A multi-dimensional view of a unified model for TDEs
A multi-dimensional view of a unified model for TDEs
Tidal disruption events (TDEs) can generate non-spherical, relativistic and optically thick outflows. Simulations show that the radiation we observe is reprocessed by these outflows. According to a unified model suggested by these simulations, the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of TDEs depend strongly on viewing angle: low [high] optical-to-X-ray ratios (OXRs) correspond to face-on [edge-on] orientations. Post-processing with radiative transfer codes have simulated the emergent spectra, but have so far been carried out only in a quasi-1D framework, with three atomic species (H, He and O). Here, we present 2.5D Monte Carlo radiative transfer simulations which model the emission from a non-spherical outflow, including a more comprehensive set of cosmically abundant species. While the basic trend of OXR increasing with inclination is preserved, the inherently multi-dimensional nature of photon transport through the non-spherical outflow significantly affects the emergent SEDs. Relaxing the quasi-1D approximation allows photons to preferentially escape in (polar) directions of lower optical depth, resulting in a greater variation of bolometric luminosity as a function of inclination. According to our simulations, inclination alone may not fully explain the large dynamic range of observed TDE OXRs. We also find that including metals, other than Oxygen, changes the emergent spectra significantly, resulting in stronger absorption and emission lines in the extreme ultraviolet, as well a greater variation in the OXR as a function of inclination. Whilst our results support previously proposed unified models for TDEs, they also highlight the critical importance of multi-dimensional ionization and radiative transfer.
astro-ph.HE, black hole physics, galaxies: nuclei, transients: tidal disruption events, accretion, accretion discs
3069-3085
Parkinson, Edward J.
01096663-3f01-450c-9457-e8328def9dba
Knigge, Christian
ac320eec-631a-426e-b2db-717c8bf7857e
Dai, Lixin
c32fe2cb-c960-4dc2-ac8d-87b4f20ada04
Thomsen, Lars Lund
18e5720e-b195-4520-8815-1e9360b9b076
Matthews, James H.
7c623891-70ae-4808-8e75-83f7973cae35
Long, Knox S.
2195d0ac-518d-4738-8e89-3e8e7a035a6c
18 June 2025
Parkinson, Edward J.
01096663-3f01-450c-9457-e8328def9dba
Knigge, Christian
ac320eec-631a-426e-b2db-717c8bf7857e
Dai, Lixin
c32fe2cb-c960-4dc2-ac8d-87b4f20ada04
Thomsen, Lars Lund
18e5720e-b195-4520-8815-1e9360b9b076
Matthews, James H.
7c623891-70ae-4808-8e75-83f7973cae35
Long, Knox S.
2195d0ac-518d-4738-8e89-3e8e7a035a6c
Parkinson, Edward J., Knigge, Christian, Dai, Lixin, Thomsen, Lars Lund, Matthews, James H. and Long, Knox S.
(2025)
A multi-dimensional view of a unified model for TDEs.
Monthly Notices of the Royal Astronomical Society, 540 (4), .
(doi:10.1093/mnras/staf880).
Abstract
Tidal disruption events (TDEs) can generate non-spherical, relativistic and optically thick outflows. Simulations show that the radiation we observe is reprocessed by these outflows. According to a unified model suggested by these simulations, the spectral energy distributions (SEDs) of TDEs depend strongly on viewing angle: low [high] optical-to-X-ray ratios (OXRs) correspond to face-on [edge-on] orientations. Post-processing with radiative transfer codes have simulated the emergent spectra, but have so far been carried out only in a quasi-1D framework, with three atomic species (H, He and O). Here, we present 2.5D Monte Carlo radiative transfer simulations which model the emission from a non-spherical outflow, including a more comprehensive set of cosmically abundant species. While the basic trend of OXR increasing with inclination is preserved, the inherently multi-dimensional nature of photon transport through the non-spherical outflow significantly affects the emergent SEDs. Relaxing the quasi-1D approximation allows photons to preferentially escape in (polar) directions of lower optical depth, resulting in a greater variation of bolometric luminosity as a function of inclination. According to our simulations, inclination alone may not fully explain the large dynamic range of observed TDE OXRs. We also find that including metals, other than Oxygen, changes the emergent spectra significantly, resulting in stronger absorption and emission lines in the extreme ultraviolet, as well a greater variation in the OXR as a function of inclination. Whilst our results support previously proposed unified models for TDEs, they also highlight the critical importance of multi-dimensional ionization and radiative transfer.
Text
2408.16371v2
- Author's Original
Text
staf880
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 28 May 2025
e-pub ahead of print date: 29 May 2025
Published date: 18 June 2025
Keywords:
astro-ph.HE, black hole physics, galaxies: nuclei, transients: tidal disruption events, accretion, accretion discs
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 504024
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/504024
ISSN: 1365-2966
PURE UUID: 8ed41eed-9822-4cfe-bdbc-12c822b4b8c4
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 21 Aug 2025 15:49
Last modified: 17 Oct 2025 16:55
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
Edward J. Parkinson
Author:
Lixin Dai
Author:
Lars Lund Thomsen
Author:
James H. Matthews
Author:
Knox S. Long
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics