Cognitive and Probabilistic Models of Group Decision Making
Cognitive and Probabilistic Models of Group Decision Making
We introduce an experiment designed to study trade-offs in collaborative decision making environments such as finding the best level of selectivity and abstraction in sharing information, and their impact on the time course and accuracy of group decisions. Two models of the experiment are presented: a cognitive model using the ACT-R cognitive architecture and a probabilistic argumentation model using Markov Random Fields (MARF). The cognitive model relies on memory mechanisms such as spreading activation, partial matching and blending to judge when to share information, which facts are relevant to a given question, and how to aggregate probabilistic evidence. MARF carries out real world reasoning after formal theory of human argumentation while at the same time being flexible to accommodate the deviations from the theory. MARF follows knowledge engineering paradigm aiming at reaching correct reasoning as much as possible. Representative results from the experiment are presented and compared to the results of the two models. Implications of the results and avenues for future work are discussed.
cognitive architectures, ACT-R, collective cognition, team cognition, cognitive modelling, cognitive engineering, group cognition, social simulation, cognitive social simulation, group decision-making
Tang, Yuqing
0b26bd4d-f1ab-40ab-8517-3dfc10767fa9
Lebiere, Christian
2d376f4e-98ba-45dc-819d-aec8c5f69ca5
Sycara, Katia
df200c43-d34d-4093-bb4e-493fea2d0732
Morrison, Don
dcb40dab-8f8d-495b-bca4-a089efca1970
Smart, Paul R.
cd8a3dbf-d963-4009-80fb-76ecc93579df
Stone, Paul
24354822-ffa9-4843-9c8c-9b4a1ea7e571
15 September 2015
Tang, Yuqing
0b26bd4d-f1ab-40ab-8517-3dfc10767fa9
Lebiere, Christian
2d376f4e-98ba-45dc-819d-aec8c5f69ca5
Sycara, Katia
df200c43-d34d-4093-bb4e-493fea2d0732
Morrison, Don
dcb40dab-8f8d-495b-bca4-a089efca1970
Smart, Paul R.
cd8a3dbf-d963-4009-80fb-76ecc93579df
Stone, Paul
24354822-ffa9-4843-9c8c-9b4a1ea7e571
Tang, Yuqing, Lebiere, Christian, Sycara, Katia, Morrison, Don, Smart, Paul R. and Stone, Paul
(2015)
Cognitive and Probabilistic Models of Group Decision Making.
Annual Fall Meeting of the International Technology Alliance, Maryland, United States.
15 - 17 Sep 2015.
8 pp
.
Record type:
Conference or Workshop Item
(Paper)
Abstract
We introduce an experiment designed to study trade-offs in collaborative decision making environments such as finding the best level of selectivity and abstraction in sharing information, and their impact on the time course and accuracy of group decisions. Two models of the experiment are presented: a cognitive model using the ACT-R cognitive architecture and a probabilistic argumentation model using Markov Random Fields (MARF). The cognitive model relies on memory mechanisms such as spreading activation, partial matching and blending to judge when to share information, which facts are relevant to a given question, and how to aggregate probabilistic evidence. MARF carries out real world reasoning after formal theory of human argumentation while at the same time being flexible to accommodate the deviations from the theory. MARF follows knowledge engineering paradigm aiming at reaching correct reasoning as much as possible. Representative results from the experiment are presented and compared to the results of the two models. Implications of the results and avenues for future work are discussed.
Text
ITAAFM2015v2.pdf
- Other
More information
Published date: 15 September 2015
Venue - Dates:
Annual Fall Meeting of the International Technology Alliance, Maryland, United States, 2015-09-15 - 2015-09-17
Keywords:
cognitive architectures, ACT-R, collective cognition, team cognition, cognitive modelling, cognitive engineering, group cognition, social simulation, cognitive social simulation, group decision-making
Organisations:
Web & Internet Science
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 379961
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/379961
PURE UUID: e7f7a1bf-256c-4db6-9881-c365a2faf82a
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 02 Aug 2015 22:47
Last modified: 15 Mar 2024 03:15
Export record
Contributors
Author:
Yuqing Tang
Author:
Christian Lebiere
Author:
Katia Sycara
Author:
Don Morrison
Author:
Paul R. Smart
Author:
Paul Stone
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics