What’s informing trust and adoption? Can current cognitive models support expert adoption of AI?
What’s informing trust and adoption? Can current cognitive models support expert adoption of AI?
Defence often uses rationalistic approaches for the adoption of AI, but we question whether this is appropriate. By studying adoption using naturalistic approaches in the work environment where AI is actually employed, we better can capture situated issues around trust and adoption. We conducted a longitudinal study of expert intelligence analysts adopting a machine-vision Object Detection and Recognition Overlay (ODRO) within their mission teams and tooling, premised on improving analyst functions. We employ and adapt naturalistic decision-making models to identify key situational challenges, showing that naturalistic approaches can better inform Defence’s AI adoption. Specifically, we find that organisational rewards for accuracy influence analysts’ willingness to adopt and rely on imperfect tools, and that analysts develop a non-uniform relationship with ODRO over time, which we translate into design implications. Crucially, our results support a model of interdependence over prevalent task-allocation paradigms that assume human and AI as functionally divided, rational entities.
Adoption, Artificial Intelligence, Human AI Teaming, Interdependence, Naturalistic Decision Making, Tust in Automation
158-175
Lamb, Shaun C.
c9d95012-21c5-48db-8b36-b6da3fb011b4
Byrne, Maire
a546959b-7516-49c0-8e04-a13e0639792d
Norman, Timothy J.
663e522f-807c-4569-9201-dc141c8eb50d
Ramchurn, Sarvapali D.
1d62ae2a-a498-444e-912d-a6082d3aaea3
Naiseh, Mohammad
ab9d6b3c-569c-4d7c-9bfd-61bbb8983049
June 2026
Lamb, Shaun C.
c9d95012-21c5-48db-8b36-b6da3fb011b4
Byrne, Maire
a546959b-7516-49c0-8e04-a13e0639792d
Norman, Timothy J.
663e522f-807c-4569-9201-dc141c8eb50d
Ramchurn, Sarvapali D.
1d62ae2a-a498-444e-912d-a6082d3aaea3
Naiseh, Mohammad
ab9d6b3c-569c-4d7c-9bfd-61bbb8983049
Lamb, Shaun C., Byrne, Maire, Norman, Timothy J., Ramchurn, Sarvapali D. and Naiseh, Mohammad
(2026)
What’s informing trust and adoption? Can current cognitive models support expert adoption of AI?
Journal of Cognitive Engineering and Decision Making, 20 (2), .
(doi:10.1177/15553434261430550).
Abstract
Defence often uses rationalistic approaches for the adoption of AI, but we question whether this is appropriate. By studying adoption using naturalistic approaches in the work environment where AI is actually employed, we better can capture situated issues around trust and adoption. We conducted a longitudinal study of expert intelligence analysts adopting a machine-vision Object Detection and Recognition Overlay (ODRO) within their mission teams and tooling, premised on improving analyst functions. We employ and adapt naturalistic decision-making models to identify key situational challenges, showing that naturalistic approaches can better inform Defence’s AI adoption. Specifically, we find that organisational rewards for accuracy influence analysts’ willingness to adopt and rely on imperfect tools, and that analysts develop a non-uniform relationship with ODRO over time, which we translate into design implications. Crucially, our results support a model of interdependence over prevalent task-allocation paradigms that assume human and AI as functionally divided, rational entities.
This record has no associated files available for download.
More information
e-pub ahead of print date: 18 March 2026
Published date: June 2026
Keywords:
Adoption, Artificial Intelligence, Human AI Teaming, Interdependence, Naturalistic Decision Making, Tust in Automation
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 514233
URI: https://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/514233
ISSN: 1555-3434
PURE UUID: fed73c76-1300-4949-b26a-1bde5745e8be
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 09 Sep 2026 16:45
Last modified: 13 Sep 2026 15:51
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Shaun C. Lamb
Author:
Maire Byrne
Author:
Sarvapali D. Ramchurn
Author:
Mohammad Naiseh
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics