The relationship between dental wear and age at death in British archaeological human skeletal remains: a re-evaluation of the ‘Brothwell chart’
The relationship between dental wear and age at death in British archaeological human skeletal remains: a re-evaluation of the ‘Brothwell chart’
The chart relating molar wear to age published by Brothwell in 1963 is widely used to estimate age at death in archaeological adult human skeletal remains, especially in Britain, but also more widely. The chart was based on examination of juvenile and adult dentitions from Neolithic to Medieval periods from Britain, but few further details of materials and methods were given. The aim of this work is to re-assess the value of molar wear for estimating age at death for adult human remains in Britain and, if necessary, to provide an updated replacement for the Brothwell chart. 870 dentitions (juveniles with at least one permanent molar erupted and adults) were examined dating from the Neolithic period onward. The aim was to use a Miles-like method to assess the relationship between molar wear and age – i.e. to calibrate wear rates using juvenile dentitions and then, by extrapolating from this baseline, estimating age from wear in individuals with successively more worn dentitions. We validate some key assumptions of the method. Molar wear bears a consistent relationship to dental age in juveniles and does not appear to vary greatly from Neolithic to Medieval times, nor in the post-Medieval rural group studied. First and second molars appear to wear at similar rates, as do third molars except in dentitions where wear is very advanced. The estimated rate of molar wear is somewhat slower than that estimated by Brothwell. The results allow a chart to be presented that replaces Brothwell’s (1963) chart, and permits age estimation from molar wear in British archaeological human remains dating from Neolithic to Medieval times and, tentatively, for rural post-Medieval remains. It is not applicable to post-Medieval remains from most urban contexts where dental wear is much reduced.
molars, wear stage, tooth crown height, age estimation, Miles method
Mays, Simon
dc5486e7-0b03-494e-a274-7e57c8b8d34c
Zakrzewski, Sonia
d80afd94-feff-4fe8-96e9-f3db79bba99d
Field, S.
65417123-b278-49df-aeb0-b83c94398b97
5 November 2022
Mays, Simon
dc5486e7-0b03-494e-a274-7e57c8b8d34c
Zakrzewski, Sonia
d80afd94-feff-4fe8-96e9-f3db79bba99d
Field, S.
65417123-b278-49df-aeb0-b83c94398b97
Mays, Simon, Zakrzewski, Sonia and Field, S.
(2022)
The relationship between dental wear and age at death in British archaeological human skeletal remains: a re-evaluation of the ‘Brothwell chart’.
Journal of Archaeological Science: Reports, 46, [103707].
Abstract
The chart relating molar wear to age published by Brothwell in 1963 is widely used to estimate age at death in archaeological adult human skeletal remains, especially in Britain, but also more widely. The chart was based on examination of juvenile and adult dentitions from Neolithic to Medieval periods from Britain, but few further details of materials and methods were given. The aim of this work is to re-assess the value of molar wear for estimating age at death for adult human remains in Britain and, if necessary, to provide an updated replacement for the Brothwell chart. 870 dentitions (juveniles with at least one permanent molar erupted and adults) were examined dating from the Neolithic period onward. The aim was to use a Miles-like method to assess the relationship between molar wear and age – i.e. to calibrate wear rates using juvenile dentitions and then, by extrapolating from this baseline, estimating age from wear in individuals with successively more worn dentitions. We validate some key assumptions of the method. Molar wear bears a consistent relationship to dental age in juveniles and does not appear to vary greatly from Neolithic to Medieval times, nor in the post-Medieval rural group studied. First and second molars appear to wear at similar rates, as do third molars except in dentitions where wear is very advanced. The estimated rate of molar wear is somewhat slower than that estimated by Brothwell. The results allow a chart to be presented that replaces Brothwell’s (1963) chart, and permits age estimation from molar wear in British archaeological human remains dating from Neolithic to Medieval times and, tentatively, for rural post-Medieval remains. It is not applicable to post-Medieval remains from most urban contexts where dental wear is much reduced.
Text
wearpaperR1a
- Accepted Manuscript
Text
1-s2.0-S2213260022001631-main
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 21 October 2022
e-pub ahead of print date: 5 November 2022
Published date: 5 November 2022
Keywords:
molars, wear stage, tooth crown height, age estimation, Miles method
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 471766
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/471766
ISSN: 2352-409X
PURE UUID: ed11093c-2276-4531-a7ef-03fc70e15048
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 17 Nov 2022 17:50
Last modified: 17 Mar 2024 02:57
Export record
Contributors
Author:
S. Field
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics
