Zick, Suzanna M.
532d42a8-e725-408f-8aa2-36a0118439a4
Schwabl, Herbert
8655cb5c-aa5d-4d29-98cf-707c51bf7545
Flower, Andrew
191c478b-64fd-458f-875c-a32ebdaf3b6e
Chakraborty, Bibhas
d3eaa3de-b4f7-443f-bc81-e94415bbb7a1
Hirschkorn, Kristine
0957f0c9-6366-446e-8b84-27e6b3c118d4
Zick, Suzanna M., Schwabl, Herbert, Flower, Andrew, Chakraborty, Bibhas and Hirschkorn, Kristine
(2009)
Unique aspects of herbal whole system research.
EXPLORE: The Journal of Science and Healing, 5 (2), .
(doi:10.1016/j.explore.2008.12.001).
Abstract
INTRODUCTION: whole systems of healthcare offer unique methodological and theoretical challenges for researchers. Herbalism has its own set of methodological and philosophical research issues that are beyond those presented for whole system research in general. It was our objective to explore various conceptual and methodological issues surrounding whole system herbal research.
METHODS: an International Society for Complementary Medicine Research workshop, Challenges in Herbal Whole System Research, was presented. Starting from a definition of herbalism, the most important challenges to herbal whole system research were elicited with inputs from both the workshop presenters and the audience.
RESULTS: five major challenges unique to herbal whole system research were identified: (1) defining herbalists and herbalism, (2) the role of the natural products industry in herbal research, (3) designing placebos and delivering active herbal treatments as given by herbalists, (4) researching the herb as a living entity, and (5) designing trials to investigate and develop multicomponent herbal therapies.
CONCLUSIONS: unique methods and theoretical frameworks are required to design studies of herbalism. Solutions to these methodological challenges need to be addressed to conduct research that examines herbal systems of medicine versus conducting trials on individual herbs given out of their original therapeutic context
This record has no associated files available for download.
More information
Published date: March 2009
Keywords:
whole systems, herbalism, research methodology
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 73673
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/73673
ISSN: 1550-8307
PURE UUID: 31c2f77a-62e7-43f2-8e5e-270f4daf823a
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 10 Mar 2010
Last modified: 13 Mar 2024 22:15
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Suzanna M. Zick
Author:
Herbert Schwabl
Author:
Andrew Flower
Author:
Bibhas Chakraborty
Author:
Kristine Hirschkorn
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics