The University of Southampton
University of Southampton Institutional Repository

Southern Ocean humpback whale trophic ecology. I. Combining multiple stable isotope methods elucidates diet, trophic position and foraging areas

Southern Ocean humpback whale trophic ecology. I. Combining multiple stable isotope methods elucidates diet, trophic position and foraging areas
Southern Ocean humpback whale trophic ecology. I. Combining multiple stable isotope methods elucidates diet, trophic position and foraging areas

Southern Ocean humpback whales Megaptera novaeangliae are capital breeders, breeding in the warm tropics/subtropics in the winter and migrating to nutrient-rich Antarctic feeding grounds in the summer. The classic feeding model is for the species to fast while migrating and breeding, surviving on blubber energy stores. Whilst northern hemisphere humpback whales are generalists, southern hemisphere counterparts are perceived as krill specialists, but for many populations, uncertainties remain regarding their diet and preferred feeding locations. This study used bulk and compound-specific stable isotope analyses and isoscape-based feeding location assignments to assess the diet, trophic ecology and likely feeding areas of humpback whales sampled in the Ross Sea region and around the Balleny Islands. Sampled whales had a mixed diet of plankton, krill and fish, similar to the diet of northern hemisphere humpback whales. Proportions of fish consumed varied but were often high (2-60%), thus challenging the widely held paradigm of Southern Ocean humpback whales being exclusive krill feeders. These whales had lower δ15N values and trophic position estimates than their northern hemisphere counterparts, likely due to lower Southern Ocean baseline δ15N surface water values and a lower percentage consumption of fish, respectively. Most whales fed in the Ross Sea shelf/slope and Balleny Islands high-productivity regions, but some isotopically distinct whales (mostly males) fed at higher trophic levels either around the Balleny Islands and frontal upwelling areas to the north, or en route to Antarctica in temperate waters off southern Australia and New Zealand. These results support other observations of humpback whales feeding during migration, highlighting the species' dietary plasticity, which may increase their foraging and breeding success and provide them with greater resilience to anthropogenically mediated ecological change. This study highlights the importance of combining in situ field data with regional-scale isoscapes to reliably assess trophic structure and animal feeding locations, and to better inform ecosystem conservation and management of marine protected areas.

Amino acids, Antarctica, Feeding ecology, Isoscapes, MixSIAR, UNSDG14 Life Below Water, δ13C, δ15N
0171-8630
123-155
Bury, Sarah J.
7a894e46-453f-4687-89f3-e568d6f1385a
Peters, Katharina J.
04549637-16f4-4c5b-aab5-091928e58b8f
Sabadel, Amandine J.M.
f68f9795-4964-4f1b-81b6-a19b75c6f958
St John Glew, Katie
8f3bc334-6c9b-4280-bd3c-2ca3290f0650
Trueman, Clive
d00d3bd6-a47b-4d47-89ae-841c3d506205
Wunder, M.B.
2a2c7797-eb0e-423d-8573-a7ec11b28009
Cobain, Matthew R.D.
d599eb73-7cf6-4a45-b6e2-6d8de87397c0
Schmitt, Natalie
58492974-fb02-4724-a16e-506a3e1c2b8e
Donnelly, David
951d664c-9424-40fd-b0d3-6881d628d4db
Magozzi, Sarah
04b10c48-de68-4c20-ad93-eeb32ce442dc
Owen, Kylie
387e8019-c0d1-4920-a7a6-ffbf24cdc7c7
Brown, Julie C.S.
ebc9e40e-6aa9-4e49-9ca4-3bdf6bada788
Escobar-Flores, Pablo
67ed0bed-8a28-4696-8211-308dce4c3d6f
Constantine, Rochelle
2bce1e1c-fc56-4158-ad9d-339624f3899b
O’Driscoll, Richard L.
985ac388-42e4-4296-b51a-317d336c9548
Double, Mike
1573dc76-9dcc-49d7-9fad-43712e4fb558
Gales, Nick
e67ed949-8d3c-4f1c-a890-0a1d09efc5f4
Childerhouse, Simon
af20c8e6-c5c4-4d0a-a66e-5f2ece45b6c7
Pinkerton, Matthew H.
9f1316f9-73ee-4184-aa74-66f2734e375a
Bury, Sarah J.
7a894e46-453f-4687-89f3-e568d6f1385a
Peters, Katharina J.
04549637-16f4-4c5b-aab5-091928e58b8f
Sabadel, Amandine J.M.
f68f9795-4964-4f1b-81b6-a19b75c6f958
St John Glew, Katie
8f3bc334-6c9b-4280-bd3c-2ca3290f0650
Trueman, Clive
d00d3bd6-a47b-4d47-89ae-841c3d506205
Wunder, M.B.
2a2c7797-eb0e-423d-8573-a7ec11b28009
Cobain, Matthew R.D.
d599eb73-7cf6-4a45-b6e2-6d8de87397c0
Schmitt, Natalie
58492974-fb02-4724-a16e-506a3e1c2b8e
Donnelly, David
951d664c-9424-40fd-b0d3-6881d628d4db
Magozzi, Sarah
04b10c48-de68-4c20-ad93-eeb32ce442dc
Owen, Kylie
387e8019-c0d1-4920-a7a6-ffbf24cdc7c7
Brown, Julie C.S.
ebc9e40e-6aa9-4e49-9ca4-3bdf6bada788
Escobar-Flores, Pablo
67ed0bed-8a28-4696-8211-308dce4c3d6f
Constantine, Rochelle
2bce1e1c-fc56-4158-ad9d-339624f3899b
O’Driscoll, Richard L.
985ac388-42e4-4296-b51a-317d336c9548
Double, Mike
1573dc76-9dcc-49d7-9fad-43712e4fb558
Gales, Nick
e67ed949-8d3c-4f1c-a890-0a1d09efc5f4
Childerhouse, Simon
af20c8e6-c5c4-4d0a-a66e-5f2ece45b6c7
Pinkerton, Matthew H.
9f1316f9-73ee-4184-aa74-66f2734e375a

