Head and neck squamous cell carcinomas are characterized by a stable immune signature within the primary tumor over time and space

Abstract

Purpose: Genetic and morphological heterogeneity is well-documented in solid cancers. Immune cells are also variably distributed within the tumor; this heterogeneity is difficult to assess in small biopsies, and may confound our understanding of the determinants of successful immunotherapy. We examined the transcriptomic variability of the immunological signature in head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) within individual tumors using transcriptomic and immunohistochemical assessments. Experimental design: Forty-four tumor biopsies from 16 HNSCC patients, taken at diagnosis and later at resection, were analyzed using RNA-sequencing. Variance filtering was used to identify the top 4000 most variable genes. Principal component analysis, hierarchical clustering and correlation analysis were performed. Gene expression of CD8A was correlated to immunohistochemical analysis. Results: Analysis of immunological gene expression was highly consistent in replicates from the same cancer. Across the cohort, samples from the same patient were most similar to each other, both spatially (at diagnosis) and notably, over time (diagnostic biopsy compared to resection); comparison of global gene expression by hierarchical clustering [p=<0.0001] and correlation analysis [median intrapatient r=0.82; median interpatient r=0.63]. CD8A gene transcript counts were highly correlated with CD8 T-cell counts by immunohistochemistry (r=0.82). Conclusion: Our data demonstrate that in HNSCC the global tumor and adaptive immune signatures are stable between discrete parts of the same tumor and also at different timepoints. This suggests that immunological heterogeneity may not be a key reason for failure of immunotherapy and underpins the use of transcriptomics for immunological evaluation of novel agents in HNSCC patients.

More information

Identifiers

ORCID for Pandurangan Vijayanand: orcid.org/0000-0001-7067-9723

Catalogue record

Export record

Altmetrics