The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Country‐level correlates of the dark triad traits in 49 countries

Country‐level correlates of the dark triad traits in 49 countries
Country‐level correlates of the dark triad traits in 49 countries

Objectives: The Dark Triad traits (i.e., narcissism, psychopathy, Machiavellianism) capture individual differences in aversive personality to complement work on other taxonomies, such as the Big Five traits. However, the literature on the Dark Triad traits relies mostly on samples from English-speaking (i.e., Westernized) countries. We broadened the scope of this literature by sampling from a wider array of countries. Method: We drew on data from 49 countries (N = 11,723; 65.8% female; Age Mean = 21.53) to examine how an extensive net of country-level variables in economic status (e.g., Human Development Index), social relations (e.g., gender equality), political orientations (e.g., democracy), and cultural values (e.g., embeddedness) relate to country-level rates of the Dark Triad traits, as well as variance in the magnitude of sex differences in them. Results: Narcissism was especially sensitive to country-level variables. Countries with more embedded and hierarchical cultural systems were more narcissistic. Also, sex differences in narcissism were larger in more developed societies: Women were less likely to be narcissistic in developed (vs. less developed) countries. Conclusions: We discuss the results based on evolutionary and social role models of personality and sex differences. That higher country-level narcissism was more common in less developed countries, whereas sex differences in narcissism were larger in more developed countries, is more consistent with evolutionary than social role models.

Dark Triad, Machiavellianism, cross-cultural, cultural values, narcissism, psychopathy
0022-3506
1252-1267
Jonason, Peter K.
53dd4f55-6834-4b62-936c-cd3783dbb79c
Żemojtel‐piotrowska, Magdalena
d0c6a0f9-f648-439f-adf1-1cc6e7581b3e
Piotrowski, Jarosław
92257102-c5e6-47e8-a3c4-e8c7ef98fb99
Sedikides, Constantine
9d45e66d-75bb-44de-87d7-21fd553812c2
Campbell, W. Keith
b2b89c15-61d6-4683-aeb7-ff9674ac82c3
Gebauer, Jochen E.
ed37e5ba-19a2-4b6a-963b-a31e4704059e
Maltby, John
49f02da9-de80-4604-a7b3-abd7b0217b9d
Adamovic, Mladen
f51b5430-56a8-4f18-9def-4e8c801e4cd5
Adams, Byron G.
f0badd9d-a108-4aea-ae09-ea34006c5c5a
Kadiyono, Anissa Lestari
46759ebe-bb2c-449b-9979-f67225b3ac92
Atitsogbe, Kokou A.
36879fce-dd84-4a2e-98f4-009b4c8ce07f
Bundhoo, Harshalini Y.
b8939f01-0962-419c-879a-02652043f52e
Bălțătescu, Sergiu
dc930ff2-ffd7-4444-a377-c9485555153d
Bilić, Snežana
cee2cfb1-cdd5-45ff-a2ff-b0021d95e5c8
Brulin, Joel Gruneau
57179f1b-682a-400f-aaf7-c78a3b0f9fed
Chobthamkit, Phatthanakit
85763af1-73a1-4c44-8bd2-93f30eeff312
Del Carmen Dominguez, Alejandra
68a04f81-536f-43f6-9dce-ae9d47afb2d4
Dragova‐koleva, Sonya
024fc3f2-15d0-4ae5-9557-8068eaa96ada
El‐asta, Sofián
7379435c-ab0d-4690-a445-e278616385e7
Esteves, Carla Sofia
e921b926-3736-4b19-a826-dc3ca46faaf8
Labib M. Eldesoki, Walaa
79436e61-d7b9-4c7a-9d1e-22b1b356980d
Gouveia, Valdiney V.
39e4972f-4179-4b1e-b613-b517e994b9e1
Gundolf, Katherine
6b2cf3a9-93f6-4ffd-a9aa-2cbba16d4685
Ilisko, Dzintra
d4ece114-9c31-42f3-8c12-175f53ace1e7
Jauk, Emanuel
e9752ec5-42b7-4a3c-9abc-99d865480d47
Kamble, Shanmukh V.
4e390744-b781-4eaa-a534-8caa74652547
Khachatryan, Narine
4935018a-72ba-436a-8fcb-c42e4ef2df7b
Klicperova‐baker, Martina
8d6936f1-5108-41a4-a796-8da6c3ec3b7c
Knezovic, Emil
23273fa3-b5e8-495a-9a5e-b8580b693df7
Kovacs, Monika
cc873cc9-0927-4082-8429-342c29d1f89e
Lei, Xuejun
46ad6336-c22b-4db5-adfe-e57ca1e7349f
Liik, Kadi
35bb9ae1-3086-4414-a4d6-2f86d69f9ba6
Mamuti, Agim
b590bd2d-4381-4f32-ac53-8729fef88029
Moreta‐herrera, Carlos Rodrigo
a020536f-d75c-47e0-9ec0-1340c30e1262
Milfont, Taciano L.
7c001c94-527b-4f62-8f1f-49af37ddff52
Wei Ong, Chin
9edc7bef-35e5-48f3-a41b-51c38f3ada6b
Osin, Evgeny
33a9ec3e-f494-4828-a89c-6329d5732627
Park, Joonha
5dc9e95d-40e9-45e2-b7da-367908d2a759
Petrovic, Boban
96d3b8ba-bdcb-43f5-ab20-97add604a212
Ramos‐diaz, Jano
50718564-9734-4a24-bfac-3b3df0771b06
Ridic, Goran
303710b7-e833-47c9-96bc-e7c52ada4a81
Qadir, Abdul
9f35b59b-ccfd-49a2-8da0-1b7c4dd17c2d
Samekin, Adil
e82117a5-19a7-4de5-9781-ea4aa46de137
Sawicki, Artur
1e65c355-6531-48bc-9441-55767a671be2
Tiliouine, Habib
ed0eac79-d97b-4635-84e8-e88f9ec1f8ae
Tomsik, Robert
2b88380a-e738-49d4-8ab3-265715a9113f
Umeh, Charles S.
97ab0f90-0854-4ed0-ac3b-058d7f775564
Van Den Bos, Kees
2522867e-e9eb-4716-a870-aa483d6f69ab
Van Hiel, Alain
9b4478e7-9679-47bc-862f-2907820443d0
Uslu, Osman
52f4881d-57a2-4049-8e16-4e7c8b8b4669
Wlodarczyk, Anna
2b074795-051c-4f53-8aed-a7142edb5595
Yahiiaev, Illia
184f7d23-f800-4db3-b093-030a84e8a827
Jonason, Peter K.
53dd4f55-6834-4b62-936c-cd3783dbb79c
Żemojtel‐piotrowska, Magdalena
d0c6a0f9-f648-439f-adf1-1cc6e7581b3e
Piotrowski, Jarosław
92257102-c5e6-47e8-a3c4-e8c7ef98fb99
Sedikides, Constantine
9d45e66d-75bb-44de-87d7-21fd553812c2
Campbell, W. Keith
b2b89c15-61d6-4683-aeb7-ff9674ac82c3
Gebauer, Jochen E.
ed37e5ba-19a2-4b6a-963b-a31e4704059e
Maltby, John
49f02da9-de80-4604-a7b3-abd7b0217b9d
Adamovic, Mladen
f51b5430-56a8-4f18-9def-4e8c801e4cd5
Adams, Byron G.
f0badd9d-a108-4aea-ae09-ea34006c5c5a
Kadiyono, Anissa Lestari
46759ebe-bb2c-449b-9979-f67225b3ac92
Atitsogbe, Kokou A.
36879fce-dd84-4a2e-98f4-009b4c8ce07f
Bundhoo, Harshalini Y.
b8939f01-0962-419c-879a-02652043f52e
Bălțătescu, Sergiu
dc930ff2-ffd7-4444-a377-c9485555153d
Bilić, Snežana
cee2cfb1-cdd5-45ff-a2ff-b0021d95e5c8
Brulin, Joel Gruneau
57179f1b-682a-400f-aaf7-c78a3b0f9fed
Chobthamkit, Phatthanakit
85763af1-73a1-4c44-8bd2-93f30eeff312
Del Carmen Dominguez, Alejandra
68a04f81-536f-43f6-9dce-ae9d47afb2d4
Dragova‐koleva, Sonya
024fc3f2-15d0-4ae5-9557-8068eaa96ada
El‐asta, Sofián
7379435c-ab0d-4690-a445-e278616385e7
Esteves, Carla Sofia
e921b926-3736-4b19-a826-dc3ca46faaf8
Labib M. Eldesoki, Walaa
79436e61-d7b9-4c7a-9d1e-22b1b356980d
Gouveia, Valdiney V.
39e4972f-4179-4b1e-b613-b517e994b9e1
Gundolf, Katherine
6b2cf3a9-93f6-4ffd-a9aa-2cbba16d4685
Ilisko, Dzintra
d4ece114-9c31-42f3-8c12-175f53ace1e7
Jauk, Emanuel
e9752ec5-42b7-4a3c-9abc-99d865480d47
Kamble, Shanmukh V.
4e390744-b781-4eaa-a534-8caa74652547
Khachatryan, Narine
4935018a-72ba-436a-8fcb-c42e4ef2df7b
Klicperova‐baker, Martina
8d6936f1-5108-41a4-a796-8da6c3ec3b7c
Knezovic, Emil
23273fa3-b5e8-495a-9a5e-b8580b693df7
Kovacs, Monika
cc873cc9-0927-4082-8429-342c29d1f89e
Lei, Xuejun
46ad6336-c22b-4db5-adfe-e57ca1e7349f
Liik, Kadi
35bb9ae1-3086-4414-a4d6-2f86d69f9ba6
Mamuti, Agim
b590bd2d-4381-4f32-ac53-8729fef88029
Moreta‐herrera, Carlos Rodrigo
a020536f-d75c-47e0-9ec0-1340c30e1262
Milfont, Taciano L.
7c001c94-527b-4f62-8f1f-49af37ddff52
Wei Ong, Chin
9edc7bef-35e5-48f3-a41b-51c38f3ada6b
Osin, Evgeny
33a9ec3e-f494-4828-a89c-6329d5732627
Park, Joonha
5dc9e95d-40e9-45e2-b7da-367908d2a759
Petrovic, Boban
96d3b8ba-bdcb-43f5-ab20-97add604a212
Ramos‐diaz, Jano
50718564-9734-4a24-bfac-3b3df0771b06
Ridic, Goran
303710b7-e833-47c9-96bc-e7c52ada4a81
Qadir, Abdul
9f35b59b-ccfd-49a2-8da0-1b7c4dd17c2d
Samekin, Adil
e82117a5-19a7-4de5-9781-ea4aa46de137
Sawicki, Artur
1e65c355-6531-48bc-9441-55767a671be2
Tiliouine, Habib
ed0eac79-d97b-4635-84e8-e88f9ec1f8ae
Tomsik, Robert
2b88380a-e738-49d4-8ab3-265715a9113f
Umeh, Charles S.
97ab0f90-0854-4ed0-ac3b-058d7f775564
Van Den Bos, Kees
2522867e-e9eb-4716-a870-aa483d6f69ab
Van Hiel, Alain
9b4478e7-9679-47bc-862f-2907820443d0
Uslu, Osman
52f4881d-57a2-4049-8e16-4e7c8b8b4669
Wlodarczyk, Anna
2b074795-051c-4f53-8aed-a7142edb5595
Yahiiaev, Illia
184f7d23-f800-4db3-b093-030a84e8a827

Jonason, Peter K., Żemojtel‐piotrowska, Magdalena, Piotrowski, Jarosław, Sedikides, Constantine, Campbell, W. Keith, Gebauer, Jochen E., Maltby, John, Adamovic, Mladen, Adams, Byron G., Kadiyono, Anissa Lestari, Atitsogbe, Kokou A., Bundhoo, Harshalini Y., Bălțătescu, Sergiu, Bilić, Snežana, Brulin, Joel Gruneau, Chobthamkit, Phatthanakit, Del Carmen Dominguez, Alejandra, Dragova‐koleva, Sonya, El‐asta, Sofián, Esteves, Carla Sofia, Labib M. Eldesoki, Walaa, Gouveia, Valdiney V., Gundolf, Katherine, Ilisko, Dzintra, Jauk, Emanuel, Kamble, Shanmukh V., Khachatryan, Narine, Klicperova‐baker, Martina, Knezovic, Emil, Kovacs, Monika, Lei, Xuejun, Liik, Kadi, Mamuti, Agim, Moreta‐herrera, Carlos Rodrigo, Milfont, Taciano L., Wei Ong, Chin, Osin, Evgeny, Park, Joonha, Petrovic, Boban, Ramos‐diaz, Jano, Ridic, Goran, Qadir, Abdul, Samekin, Adil, Sawicki, Artur, Tiliouine, Habib, Tomsik, Robert, Umeh, Charles S., Van Den Bos, Kees, Van Hiel, Alain, Uslu, Osman, Wlodarczyk, Anna and Yahiiaev, Illia (2020) Country‐level correlates of the dark triad traits in 49 countries. Journal of Personality, 88 (6), 1252-1267. (doi:10.1111/jopy.12569).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Objectives: The Dark Triad traits (i.e., narcissism, psychopathy, Machiavellianism) capture individual differences in aversive personality to complement work on other taxonomies, such as the Big Five traits. However, the literature on the Dark Triad traits relies mostly on samples from English-speaking (i.e., Westernized) countries. We broadened the scope of this literature by sampling from a wider array of countries. Method: We drew on data from 49 countries (N = 11,723; 65.8% female; Age Mean = 21.53) to examine how an extensive net of country-level variables in economic status (e.g., Human Development Index), social relations (e.g., gender equality), political orientations (e.g., democracy), and cultural values (e.g., embeddedness) relate to country-level rates of the Dark Triad traits, as well as variance in the magnitude of sex differences in them. Results: Narcissism was especially sensitive to country-level variables. Countries with more embedded and hierarchical cultural systems were more narcissistic. Also, sex differences in narcissism were larger in more developed societies: Women were less likely to be narcissistic in developed (vs. less developed) countries. Conclusions: We discuss the results based on evolutionary and social role models of personality and sex differences. That higher country-level narcissism was more common in less developed countries, whereas sex differences in narcissism were larger in more developed countries, is more consistent with evolutionary than social role models.

