Evidence-based conservation in a changing world: lessons from waterbird individual-based models
Evidence-based conservation in a changing world: lessons from waterbird individual-based models
Drivers of environmental change are causing novel combinations of pressures on ecological systems. Prediction in ecology often uses understanding of past conditions to make predictions to the future, but such an approach can breakdown when future conditions have not previously been encountered. Individual-based models (IBMs) consider ecological systems as arising from the adaptive behavior and fates of individuals and have potential to provide more reliable predictions. To demonstrate potential, we review a lineage of related IBMs addressing the effects of environmental change on waterbirds, comprising 53 case studies of 28 species in 32 sites in 9 countries, using the Drivers-Pressures-State-Impact-Response (DPSIR) environmental management framework. Each case study comprises the predictions of an IBM on the effects of one or more drivers of environmental change on one or more bird species. Drivers exert a pressure on the environment which is represented in the IBMs as changes in either area or time available for feeding, the quality of habitat, or the energetic cost of living within an environment. Birds in the IBMs adapt to increased pressure by altering their behavioral state, defined as their location, diet, and the proportion of time spent feeding. If the birds are not able to compensate behaviorally, they suffer a physiological impact, determined by a decrease in body energy reserves, increased mortality, or decreased ability to migrate. Each case study assesses the impact of alternative drivers and potential ways to mitigate impacts to advise appropriate conservation management responses. We overview the lessons learned from the case studies and highlight the opportunities of using IBMs to inform conservation management for other species. Key findings indicate that understanding the behavioral and physiological processes that determine whether or not birds survive following a change in their environment is vital, so that mitigation measures can be better targeted. This is especially important where multiple hazards exist so that sensitivities and worse-case scenarios can be better understood. Increasing the involvement of stakeholders to help inform and shape model development is encouraged and can lead to better representation of the modeled system and wider understanding and support for the final model.
Brown, Sally
dd3c5852-78cc-435a-9846-4f3f540f2840
Stillman, Richard A
33285c61-962d-4ab0-966c-4061d01b4e84
Brown, Sally
dd3c5852-78cc-435a-9846-4f3f540f2840
Stillman, Richard A
33285c61-962d-4ab0-966c-4061d01b4e84
Brown, Sally and Stillman, Richard A
(2021)
Evidence-based conservation in a changing world: lessons from waterbird individual-based models.
Ecosphere, 12 (7).
(doi:10.1002/ecs2.3632).
Abstract
Drivers of environmental change are causing novel combinations of pressures on ecological systems. Prediction in ecology often uses understanding of past conditions to make predictions to the future, but such an approach can breakdown when future conditions have not previously been encountered. Individual-based models (IBMs) consider ecological systems as arising from the adaptive behavior and fates of individuals and have potential to provide more reliable predictions. To demonstrate potential, we review a lineage of related IBMs addressing the effects of environmental change on waterbirds, comprising 53 case studies of 28 species in 32 sites in 9 countries, using the Drivers-Pressures-State-Impact-Response (DPSIR) environmental management framework. Each case study comprises the predictions of an IBM on the effects of one or more drivers of environmental change on one or more bird species. Drivers exert a pressure on the environment which is represented in the IBMs as changes in either area or time available for feeding, the quality of habitat, or the energetic cost of living within an environment. Birds in the IBMs adapt to increased pressure by altering their behavioral state, defined as their location, diet, and the proportion of time spent feeding. If the birds are not able to compensate behaviorally, they suffer a physiological impact, determined by a decrease in body energy reserves, increased mortality, or decreased ability to migrate. Each case study assesses the impact of alternative drivers and potential ways to mitigate impacts to advise appropriate conservation management responses. We overview the lessons learned from the case studies and highlight the opportunities of using IBMs to inform conservation management for other species. Key findings indicate that understanding the behavioral and physiological processes that determine whether or not birds survive following a change in their environment is vital, so that mitigation measures can be better targeted. This is especially important where multiple hazards exist so that sensitivities and worse-case scenarios can be better understood. Increasing the involvement of stakeholders to help inform and shape model development is encouraged and can lead to better representation of the modeled system and wider understanding and support for the final model.
Text
waterbirds_brown_stillman_revised_brian
- Accepted Manuscript
Text
brown_stillman_read_me
- Accepted Manuscript
Spreadsheet
appendix_s2_final
- Accepted Manuscript
Text
appendix_s1_final
- Accepted Manuscript
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 19 February 2021
e-pub ahead of print date: 5 July 2021
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 471136
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/471136
ISSN: 2150-8925
PURE UUID: 842a07ab-8619-4a4d-bbf6-dd28cb9d7851
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 27 Oct 2022 16:47
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 03:15
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Richard A Stillman
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics