The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

The empty pelvis syndrome: a core data set from the PelvEx collaborative

The empty pelvis syndrome: a core data set from the PelvEx collaborative
The empty pelvis syndrome: a core data set from the PelvEx collaborative

Background: empty pelvis syndrome (EPS) is a significant source of morbidity following pelvic exenteration (PE), but is undefined. EPS outcome reporting and descriptors of radicality of PE are inconsistent; therefore, the best approaches for prevention are unknown. To facilitate future research into EPS, the aim of this study is to define a measurable core outcome set, core descriptor set and written definition for EPS. Consensus on strategies to mitigate EPS was also explored.


Method: three-stage consensus methodology was used: longlisting with systematic review, healthcare professional event, patient engagement, and Delphi-piloting; shortlisting with two rounds of modified Delphi; and a confirmatory stage using a modified nominal group technique. This included a selection of measurement instruments, and iterative generation of a written EPS definition.


Results: one hundred and three and 119 participants took part in the modified Delphi and consensus meetings, respectively. This encompassed international patient and healthcare professional representation with multidisciplinary input. Seventy statements were longlisted, seven core outcomes (bowel obstruction, enteroperineal fistula, chronic perineal sinus, infected pelvic collection, bowel obstruction, morbidity from reconstruction, re-intervention, and quality of life), and four core descriptors (magnitude of surgery, radiotherapy-induced damage, methods of reconstruction, and changes in volume of pelvic dead space) reached consensus—where applicable, measurement of these outcomes and descriptors was defined. A written definition for EPS was agreed.


Conclusions: EPS is an area of unmet research and clinical need. This study provides an agreed definition and core data set for EPS to facilitate further research.

0007-1323
West, Charles T.
f55ef5be-4040-4c3a-978e-d0ce1eaeb366
West, M.A.
98b67e58-9875-4133-b236-8a10a0a12c04
Mirnezami, A.H.
b3c7aee7-46a4-404c-bfe3-f72388e0bc94
Drami, I.
90f20ace-7104-425e-88e3-63e851b0436c
Glyn, T.
6f1ed308-12fc-490b-9a09-abab2d12fca6
Sutton, P. A.
b9a9d1cf-1a82-4054-a47f-6be9674b9c75
Tiernan, J.
c65174ce-4a54-4db8-b38f-78cbdb641e24
Behrenbruch, C.
eb607c44-502c-4e73-b32f-4a4d18a2aad8
Guerra, G.
83dbb366-b472-414d-ad94-756b14b7d227
Waters, P. S.
a022b507-6356-4afe-bbbc-d2f7adb70385
Woodward, N.
5b3546b5-629c-4722-9548-c83b401db528
Applin, S.
4e8f3daa-3952-4594-a9ec-4ddfbb533331
Charles, S. J.
c70d30e4-1352-4418-b1b3-9bf59fd996e0
Rose, S. A.
a8ff45f5-6d5a-4fdb-85d8-435462b595fe
Denys, A.
97bdcb8d-de45-4db9-8f07-3877d4d8d1cd
Pape, E.
54cfd4bd-9e20-4f66-bf0f-b4bb4e47f7aa
van Ramshorst, G. H.
50a20e68-79bb-4096-875f-2b61191bf6e5
Baker, D.
e64b0215-5bb7-4c8a-8f14-028b843e7fb9
Bignall, E.
5f8d6d88-d134-44dc-ad50-487757ab38a4
Blair, I.
82f13b66-00fd-4275-bad0-2ec5694e943b
Davis, P.
0378a22b-e654-4bbd-ac96-6879082665b3
Edwards, T.
a4413a35-ba4f-4abc-9364-78edcdc4586a
Jackson, K.
93f8618d-f19d-4e71-894f-40bd078ef8f3
Leendertse, P. G.
23756700-014b-4896-b102-939f42420f97
Love-Mott, E.
4dc1d522-3e07-4b5f-a634-04be4e8b7337
MacKenzie, L.
058b12a9-2fa6-4b2b-bbb1-a82fb751bd94
Martens, F.
d31d57dc-c6e0-4994-8098-ef2f3f925554
Meredith, D.
52056084-4fcf-4b93-8b8b-23ff1e307667
Nettleton, S. E.
ea72412b-d432-4e73-9646-4cfc375adb24
Trotman, M. P.
1cec86d5-d8cb-4387-9ffa-1a490bb8ec4e
van Hecke, J. J.M.
3f729104-cb77-45ff-8e76-62ab97d1821c
Weemaes, A. M.J.
d8162069-d1d2-42ca-9106-889d319f7310
Abecasis, N.
207e5030-9446-4725-9692-c12f80e35540
Angenete, E.
26045081-e60a-481b-a878-98cd4a53f17e
Aziz, O.
d27267f6-d86c-471a-a5af-7cffe770e5e8
Bacalbasa, N.
6998ae28-e2ca-4250-b5ad-b52c55f0a6a6
Barton, D.
5118e67f-ab12-4a88-b3ea-911b700fc193
Baseckas, G.
80cc9e26-cf33-415f-800c-9b50694cc45a
Beggs, A.
6d48ef1a-53b3-4eb9-82c2-c62ed231a380
Brown, K.
aeea08d9-b792-4505-9835-0e6a0ae7a0ef
Buchwald, P.
f533fe9a-d36b-4108-838b-416658e8938e
Burling, D.
95698150-b8b1-4b11-9190-85cfd8616ced
Burns, E.
454328b3-a4d1-4979-a931-b29432731404
Caycedo-Marulanda, A.
2e2e7ec7-cbc2-43ca-9c76-18a0deb7fb8c
Chang, G. J.
267d18e5-e0cb-4dd3-b11f-3ba03cda1dca
Coyne, P. E.
09c3be10-5977-4da9-8bab-c928cb8802ed
Croner, R. S.
50054e53-adfc-4b2f-8f57-743804697b5f
Daniels, I. R.
ef3e425a-c88a-44bf-8e4b-ad9bad513ba6
Denost, Q. D.
9576b74e-a462-4d23-b8ed-b9602453b007
Drozdov, E.
0a709f2c-3c66-42aa-a0d7-1b38f25334bd
PelvEx Collaborative
West, Charles T.
f55ef5be-4040-4c3a-978e-d0ce1eaeb366
West, M.A.
98b67e58-9875-4133-b236-8a10a0a12c04
Mirnezami, A.H.
b3c7aee7-46a4-404c-bfe3-f72388e0bc94
Drami, I.
90f20ace-7104-425e-88e3-63e851b0436c
Glyn, T.
6f1ed308-12fc-490b-9a09-abab2d12fca6
Sutton, P. A.
b9a9d1cf-1a82-4054-a47f-6be9674b9c75
Tiernan, J.
c65174ce-4a54-4db8-b38f-78cbdb641e24
Behrenbruch, C.
eb607c44-502c-4e73-b32f-4a4d18a2aad8
Guerra, G.
83dbb366-b472-414d-ad94-756b14b7d227
Waters, P. S.
a022b507-6356-4afe-bbbc-d2f7adb70385
Woodward, N.
5b3546b5-629c-4722-9548-c83b401db528
Applin, S.
4e8f3daa-3952-4594-a9ec-4ddfbb533331
Charles, S. J.
c70d30e4-1352-4418-b1b3-9bf59fd996e0
Rose, S. A.
a8ff45f5-6d5a-4fdb-85d8-435462b595fe
Denys, A.
97bdcb8d-de45-4db9-8f07-3877d4d8d1cd
Pape, E.
54cfd4bd-9e20-4f66-bf0f-b4bb4e47f7aa
van Ramshorst, G. H.
50a20e68-79bb-4096-875f-2b61191bf6e5
Baker, D.
e64b0215-5bb7-4c8a-8f14-028b843e7fb9
Bignall, E.
5f8d6d88-d134-44dc-ad50-487757ab38a4
Blair, I.
82f13b66-00fd-4275-bad0-2ec5694e943b
Davis, P.
0378a22b-e654-4bbd-ac96-6879082665b3
Edwards, T.
a4413a35-ba4f-4abc-9364-78edcdc4586a
Jackson, K.
93f8618d-f19d-4e71-894f-40bd078ef8f3
Leendertse, P. G.
23756700-014b-4896-b102-939f42420f97
Love-Mott, E.
4dc1d522-3e07-4b5f-a634-04be4e8b7337
MacKenzie, L.
058b12a9-2fa6-4b2b-bbb1-a82fb751bd94
Martens, F.
d31d57dc-c6e0-4994-8098-ef2f3f925554
Meredith, D.
52056084-4fcf-4b93-8b8b-23ff1e307667
Nettleton, S. E.
ea72412b-d432-4e73-9646-4cfc375adb24
Trotman, M. P.
1cec86d5-d8cb-4387-9ffa-1a490bb8ec4e
van Hecke, J. J.M.
3f729104-cb77-45ff-8e76-62ab97d1821c
Weemaes, A. M.J.
d8162069-d1d2-42ca-9106-889d319f7310
Abecasis, N.
207e5030-9446-4725-9692-c12f80e35540
Angenete, E.
26045081-e60a-481b-a878-98cd4a53f17e
Aziz, O.
d27267f6-d86c-471a-a5af-7cffe770e5e8
Bacalbasa, N.
6998ae28-e2ca-4250-b5ad-b52c55f0a6a6
Barton, D.
5118e67f-ab12-4a88-b3ea-911b700fc193
Baseckas, G.
80cc9e26-cf33-415f-800c-9b50694cc45a
Beggs, A.
6d48ef1a-53b3-4eb9-82c2-c62ed231a380
Brown, K.
aeea08d9-b792-4505-9835-0e6a0ae7a0ef
Buchwald, P.
f533fe9a-d36b-4108-838b-416658e8938e
Burling, D.
95698150-b8b1-4b11-9190-85cfd8616ced
Burns, E.
454328b3-a4d1-4979-a931-b29432731404
Caycedo-Marulanda, A.
2e2e7ec7-cbc2-43ca-9c76-18a0deb7fb8c
Chang, G. J.
267d18e5-e0cb-4dd3-b11f-3ba03cda1dca
Coyne, P. E.
09c3be10-5977-4da9-8bab-c928cb8802ed
Croner, R. S.
50054e53-adfc-4b2f-8f57-743804697b5f
Daniels, I. R.
ef3e425a-c88a-44bf-8e4b-ad9bad513ba6
Denost, Q. D.
9576b74e-a462-4d23-b8ed-b9602453b007
Drozdov, E.
0a709f2c-3c66-42aa-a0d7-1b38f25334bd