Text
Jonason et al._2020, Journal of Personality - Accepted Manuscript
Download (105kB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 1 February 2020
e-pub ahead of print date: 18 June 2020
Published date: 1 December 2020
Additional Information: Funding Information: We thank Jeremy Frimer for providing the Canadian sample, Shalom H. Schwartz for commenting our paper prior to submission, and Rados?aw Rogoza for statistical consultation regarding cross-cultural invariance. The authors disclosed receipt of the following financial support for the research, authorship, and/or publication of this article: Peter Jonason was partially funded by a grant from the Polish National Agency for Academic Exchange (PPN/ULM/2019/1/00019/U/00001). Magdalena ?emojtel-Piotrowska and Jaros?aw Piotrowski were supported by a grant from the Polish National Science Centre (2016/21/B/HS6/01069). Kokou A. Atitsogbe was supported by a Swiss Government Excellence PhD Scholarship no. 2015.0639/Togo/OP. Valdiney V. Gouveia was supported by the Brazilian National Council of Technological and Scientific Development. Joel Gruneau Brulin was supported by a John Templeton Foundation grant (51897). Martina Klicperova-Baker was supported by grants from the Grant Agency of the Czech Republic (#15-11062S) and the Czech Academy of Sciences (RVO 68081740). Evgeny Osin was supported by a grant from the Russian Academic Excellence (5-100). Publisher Copyright: © 2020 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.
Keywords: Dark Triad, Machiavellianism, cross-cultural, cultural values, narcissism, psychopathy

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 441748
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/441748
ISSN: 0022-3506
PURE UUID: f469a879-64c7-4016-8927-f6a54f24ad45
ORCID for Constantine Sedikides: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0003-4036-889X

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 25 Jun 2020 16:48
Last modified: 16 Apr 2024 04:02

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Peter K. Jonason
Author: Magdalena Żemojtel‐piotrowska
Author: Jarosław Piotrowski
Author: W. Keith Campbell
Author: Jochen E. Gebauer
Author: John Maltby
Author: Mladen Adamovic
Author: Byron G. Adams
Author: Anissa Lestari Kadiyono
Author: Kokou A. Atitsogbe
Author: Harshalini Y. Bundhoo
Author: Sergiu Bălțătescu
Author: Snežana Bilić
Author: Joel Gruneau Brulin
Author: Phatthanakit Chobthamkit
Author: Alejandra Del Carmen Dominguez
Author: Sonya Dragova‐koleva
Author: Sofián El‐asta
Author: Carla Sofia Esteves
Author: Walaa Labib M. Eldesoki
Author: Valdiney V. Gouveia
Author: Katherine Gundolf
Author: Dzintra Ilisko
Author: Emanuel Jauk
Author: Shanmukh V. Kamble
Author: Narine Khachatryan
Author: Martina Klicperova‐baker
Author: Emil Knezovic
Author: Monika Kovacs
Author: Xuejun Lei
Author: Kadi Liik
Author: Agim Mamuti
Author: Carlos Rodrigo Moreta‐herrera
Author: Taciano L. Milfont
Author: Chin Wei Ong
Author: Evgeny Osin
Author: Joonha Park
Author: Boban Petrovic
Author: Jano Ramos‐diaz
Author: Goran Ridic
Author: Abdul Qadir
Author: Adil Samekin
Author: Artur Sawicki
Author: Habib Tiliouine
Author: Robert Tomsik
Author: Charles S. Umeh
Author: Kees Van Den Bos
Author: Alain Van Hiel
Author: Osman Uslu
Author: Anna Wlodarczyk
Author: Illia Yahiiaev

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×