Neural correlates of human fear conditioning and sources of variability in 2199 individuals
Neural correlates of human fear conditioning and sources of variability in 2199 individuals
Pavlovian fear conditioning is a fundamental process in both health and disease. We investigate its neural correlates and sources of variability using harmonized functional magnetic resonance imaging data from 2199 individuals across nine countries, including 1888 healthy individuals and 311 with anxiety-related or depressive disorders. Using mega-analysis and normative modeling, we show that fear conditioning consistently engages brain regions within the "central autonomic-interoceptive" or "salience" network. Several task variables strongly modulate activity in these regions, contributing to variability in neural responses. Additionally, brain activation patterns differ between healthy individuals and those with anxiety-related or depressive disorders, with distinct profiles characterizing specific disorders such as post-traumatic stress disorder and obsessive-compulsive disorder. While the neural correlates of fear conditioning are highly generalizable at the population level, variability arises from differences in task design and clinical status, highlighting the importance of methodological diversity in capturing fear learning mechanisms.
Adolescent, Adult, Anxiety Disorders/physiopathology, Brain Mapping, Brain/physiology, Conditioning, Classical/physiology, Fear/physiology, Female, Humans, Magnetic Resonance Imaging, Male, Middle Aged, Obsessive-Compulsive Disorder/physiopathology, Stress Disorders, Post-Traumatic/physiopathology, Young Adult
Radua, Joaquim
62338ecf-18b6-4fe3-aa9a-ccd2ad389c19
Savage, Hannah S.
a20d54f8-399a-4b00-b580-7fbdf7039f8e
Vilajosana, Enric
56ebd6a2-dd87-46c7-ae96-a6fa352e159b
Jamieson, Alec
ba92040c-9e43-4ada-bd31-ab0386eed53a
Abler, Birgit
35953978-2f6a-4c9a-9013-8f836661eb00
Åhs, Fredrik
30d482b5-aa07-4db7-8210-c18343ce4770
Beckers, Tom
d024b28d-2e35-4b03-a4e6-cad137434a5b
Cardoner, Narcís
ab8dbaea-03ad-4008-99c5-a9ebca76aabe
Cisler, Josh M.
7e1b1633-140a-4cb9-9e4a-a4a256f42f73
Diniz, Juliana B.
521cf9bf-a9c8-48b6-bb91-a5d09bf192dc
Bach, Dominik R.
0fb7b7de-72e8-4930-8550-04970e4c73b8
Elsenbruch, Sigrid
5db8e6a2-0c29-4f18-abb1-5e98d68a37c6
Greening, Steven G.
c0d7e5c6-69f1-4f56-8061-34c05ac066f7
Holt, Daphne J.
4a602638-bc9a-49a0-9c86-1be74df47540
Kaczkurkin, Antonia N.
b9f4c9f2-7197-49b0-9ae1-d9cff7bde9bf
Keil, Andreas
138c56bb-a204-48fc-ade8-2bfe2fa19466
Kindt, Merel
e7928008-0b31-4ebb-adfc-e56a3f150a14
Koch, Kathrin
e867eb11-d769-400b-97b5-1ff5a2903e9e
LaBar, Kevin S.
dcaa0f5e-3a73-47d8-b133-cded6a058a3d
Lam, Charlene L.
65ef68a1-44ab-49a2-8057-517747592b8f
Larson, Christine L.
39944fd2-0506-4656-a1c5-b94ceaaeb95f
Lonsdorf, Tina B.
463a4e71-6feb-467a-9c1b-90ebe44d0d3d
Merz, Christian J.
7eaa1b7e-2fe4-43ca-ba5a-46b7c4466496
McLaughlin, Katie A.
efbc2fb0-ca46-4816-8da2-6886021c7219
Neria, Yuval
a0dec1a0-cffd-499c-ab48-032b14bf62e9
Pine, Daniel S.
debffc1c-1efc-4bcf-81b3-87aadee1047d
van Reekum, Carien M.
56010ab6-5a14-4c5a-b463-eb2159b3684c
Shackman, Alexander J.
2c0ea316-0455-4568-83fd-4d404b3f7efc
Soriano-Mas, Carles
5f69a88e-d372-4a18-a90d-4342ecd81af3
Spoormaker, Victor I.
af68ac72-3c28-414d-919e-244c12519519
Stout, Daniel M.
eb918de7-a877-416d-809d-5ee19ec9db8e
Straube, Benjamin
ee453097-8034-4741-8837-21a31b083803
Straube, Thomas
d915fe2d-79bb-4609-9854-768929281a55
Tuominen, Lauri
fdca0270-e28a-44fd-82e6-7ddc22537323
Visser, Renée M.
1b1ff5ef-85bc-4e59-aa28-8cbc73101904
Ahumada, Laura
fe5f58f4-2a16-4a76-9613-2f5ec7c7f3c7
Arolt, Volker
5a6f1ab0-276e-4bc1-a6bb-24e22df7b3c0
Batistuzzo, Marcelo C.
65f2e17c-700f-4431-902e-619158b6afbd
Bazán, Paulo R.
85bd724b-b589-4d79-9090-c3beb40acdb6
Biggs, Emma E.
a058369a-080e-4fde-aa58-b344738d595a
Cano, Marta
ce86426d-8529-491f-9723-a425f66f77b9
Chavarría-Elizondo, Pamela
52b2d645-9f1e-44b8-a85c-e48f929db883
Cooper, Samuel E.
20a012f0-49d1-4c69-a9fd-91cfa0bc589f
Dannlowski, Udo
12e279df-b07c-48da-8a72-6e1b9aa54a2a
de la Peña-Arteaga, Víctor
1b9b009c-3169-4b5b-8531-dd6d8962e38c
DeCross, Stephanie N.
b2cc0b48-4fda-4e70-850a-305bb2a6d8ce
Domschke, Katharina
a95f773b-9987-4a3d-9358-d38ddc5c5b5f
Ehlers, Mana R.
ebaa4f4f-fed0-44b2-aa5e-91d1d3cda982
Graner, John L.
c192da1c-068b-400e-9b97-f18ff4ee9d8d
Morriss, Jayne
a6005806-07cf-4283-8766-900003a7306f
23 August 2025
Radua, Joaquim
62338ecf-18b6-4fe3-aa9a-ccd2ad389c19
Savage, Hannah S.
a20d54f8-399a-4b00-b580-7fbdf7039f8e
Vilajosana, Enric
56ebd6a2-dd87-46c7-ae96-a6fa352e159b
Jamieson, Alec
ba92040c-9e43-4ada-bd31-ab0386eed53a
Abler, Birgit
35953978-2f6a-4c9a-9013-8f836661eb00
Åhs, Fredrik
30d482b5-aa07-4db7-8210-c18343ce4770
Beckers, Tom
d024b28d-2e35-4b03-a4e6-cad137434a5b
Cardoner, Narcís
ab8dbaea-03ad-4008-99c5-a9ebca76aabe
Cisler, Josh M.
7e1b1633-140a-4cb9-9e4a-a4a256f42f73
Diniz, Juliana B.
521cf9bf-a9c8-48b6-bb91-a5d09bf192dc
Bach, Dominik R.
0fb7b7de-72e8-4930-8550-04970e4c73b8
Elsenbruch, Sigrid
5db8e6a2-0c29-4f18-abb1-5e98d68a37c6
Greening, Steven G.
c0d7e5c6-69f1-4f56-8061-34c05ac066f7
Holt, Daphne J.
4a602638-bc9a-49a0-9c86-1be74df47540
Kaczkurkin, Antonia N.
b9f4c9f2-7197-49b0-9ae1-d9cff7bde9bf
Keil, Andreas
138c56bb-a204-48fc-ade8-2bfe2fa19466
Kindt, Merel
e7928008-0b31-4ebb-adfc-e56a3f150a14
Koch, Kathrin
e867eb11-d769-400b-97b5-1ff5a2903e9e
LaBar, Kevin S.
dcaa0f5e-3a73-47d8-b133-cded6a058a3d
Lam, Charlene L.
65ef68a1-44ab-49a2-8057-517747592b8f
Larson, Christine L.
39944fd2-0506-4656-a1c5-b94ceaaeb95f
Lonsdorf, Tina B.
463a4e71-6feb-467a-9c1b-90ebe44d0d3d
Merz, Christian J.
7eaa1b7e-2fe4-43ca-ba5a-46b7c4466496
McLaughlin, Katie A.
efbc2fb0-ca46-4816-8da2-6886021c7219
Neria, Yuval
a0dec1a0-cffd-499c-ab48-032b14bf62e9
Pine, Daniel S.
debffc1c-1efc-4bcf-81b3-87aadee1047d
van Reekum, Carien M.
56010ab6-5a14-4c5a-b463-eb2159b3684c
Shackman, Alexander J.
2c0ea316-0455-4568-83fd-4d404b3f7efc
Soriano-Mas, Carles
5f69a88e-d372-4a18-a90d-4342ecd81af3
Spoormaker, Victor I.
af68ac72-3c28-414d-919e-244c12519519
Stout, Daniel M.
eb918de7-a877-416d-809d-5ee19ec9db8e
Straube, Benjamin
ee453097-8034-4741-8837-21a31b083803
Straube, Thomas
d915fe2d-79bb-4609-9854-768929281a55
Tuominen, Lauri
fdca0270-e28a-44fd-82e6-7ddc22537323
Visser, Renée M.
1b1ff5ef-85bc-4e59-aa28-8cbc73101904
Ahumada, Laura
fe5f58f4-2a16-4a76-9613-2f5ec7c7f3c7
Arolt, Volker
5a6f1ab0-276e-4bc1-a6bb-24e22df7b3c0
Batistuzzo, Marcelo C.
65f2e17c-700f-4431-902e-619158b6afbd
Bazán, Paulo R.
85bd724b-b589-4d79-9090-c3beb40acdb6
Biggs, Emma E.
a058369a-080e-4fde-aa58-b344738d595a
Cano, Marta
ce86426d-8529-491f-9723-a425f66f77b9
Chavarría-Elizondo, Pamela
52b2d645-9f1e-44b8-a85c-e48f929db883
Cooper, Samuel E.
20a012f0-49d1-4c69-a9fd-91cfa0bc589f
Dannlowski, Udo
12e279df-b07c-48da-8a72-6e1b9aa54a2a
de la Peña-Arteaga, Víctor
1b9b009c-3169-4b5b-8531-dd6d8962e38c
DeCross, Stephanie N.
b2cc0b48-4fda-4e70-850a-305bb2a6d8ce
Domschke, Katharina
a95f773b-9987-4a3d-9358-d38ddc5c5b5f
Ehlers, Mana R.
ebaa4f4f-fed0-44b2-aa5e-91d1d3cda982
Graner, John L.
c192da1c-068b-400e-9b97-f18ff4ee9d8d
Morriss, Jayne
a6005806-07cf-4283-8766-900003a7306f