Harmonizing lipidomics: NIST interlaboratory comparison exercise for lipidomics using SRM 1950–Metabolites in Frozen Human Plasma
Harmonizing lipidomics: NIST interlaboratory comparison exercise for lipidomics using SRM 1950–Metabolites in Frozen Human Plasma
As the lipidomics field continues to advance, self-evaluation within the community is critical. Here, we performed an interlaboratory comparison exercise for lipidomics using Standard Reference Material (SRM) 1950-Metabolites in Frozen Human Plasma, a commercially available reference material. The interlaboratory study comprised 31 diverse laboratories, with each laboratory using a different lipidomics workflow. A total of 1,527 unique lipids were measured across all laboratories and consensus location estimates and associated uncertainties were determined for 339 of these lipids measured at the sum composition level by five or more participating laboratories. These evaluated lipids detected in SRM 1950 serve as community-wide benchmarks for intra- and interlaboratory quality control and method validation. These analyses were performed using nonstandardized laboratory-independent workflows. The consensus locations were also compared with a previous examination of SRM 1950 by the LIPID MAPS consortium. While the central theme of the interlaboratory study was to provide values to help harmonize lipids, lipid mediators, and precursor measurements across the community, it was also initiated to stimulate a discussion regarding areas in need of improvement
2275-2288
Bowden, John A.
121e3839-5f2c-4c06-bb9a-23bdf5aa4cfa
Heckert, Alan
19007526-9846-4567-9719-cbc21affba18
Ulmer, Candice Z.
b0f6baff-e0f1-45ad-902a-7900d2a4e34d
Jones, Christina M.
c4918f16-f963-48ac-bcfb-1c9bdb76b808
Koelmel, Jeremy P.
af7139a6-4e98-45d3-b01e-b528de29db76
Abdullah, Laila
ed4cc72f-eeca-46d1-a8ff-a5edfbe4c096
Ahonen, Linda
f4dee723-6b0c-4b37-9048-020cdceceb8d
Alnouti, Yazen
2f25cad4-a214-4fbf-a278-e6c2e65c4916
Armando, Aaron M.
0dde0efa-8f0e-478e-900f-b1db5d078f34
Asara, John M.
9c74d661-06fc-4e36-a1b7-468f36de98ff
Bamba, Takeshi
1081c9a9-0599-41c4-8810-1441a252a958
Barr, John R.
74742d08-7859-45c8-8c85-1b7bf4496435
Bergquist, Jonas
2532f2e4-2298-407b-8dcb-849d8cf8c2aa
Borchers, Christoph H.
b2e928a0-0238-4799-a1c0-25ed991e484f
Brandsma, Joost
b4c553dc-9444-466a-b352-25fd8fa25ee7
Breitkopf, Susanne B.
1a90582e-9b78-4bd2-91e0-a67d693cb849
Cajka, Tomas
38a682ae-ef25-43cb-bb6b-9b0998e01c5c
Cazenave-gassiot, Amaury
6eace962-dff6-4759-a8bf-090212014f9a
Checa, Antonio
4e268495-7b91-4e8e-ad37-9d815401cc57
Cinel, Michelle A.
18decff2-8069-4862-92da-df6b1a3f76f9
Colas, Romain A.
22462f2d-8e61-422a-909e-3b7e203e7c1b
Cremers, Serge
c0a6fde1-232c-4d06-9b2f-c4489ca93cef
Dennis, Edward A.
716a2178-f674-4dc2-9868-36565bb4c978
Evans, James E.
abc42e7b-f268-49b6-b148-5b75c5e3ec26
Fauland, Alexander
8de02226-1a4d-45d9-b943-ab4a4fd86cc1
Fiehn, Oliver
ad34137d-9d2d-4deb-a3af-596db21bc028
Gardner, Michael S.
98167548-ac0c-4283-99d2-23a716045286
Garrett, Timothy J.
95f3a6e8-2875-433a-baa0-2fdefd46f7c4
Gotlinger, Katherine H.
0f0ae857-55d8-46f4-9828-900d12d49b90
Han, Jun
6e42cb89-f5c8-4000-9029-438e5d1665f0
Huang, Yingying
1369f662-8cd0-4c6b-8bc4-eb25a0fa4fb3
Neo, Aveline Huipeng
c57a7aa0-53d1-441c-8073-d44f678b8486
Hyötyläinen, Tuulia
9cf49356-b9ba-4017-8aee-31ca492a4344
Izumi, Yoshihiro
795fb3a6-fa18-436e-a3fa-0cba73e573cf
Jiang, Hongfeng
4d6f125a-fd32-4836-bfad-1efe61453a84
Jiang, Houli
f4033e27-1d9f-4407-9354-41cacbbd44b4
Jiang, Jiang
8e08b13c-de28-466e-9936-ead4b1694307
Kachman, Maureen
95818a6b-3c2e-4df9-8c0d-9873366ce3e7
Kiyonami, Reiko
75b86d5b-502b-4fd1-9912-013df8a5aa7b
Klavins, Kristaps
13e5cc60-0657-4d75-853a-a0d97173819c
Klose, Christian
b5ebb357-1d75-478f-b45b-b372b14180c7
Köfeler, Harald C.
ce129a2d-634e-4100-a88c-1355ae85922f
Kolmert, Johan
031a7e44-0f44-45b0-a2ed-0d095d20f449
Koal, Therese
b5acd1cb-43a3-43fd-94b1-c8b16b1973f6
Koster, Grielof
e404c38a-6f48-430a-adf0-5208228cb9e7
Kuklenyik, Zsuzsanna
25079b0c-d867-4d8e-8bb3-ba2548ef637b
Kurland, Irwin J.
b60923d9-a360-430c-8be1-276d037f3afc
Leadley, Michael
d481a29a-ec2d-4259-990f-ddfb1eaeeeb0
Lin, Karen
ff54a80a-47e9-468d-ad1d-72aae45a990c
Maddipati, Krishna Rao
dda582f2-c0b1-49b9-9add-2821a8425600
Mcdougall, Danielle
281d99a4-3214-4bf2-afa8-c6e042510156
Meikle, Peter J.
25188178-afa4-475a-8a27-52e12c4ffd32
Mellett, Natalie A.
82f63154-4402-41c4-9ce7-76480bcd0eb4
Monnin, Cian
d2ab9ee7-02eb-40ad-b12b-a265a7efd7e1
Moseley, M. Arthur
eb1c3912-47df-4ae0-b48d-a1f0e15ab6ae
Nandakumar, Renu
8d14e536-7924-4407-98d4-eb2caae5ed24
Oresic, Matej
2b178124-9f65-43ce-aa8b-33cc6166b53e
Patterson, Rainey
86f568a9-a47a-411d-9b48-78c1dc054635
Peake, David
e516d39f-63ed-4623-a4d4-5bbd6199a336
Pierce, Jason S.
ca253c1d-57cf-474c-8297-d5b5c670f16b
Post, Martin
cc70999e-cb94-4842-8949-b29bb902e9e4
Postle, Anthony D.
0fa17988-b4a0-4cdc-819a-9ae15c5dad66
Pugh, Rebecca
1468eddd-1a20-4d3f-8b8d-e5f60009b8ba
Qiu, Yunping
5982e690-d507-41a4-8059-f1b7fcc69571
Quehenberger, Oswald
c264f8aa-4673-4b96-bf5b-b6f4476efe05
Ramrup, Parsram
7d896019-873e-4741-b787-9e6052b00032
Rees, Jon
44d03b37-161c-45af-8cbf-0a29fc05b31f
Rembiesa, Barbara
a39a2afa-d4af-4506-85d5-b94785e47873
Reynaud, Denis
6df72dc9-55dc-4650-bd80-585c3a51cf0b
Roth, Mary R.
b415167f-6072-44ee-9266-e3357c72e405
Sales, Susanne
6fb1964e-411b-40a2-85ed-5f600c33c208
Schuhmann, Kai
de9a4ea2-03f3-467b-ac32-d929ecbb3907
Schwartzman, Michal Laniado
c3cf5b30-1280-4c52-aca8-9559ed470261
Serhan, Charles N.
34144071-c667-45ef-90e5-2e4f894dff4a
Shevchenko, Andrej
48f00d67-20ec-489f-b408-4379f64a8ac7
Somerville, Stephen E.
68cebd57-a4c0-44e8-abcd-5b852d439ad3
St. John-williams, Lisa
b6f0389a-44e1-4120-885c-45e9e66c2daa
Surma, Michal A.
c467b870-b9da-4f24-a2fd-841bdaba345f
Takeda, Hiroaki
6d092b46-b967-43d9-93b2-dc34fc604bb2
Thakare, Rhishikesh
62c28104-c401-442c-99b3-15f5ba84522b
Thompson, J. Will
ebf49b75-5c13-4800-b409-a33b47a47afe
Torta, Federico
c05528af-6ac6-4660-a31b-6dd95dd2640c
Triebl, Alexander
98284374-8553-47a5-97dc-c154e3095c06
Trötzmüller, Martin
a371b774-e8fb-4b58-bd7b-37e4d5d458d3
Ubhayasekera, S. J. Kumari
f43029bc-8c0e-42aa-9566-e72c2473f7fe
Vuckovic, Dajana
a7341f16-0e94-4e9d-b379-be75f5bff607
Weir, Jacquelyn M.
72446347-d91a-4da2-8731-03169a1235c0
Welti, Ruth
f0dfb770-482a-49b4-a5db-23349e2c8f73
Wenk, Markus R.
d1ba356f-b0ed-4318-886a-c8f929679060
Wheelock, Craig E.
a22e130a-c8b7-4fdf-ad52-fc39635063bc
Yao, Libin
bb43d344-47b2-4bb2-b0ff-7d67804cad47
Yuan, Min
1a413280-2314-4072-8266-1bf75fd1f079
Zhao, Xueqing Heather
fe2683fa-9741-4bd5-8dbc-d7421f049a82
Zhou, Senlin
f88b366d-b768-4758-a3d6-f75b5941d6f8
1 December 2017
Bowden, John A.
121e3839-5f2c-4c06-bb9a-23bdf5aa4cfa
Heckert, Alan
19007526-9846-4567-9719-cbc21affba18
Ulmer, Candice Z.
b0f6baff-e0f1-45ad-902a-7900d2a4e34d
Jones, Christina M.
c4918f16-f963-48ac-bcfb-1c9bdb76b808
Koelmel, Jeremy P.
af7139a6-4e98-45d3-b01e-b528de29db76
Abdullah, Laila
ed4cc72f-eeca-46d1-a8ff-a5edfbe4c096
Ahonen, Linda
f4dee723-6b0c-4b37-9048-020cdceceb8d
Alnouti, Yazen
2f25cad4-a214-4fbf-a278-e6c2e65c4916
Armando, Aaron M.
0dde0efa-8f0e-478e-900f-b1db5d078f34
Asara, John M.
9c74d661-06fc-4e36-a1b7-468f36de98ff
Bamba, Takeshi
1081c9a9-0599-41c4-8810-1441a252a958
Barr, John R.
74742d08-7859-45c8-8c85-1b7bf4496435
Bergquist, Jonas
2532f2e4-2298-407b-8dcb-849d8cf8c2aa
Borchers, Christoph H.
b2e928a0-0238-4799-a1c0-25ed991e484f
Brandsma, Joost
b4c553dc-9444-466a-b352-25fd8fa25ee7
Breitkopf, Susanne B.
1a90582e-9b78-4bd2-91e0-a67d693cb849
Cajka, Tomas
38a682ae-ef25-43cb-bb6b-9b0998e01c5c
Cazenave-gassiot, Amaury
6eace962-dff6-4759-a8bf-090212014f9a
Checa, Antonio
4e268495-7b91-4e8e-ad37-9d815401cc57
Cinel, Michelle A.
18decff2-8069-4862-92da-df6b1a3f76f9
Colas, Romain A.
22462f2d-8e61-422a-909e-3b7e203e7c1b
Cremers, Serge
c0a6fde1-232c-4d06-9b2f-c4489ca93cef
Dennis, Edward A.
716a2178-f674-4dc2-9868-36565bb4c978
Evans, James E.
abc42e7b-f268-49b6-b148-5b75c5e3ec26
Fauland, Alexander
8de02226-1a4d-45d9-b943-ab4a4fd86cc1
Fiehn, Oliver
ad34137d-9d2d-4deb-a3af-596db21bc028
Gardner, Michael S.
98167548-ac0c-4283-99d2-23a716045286
Garrett, Timothy J.
95f3a6e8-2875-433a-baa0-2fdefd46f7c4
Gotlinger, Katherine H.
0f0ae857-55d8-46f4-9828-900d12d49b90
Han, Jun
6e42cb89-f5c8-4000-9029-438e5d1665f0
Huang, Yingying
1369f662-8cd0-4c6b-8bc4-eb25a0fa4fb3
Neo, Aveline Huipeng
c57a7aa0-53d1-441c-8073-d44f678b8486
Hyötyläinen, Tuulia
9cf49356-b9ba-4017-8aee-31ca492a4344
Izumi, Yoshihiro
795fb3a6-fa18-436e-a3fa-0cba73e573cf
Jiang, Hongfeng
4d6f125a-fd32-4836-bfad-1efe61453a84
Jiang, Houli
f4033e27-1d9f-4407-9354-41cacbbd44b4
Jiang, Jiang
8e08b13c-de28-466e-9936-ead4b1694307
Kachman, Maureen
95818a6b-3c2e-4df9-8c0d-9873366ce3e7
Kiyonami, Reiko
75b86d5b-502b-4fd1-9912-013df8a5aa7b
Klavins, Kristaps
13e5cc60-0657-4d75-853a-a0d97173819c
Klose, Christian
b5ebb357-1d75-478f-b45b-b372b14180c7
Köfeler, Harald C.
ce129a2d-634e-4100-a88c-1355ae85922f
Kolmert, Johan
031a7e44-0f44-45b0-a2ed-0d095d20f449
Koal, Therese
b5acd1cb-43a3-43fd-94b1-c8b16b1973f6
Koster, Grielof
e404c38a-6f48-430a-adf0-5208228cb9e7
Kuklenyik, Zsuzsanna
25079b0c-d867-4d8e-8bb3-ba2548ef637b
Kurland, Irwin J.
b60923d9-a360-430c-8be1-276d037f3afc
Leadley, Michael
d481a29a-ec2d-4259-990f-ddfb1eaeeeb0
Lin, Karen
ff54a80a-47e9-468d-ad1d-72aae45a990c
Maddipati, Krishna Rao
dda582f2-c0b1-49b9-9add-2821a8425600
Mcdougall, Danielle
281d99a4-3214-4bf2-afa8-c6e042510156
Meikle, Peter J.
25188178-afa4-475a-8a27-52e12c4ffd32
Mellett, Natalie A.
82f63154-4402-41c4-9ce7-76480bcd0eb4
Monnin, Cian
d2ab9ee7-02eb-40ad-b12b-a265a7efd7e1
Moseley, M. Arthur
eb1c3912-47df-4ae0-b48d-a1f0e15ab6ae
Nandakumar, Renu
8d14e536-7924-4407-98d4-eb2caae5ed24
Oresic, Matej
2b178124-9f65-43ce-aa8b-33cc6166b53e
Patterson, Rainey
86f568a9-a47a-411d-9b48-78c1dc054635
Peake, David
e516d39f-63ed-4623-a4d4-5bbd6199a336
Pierce, Jason S.
ca253c1d-57cf-474c-8297-d5b5c670f16b
Post, Martin
cc70999e-cb94-4842-8949-b29bb902e9e4
Postle, Anthony D.
0fa17988-b4a0-4cdc-819a-9ae15c5dad66
Pugh, Rebecca
1468eddd-1a20-4d3f-8b8d-e5f60009b8ba
Qiu, Yunping
5982e690-d507-41a4-8059-f1b7fcc69571
Quehenberger, Oswald
c264f8aa-4673-4b96-bf5b-b6f4476efe05
Ramrup, Parsram
7d896019-873e-4741-b787-9e6052b00032
Rees, Jon
44d03b37-161c-45af-8cbf-0a29fc05b31f
Rembiesa, Barbara
a39a2afa-d4af-4506-85d5-b94785e47873
Reynaud, Denis
6df72dc9-55dc-4650-bd80-585c3a51cf0b
Roth, Mary R.
b415167f-6072-44ee-9266-e3357c72e405
Sales, Susanne
6fb1964e-411b-40a2-85ed-5f600c33c208
Schuhmann, Kai
de9a4ea2-03f3-467b-ac32-d929ecbb3907
Schwartzman, Michal Laniado
c3cf5b30-1280-4c52-aca8-9559ed470261
Serhan, Charles N.
34144071-c667-45ef-90e5-2e4f894dff4a
Shevchenko, Andrej
48f00d67-20ec-489f-b408-4379f64a8ac7
Somerville, Stephen E.
68cebd57-a4c0-44e8-abcd-5b852d439ad3
St. John-williams, Lisa
b6f0389a-44e1-4120-885c-45e9e66c2daa
Surma, Michal A.
c467b870-b9da-4f24-a2fd-841bdaba345f
Takeda, Hiroaki
6d092b46-b967-43d9-93b2-dc34fc604bb2
Thakare, Rhishikesh
62c28104-c401-442c-99b3-15f5ba84522b
Thompson, J. Will
ebf49b75-5c13-4800-b409-a33b47a47afe
Torta, Federico
c05528af-6ac6-4660-a31b-6dd95dd2640c
Triebl, Alexander
98284374-8553-47a5-97dc-c154e3095c06
Trötzmüller, Martin
a371b774-e8fb-4b58-bd7b-37e4d5d458d3
Ubhayasekera, S. J. Kumari
f43029bc-8c0e-42aa-9566-e72c2473f7fe
Vuckovic, Dajana
a7341f16-0e94-4e9d-b379-be75f5bff607
Weir, Jacquelyn M.
72446347-d91a-4da2-8731-03169a1235c0
Welti, Ruth
f0dfb770-482a-49b4-a5db-23349e2c8f73
Wenk, Markus R.
d1ba356f-b0ed-4318-886a-c8f929679060
Wheelock, Craig E.
a22e130a-c8b7-4fdf-ad52-fc39635063bc
Yao, Libin
bb43d344-47b2-4bb2-b0ff-7d67804cad47
Yuan, Min
1a413280-2314-4072-8266-1bf75fd1f079
Zhao, Xueqing Heather
fe2683fa-9741-4bd5-8dbc-d7421f049a82
Zhou, Senlin
f88b366d-b768-4758-a3d6-f75b5941d6f8