PelvEx Collaborative (2024) The empty pelvis syndrome: a core data set from the PelvEx collaborative. British Journal of Surgery, 111 (3), [znae042]. (doi:10.1093/bjs/znae042).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Background: empty pelvis syndrome (EPS) is a significant source of morbidity following pelvic exenteration (PE), but is undefined. EPS outcome reporting and descriptors of radicality of PE are inconsistent; therefore, the best approaches for prevention are unknown. To facilitate future research into EPS, the aim of this study is to define a measurable core outcome set, core descriptor set and written definition for EPS. Consensus on strategies to mitigate EPS was also explored.


Method: three-stage consensus methodology was used: longlisting with systematic review, healthcare professional event, patient engagement, and Delphi-piloting; shortlisting with two rounds of modified Delphi; and a confirmatory stage using a modified nominal group technique. This included a selection of measurement instruments, and iterative generation of a written EPS definition.


Results: one hundred and three and 119 participants took part in the modified Delphi and consensus meetings, respectively. This encompassed international patient and healthcare professional representation with multidisciplinary input. Seventy statements were longlisted, seven core outcomes (bowel obstruction, enteroperineal fistula, chronic perineal sinus, infected pelvic collection, bowel obstruction, morbidity from reconstruction, re-intervention, and quality of life), and four core descriptors (magnitude of surgery, radiotherapy-induced damage, methods of reconstruction, and changes in volume of pelvic dead space) reached consensus—where applicable, measurement of these outcomes and descriptors was defined. A written definition for EPS was agreed.


Conclusions: EPS is an area of unmet research and clinical need. This study provides an agreed definition and core data set for EPS to facilitate further research.

Text
znae042 - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (6MB)
Text
Empty pelvis consensus paper - approved draft (gvr_ahm_mw_cb_tg)
Download (80kB)
Text
Correction notice
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (111kB)

More information

Accepted/In Press date: 15 January 2024
Published date: 8 March 2024
Additional Information: A correction has been attached to this output located at https://doi.org/10.1093/bjs/znae095 and https://academic.oup.com/bjs/article/111/3/znae095/7637323

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 490896
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/490896
ISSN: 0007-1323
PURE UUID: 0411662f-50db-4852-8219-52ea38b676c3
ORCID for M.A. West: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-0345-5356

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 07 Jun 2024 17:45
Last modified: 19 Jun 2024 01:52

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Charles T. West
Author: M.A. West ORCID iD
Author: A.H. Mirnezami
Author: I. Drami
Author: T. Glyn
Author: P. A. Sutton
Author: J. Tiernan
Author: C. Behrenbruch
Author: G. Guerra
Author: P. S. Waters
Author: N. Woodward
Author: S. Applin
Author: S. J. Charles
Author: S. A. Rose
Author: A. Denys
Author: E. Pape
Author: G. H. van Ramshorst
Author: D. Baker
Author: E. Bignall
Author: I. Blair
Author: P. Davis
Author: T. Edwards
Author: K. Jackson
Author: P. G. Leendertse
Author: E. Love-Mott
Author: L. MacKenzie
Author: F. Martens
Author: D. Meredith
Author: S. E. Nettleton
Author: M. P. Trotman
Author: J. J.M. van Hecke
Author: A. M.J. Weemaes
Author: N. Abecasis
Author: E. Angenete
Author: O. Aziz
Author: N. Bacalbasa
Author: D. Barton
Author: G. Baseckas
Author: A. Beggs
Author: K. Brown
Author: P. Buchwald
Author: D. Burling
Author: E. Burns
Author: A. Caycedo-Marulanda
Author: G. J. Chang
Author: P. E. Coyne
Author: R. S. Croner
Author: I. R. Daniels
Author: Q. D. Denost
Author: E. Drozdov
Corporate Author: PelvEx Collaborative

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×