A sharing practices review of the visual search and eye movements literature reveals recommendations for our field and others
A sharing practices review of the visual search and eye movements literature reveals recommendations for our field and others
The sharing of outputs from scientific research is an important endeavor; one that is required at an increasing rate by funders and publishers alike. Here, we catalogued and examined data sharing practices, using our own field of visual search and eye movement behavior as an example. To find outputs from scientific research, we conducted two searches: a Literature Search and a Repository Search. Overall, we found that researchers in our field generally shared outputs that enabled others to analytically reproduce published results. It was rare for researchers to share outputs that enabled direct replications of their work, and it was also rare for researchers to share raw data that would enable secondary data analyses. Comparing the results of our two searches of the literature, we found that a lack of metadata substantially reduced the rates at which outputs could be found and used. Based on our findings, we present a set of recommendations summarized in our ‘Find It – Access It – Reuse It’ scorecard. The scorecard is intended to assist researchers in sharing outputs in a manner that will enable others to better find, access, and understand them – and this includes researchers in other fields beyond our own.
Data sharing, Eye tracking, Open science, Secondary data analyses, Sharing practices review, Visual search
Godwin, Hayward J.
df22dc0c-01d1-440a-a369-a763801851e5
Dewis, Haden
8bfc20ea-9a60-48f6-bb25-00c4d4252a84
Darch, Peter T.
e2873c95-fc2f-4629-af6c-ba0241b5435e
Hout, Michael C.
79882490-f79b-4e7d-990a-fdcdcb87f3ce
Ernst, Daniel
1f9c983f-c27f-4176-9429-d678c26b8670
Broadbent, Philippa
f9e72e3e-0692-4257-9ab8-f79179d3d18f
Papesh, Megan
398b47b1-3004-4cde-8a5f-7136aafdd8fa
Wolfe, Jeremy M.
940c81fb-44f8-4eff-b172-a43730b2fd92
25 July 2025
Godwin, Hayward J.
df22dc0c-01d1-440a-a369-a763801851e5
Dewis, Haden
8bfc20ea-9a60-48f6-bb25-00c4d4252a84
Darch, Peter T.
e2873c95-fc2f-4629-af6c-ba0241b5435e
Hout, Michael C.
79882490-f79b-4e7d-990a-fdcdcb87f3ce
Ernst, Daniel
1f9c983f-c27f-4176-9429-d678c26b8670
Broadbent, Philippa
f9e72e3e-0692-4257-9ab8-f79179d3d18f
Papesh, Megan
398b47b1-3004-4cde-8a5f-7136aafdd8fa
Wolfe, Jeremy M.
940c81fb-44f8-4eff-b172-a43730b2fd92
Godwin, Hayward J., Dewis, Haden, Darch, Peter T., Hout, Michael C., Ernst, Daniel, Broadbent, Philippa, Papesh, Megan and Wolfe, Jeremy M.
(2025)
A sharing practices review of the visual search and eye movements literature reveals recommendations for our field and others.
Behavior Research Methods, 57 (9), [235].
(doi:10.3758/s13428-025-02759-3).
Abstract
The sharing of outputs from scientific research is an important endeavor; one that is required at an increasing rate by funders and publishers alike. Here, we catalogued and examined data sharing practices, using our own field of visual search and eye movement behavior as an example. To find outputs from scientific research, we conducted two searches: a Literature Search and a Repository Search. Overall, we found that researchers in our field generally shared outputs that enabled others to analytically reproduce published results. It was rare for researchers to share outputs that enabled direct replications of their work, and it was also rare for researchers to share raw data that would enable secondary data analyses. Comparing the results of our two searches of the literature, we found that a lack of metadata substantially reduced the rates at which outputs could be found and used. Based on our findings, we present a set of recommendations summarized in our ‘Find It – Access It – Reuse It’ scorecard. The scorecard is intended to assist researchers in sharing outputs in a manner that will enable others to better find, access, and understand them – and this includes researchers in other fields beyond our own.
Text
Accepted Manuscript Changes Accepted
- Accepted Manuscript
Text
s13428-025-02759-3
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 20 June 2025
Published date: 25 July 2025
Keywords:
Data sharing, Eye tracking, Open science, Secondary data analyses, Sharing practices review, Visual search
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 503621
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/503621
ISSN: 1554-351X
PURE UUID: 14cef750-715d-427c-99b7-47573831a9dc
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 07 Aug 2025 16:37
Last modified: 22 Aug 2025 02:01
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Haden Dewis
Author:
Peter T. Darch
Author:
Michael C. Hout
Author:
Daniel Ernst
Author:
Philippa Broadbent
Author:
Megan Papesh
Author:
Jeremy M. Wolfe
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics