Convergently evolved placental villi show multiscale structural adaptations to differential placental invasiveness
Convergently evolved placental villi show multiscale structural adaptations to differential placental invasiveness
Despite having a single evolutionary origin and conserved function, the mammalian placenta exhibits radical structural diversity. The evolutionary drivers and functional consequences of placental structural diversity are poorly understood. Humans and equids both display treelike placental villi, however these villi evolved independently and exhibit starkly different levels of invasiveness into maternal tissue (i.e. the number of maternal tissue layers between placental tissue and maternal blood). The villi in these species therefore serve as a compelling evolutionary case study to explore whether placentas have developed structural adaptations to respond to the challenge of reduced nutrient availability in less invasive placentas. Here, we use three-dimensional X-ray microfocus computed tomography and electron microscopy to quantitatively evaluate key structures involved in exchange in human and equid placental villi. We find that equid villi have a higher surface area to volume ratio and deeper trophoblastic vessel indentation than human villi. Using illustrative computational models, we propose that these structural adaptations have evolved in equids to boost nutrient transfer to compensate for reduced invasiveness into maternal tissue. We discuss these findings in relation to the 'maternal-fetal conflict hypothesis' of placental evolution.
Animals, Chorionic Villi, Female, Humans, Mammals, Placenta, Pregnancy
Laundon, Davis
b2ba5687-d949-47dd-b84f-fb3c0c032550
Sengers, Bram G.
d6b771b1-4ede-48c5-9644-fa86503941aa
Thompson, James
a0a1e940-d720-47de-81d7-ebcd48738239
Harris, Shelley E.
6efe8f50-354e-48ea-889e-c2d8293bb16a
Beasley, Olivia
dfb3a253-5460-40d5-a048-c09838ad4d7d
Basford, Philip J.
d65c2fe2-adab-4d34-a346-af9a7164e034
Katsamenis, Orestis L.
8553e7c3-d860-4b7a-a883-abf6c0c4b438
Goggin, Patricia
e1e6172b-6e76-47aa-a2a6-3f2a7f4a0a7d
Derisoud, Emilie
b8ae28f6-37b2-40fa-ac6e-a5693f75bddd
Fanelli, Diana
56bb5114-c691-4249-8a69-42f07461e9e3
Bocci, Carlotta
6038e05a-5142-46b3-a83d-a3da5da7b1a9
Camillo, Francesco
b7cec868-8cab-4ad4-b397-0c6fec11a460
Shotton, Justine
431d36c4-045b-462f-9043-67cc34f02ba7
Constable-Dakeyne, Georgina
a4427a52-9021-4e8d-b80b-d14d75e4df11
Gostling, Neil J.
4840aa40-cb6c-4112-a0b9-694a869523fc
Chavatte-Palmer, Pascale
3b1ff263-828e-4f55-ab66-13168e3ed45f
Lewis, Rohan M.
caaeb97d-ea69-4f7b-8adb-5fa25e2d3502
27 March 2024
Laundon, Davis
b2ba5687-d949-47dd-b84f-fb3c0c032550
Sengers, Bram G.
d6b771b1-4ede-48c5-9644-fa86503941aa
Thompson, James
a0a1e940-d720-47de-81d7-ebcd48738239
Harris, Shelley E.
6efe8f50-354e-48ea-889e-c2d8293bb16a
Beasley, Olivia
dfb3a253-5460-40d5-a048-c09838ad4d7d
Basford, Philip J.
d65c2fe2-adab-4d34-a346-af9a7164e034
Katsamenis, Orestis L.
8553e7c3-d860-4b7a-a883-abf6c0c4b438
Goggin, Patricia
e1e6172b-6e76-47aa-a2a6-3f2a7f4a0a7d
Derisoud, Emilie
b8ae28f6-37b2-40fa-ac6e-a5693f75bddd
Fanelli, Diana
56bb5114-c691-4249-8a69-42f07461e9e3
Bocci, Carlotta
6038e05a-5142-46b3-a83d-a3da5da7b1a9
Camillo, Francesco
b7cec868-8cab-4ad4-b397-0c6fec11a460
Shotton, Justine
431d36c4-045b-462f-9043-67cc34f02ba7
Constable-Dakeyne, Georgina
a4427a52-9021-4e8d-b80b-d14d75e4df11
Gostling, Neil J.
4840aa40-cb6c-4112-a0b9-694a869523fc
Chavatte-Palmer, Pascale
3b1ff263-828e-4f55-ab66-13168e3ed45f
Lewis, Rohan M.
caaeb97d-ea69-4f7b-8adb-5fa25e2d3502
Laundon, Davis, Sengers, Bram G., Thompson, James, Harris, Shelley E., Beasley, Olivia, Basford, Philip J., Katsamenis, Orestis L., Goggin, Patricia, Derisoud, Emilie, Fanelli, Diana, Bocci, Carlotta, Camillo, Francesco, Shotton, Justine, Constable-Dakeyne, Georgina, Gostling, Neil J., Chavatte-Palmer, Pascale and Lewis, Rohan M.
(2024)
Convergently evolved placental villi show multiscale structural adaptations to differential placental invasiveness.
Biology Letters, 20 (3), [20240016].
(doi:10.1098/rsbl.2024.0016).
Abstract
Despite having a single evolutionary origin and conserved function, the mammalian placenta exhibits radical structural diversity. The evolutionary drivers and functional consequences of placental structural diversity are poorly understood. Humans and equids both display treelike placental villi, however these villi evolved independently and exhibit starkly different levels of invasiveness into maternal tissue (i.e. the number of maternal tissue layers between placental tissue and maternal blood). The villi in these species therefore serve as a compelling evolutionary case study to explore whether placentas have developed structural adaptations to respond to the challenge of reduced nutrient availability in less invasive placentas. Here, we use three-dimensional X-ray microfocus computed tomography and electron microscopy to quantitatively evaluate key structures involved in exchange in human and equid placental villi. We find that equid villi have a higher surface area to volume ratio and deeper trophoblastic vessel indentation than human villi. Using illustrative computational models, we propose that these structural adaptations have evolved in equids to boost nutrient transfer to compensate for reduced invasiveness into maternal tissue. We discuss these findings in relation to the 'maternal-fetal conflict hypothesis' of placental evolution.
Text
RSBL20240016
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 1 March 2024
e-pub ahead of print date: 27 March 2024
Published date: 27 March 2024
Additional Information:
For the purpose of open access, the author has applied a Creative Commons Attribution license (CC BY) to any Author Accepted Manuscript version arising from this submission.
Keywords:
Animals, Chorionic Villi, Female, Humans, Mammals, Placenta, Pregnancy
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 488992
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/488992
ISSN: 1744-9561
PURE UUID: e1de9039-832a-488c-9f1a-e3f1357029c3
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 10 Apr 2024 16:56
Last modified: 05 Jun 2024 02:03
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Davis Laundon
Author:
James Thompson
Author:
Shelley E. Harris
Author:
Olivia Beasley
Author:
Philip J. Basford
Author:
Patricia Goggin
Author:
Emilie Derisoud
Author:
Diana Fanelli
Author:
Carlotta Bocci
Author:
Francesco Camillo
Author:
Justine Shotton
Author:
Georgina Constable-Dakeyne
Author:
Pascale Chavatte-Palmer
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics