A new broadband spectral state in the ultraluminous x-ray source Holmberg IX X-1
A new broadband spectral state in the ultraluminous x-ray source Holmberg IX X-1
We present a series of five new broad-band X-ray observations of the ultraluminous X-ray source Holmberg IX X-1, performed by XMM–Newton and NuSTAR in coordination. The first three of these show high-soft X-ray fluxes but a near total collapse of the high-energy (≥15 keV) emission, previously seen to be surprisingly stable across all prior broad-band observations of the source. The latter two show a recovery in hard X-rays, remarkably once again respecting the same stable high-energy flux exhibited by all of the archival observations. We also present a joint analysis of all broad-band observations of Holmberg IX X-1to date (encompassing 11 epochs in total) in order to investigate whether it shows the same luminosity–temperature behaviouras NGC 1313 X-1 (which also shows a stable high-energy flux), whereby the hotter disc component in the spectrum exhibits twodistinct, positively-correlated tracks in the luminosity–temperature plane. Holmberg IX X-1 may show similar behaviour, butthe results depend on whether the highest energy emission is assumed to be an up-scattering corona or an accretion column. Thestrongest evidence for this behaviour is found in the former case, while in the latter the new ‘soft’ epochs appear distinct fromthe other high-flux epochs. We discuss possible explanations for these new ‘soft’ spectra in the context of the expected structureof super-Eddington accretion flows around black holes and neutron stars, and highlight a potentially interesting analogy withthe recent destruction and re-creation of the corona seen in the AGN 1ES 1927 + 654
astro-ph.GA, astro-ph.HE
2902-2916
Walton, D.J.
f158ba91-4ad4-4f7f-9530-821ced49246f
Bachetti, M.
ff8a204c-8e1e-455f-8f50-0041814bb01f
Kosec, P.
77672063-f196-4dc2-8cf7-0c936b5fcce2
Furst, F.
b85eb74e-a1c3-4861-ac7b-6e273c052920
Pinto, C.
511ced1e-3051-4bb1-94c2-0c65b2bd167c
Roberts, T.P.
6c8faf6b-bd49-4935-a00f-4d66a39f276b
Soria, R.
c4f62b29-384b-4031-8dbc-05c76ff11a9b
Stern, D.
84242e0f-41ca-407d-a69d-ac9531a23897
Alston, W.N.
6f47754e-2eaf-4ec1-a263-f762bfd0222e
Brightman, M.
d4c4b8b2-327a-495e-94c2-ff56adf34b5f
Earnshaw, H.P.
08135aea-9b43-40fc-8a6f-3006dec21b79
Fabian, A.C.
87ada31c-2907-4574-8e9f-25e347da6d30
Harrison, F.A.
e6a0d64c-9477-454d-b6ca-2a098779a53e
Middleton, M.J.
f91b89d9-fd2e-42ec-aa99-1249f08a52ad
Sathyaprakash, R.
998be26e-628c-4e94-b5c7-b3091f4579e6
13 October 2025
Walton, D.J.
f158ba91-4ad4-4f7f-9530-821ced49246f
Bachetti, M.
ff8a204c-8e1e-455f-8f50-0041814bb01f
Kosec, P.
77672063-f196-4dc2-8cf7-0c936b5fcce2
Furst, F.
b85eb74e-a1c3-4861-ac7b-6e273c052920
Pinto, C.
511ced1e-3051-4bb1-94c2-0c65b2bd167c
Roberts, T.P.
6c8faf6b-bd49-4935-a00f-4d66a39f276b
Soria, R.
c4f62b29-384b-4031-8dbc-05c76ff11a9b
Stern, D.
84242e0f-41ca-407d-a69d-ac9531a23897
Alston, W.N.
6f47754e-2eaf-4ec1-a263-f762bfd0222e
Brightman, M.
d4c4b8b2-327a-495e-94c2-ff56adf34b5f
Earnshaw, H.P.
08135aea-9b43-40fc-8a6f-3006dec21b79
Fabian, A.C.
87ada31c-2907-4574-8e9f-25e347da6d30
Harrison, F.A.
e6a0d64c-9477-454d-b6ca-2a098779a53e
Middleton, M.J.
f91b89d9-fd2e-42ec-aa99-1249f08a52ad
Sathyaprakash, R.
998be26e-628c-4e94-b5c7-b3091f4579e6
Walton, D.J., Bachetti, M., Kosec, P., Furst, F., Pinto, C., Roberts, T.P., Soria, R., Stern, D., Alston, W.N., Brightman, M., Earnshaw, H.P., Fabian, A.C., Harrison, F.A., Middleton, M.J. and Sathyaprakash, R.
(2025)
A new broadband spectral state in the ultraluminous x-ray source Holmberg IX X-1.
MNRAS, Volume, 543 (3), .
(doi:10.1093/mnras/staf1609).
Abstract
We present a series of five new broad-band X-ray observations of the ultraluminous X-ray source Holmberg IX X-1, performed by XMM–Newton and NuSTAR in coordination. The first three of these show high-soft X-ray fluxes but a near total collapse of the high-energy (≥15 keV) emission, previously seen to be surprisingly stable across all prior broad-band observations of the source. The latter two show a recovery in hard X-rays, remarkably once again respecting the same stable high-energy flux exhibited by all of the archival observations. We also present a joint analysis of all broad-band observations of Holmberg IX X-1to date (encompassing 11 epochs in total) in order to investigate whether it shows the same luminosity–temperature behaviouras NGC 1313 X-1 (which also shows a stable high-energy flux), whereby the hotter disc component in the spectrum exhibits twodistinct, positively-correlated tracks in the luminosity–temperature plane. Holmberg IX X-1 may show similar behaviour, butthe results depend on whether the highest energy emission is assumed to be an up-scattering corona or an accretion column. Thestrongest evidence for this behaviour is found in the former case, while in the latter the new ‘soft’ epochs appear distinct fromthe other high-flux epochs. We discuss possible explanations for these new ‘soft’ spectra in the context of the expected structureof super-Eddington accretion flows around black holes and neutron stars, and highlight a potentially interesting analogy withthe recent destruction and re-creation of the corona seen in the AGN 1ES 1927 + 654
Text
2409.12241v2
- Author's Original
Text
staf1609
- Version of Record
More information
Accepted/In Press date: 15 September 2024
e-pub ahead of print date: 30 September 2025
Published date: 13 October 2025
Keywords:
astro-ph.GA, astro-ph.HE
Identifiers
Local EPrints ID: 507178
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/507178
ISSN: 1365-2966
PURE UUID: 133db8d9-ae2a-429a-bd0f-ef86370fb2d6
Catalogue record
Date deposited: 28 Nov 2025 17:37
Last modified: 28 Nov 2025 17:38
Export record
Altmetrics
Contributors
Author:
D.J. Walton
Author:
M. Bachetti
Author:
P. Kosec
Author:
F. Furst
Author:
C. Pinto
Author:
T.P. Roberts
Author:
R. Soria
Author:
D. Stern
Author:
W.N. Alston
Author:
M. Brightman
Author:
H.P. Earnshaw
Author:
A.C. Fabian
Author:
F.A. Harrison
Author:
R. Sathyaprakash
Download statistics
Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.
View more statistics