Bury, Sarah J., Peters, Katharina J., Sabadel, Amandine J.M., St John Glew, Katie, Trueman, Clive, Wunder, M.B., Cobain, Matthew R.D., Schmitt, Natalie, Donnelly, David, Magozzi, Sarah, Owen, Kylie, Brown, Julie C.S., Escobar-Flores, Pablo, Constantine, Rochelle, O’Driscoll, Richard L., Double, Mike, Gales, Nick, Childerhouse, Simon and Pinkerton, Matthew H. (2024) Southern Ocean humpback whale trophic ecology. I. Combining multiple stable isotope methods elucidates diet, trophic position and foraging areas. Marine Ecology Progress Series, 734, 123-155. (doi:10.3354/meps14532).

Record type: Article

Abstract

Southern Ocean humpback whales Megaptera novaeangliae are capital breeders, breeding in the warm tropics/subtropics in the winter and migrating to nutrient-rich Antarctic feeding grounds in the summer. The classic feeding model is for the species to fast while migrating and breeding, surviving on blubber energy stores. Whilst northern hemisphere humpback whales are generalists, southern hemisphere counterparts are perceived as krill specialists, but for many populations, uncertainties remain regarding their diet and preferred feeding locations. This study used bulk and compound-specific stable isotope analyses and isoscape-based feeding location assignments to assess the diet, trophic ecology and likely feeding areas of humpback whales sampled in the Ross Sea region and around the Balleny Islands. Sampled whales had a mixed diet of plankton, krill and fish, similar to the diet of northern hemisphere humpback whales. Proportions of fish consumed varied but were often high (2-60%), thus challenging the widely held paradigm of Southern Ocean humpback whales being exclusive krill feeders. These whales had lower δ15N values and trophic position estimates than their northern hemisphere counterparts, likely due to lower Southern Ocean baseline δ15N surface water values and a lower percentage consumption of fish, respectively. Most whales fed in the Ross Sea shelf/slope and Balleny Islands high-productivity regions, but some isotopically distinct whales (mostly males) fed at higher trophic levels either around the Balleny Islands and frontal upwelling areas to the north, or en route to Antarctica in temperate waters off southern Australia and New Zealand. These results support other observations of humpback whales feeding during migration, highlighting the species' dietary plasticity, which may increase their foraging and breeding success and provide them with greater resilience to anthropogenically mediated ecological change. This study highlights the importance of combining in situ field data with regional-scale isoscapes to reliably assess trophic structure and animal feeding locations, and to better inform ecosystem conservation and management of marine protected areas.

Text
Manuscript_Bury_Humpback whale isotope foraging_21 Dec 2023 - Accepted Manuscript
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (5MB)
Text
m734p123 - Version of Record
Available under License Creative Commons Attribution.
Download (6MB)

More information

Submitted date: 13 June 2023
Accepted/In Press date: 10 January 2024
Published date: 18 April 2024
Keywords: Amino acids, Antarctica, Feeding ecology, Isoscapes, MixSIAR, UNSDG14 Life Below Water, δ13C, δ15N

Identifiers

Local EPrints ID: 491092
URI: http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/id/eprint/491092
ISSN: 0171-8630
PURE UUID: 65166440-8248-4f23-a643-6eb844829abb
ORCID for Clive Trueman: ORCID iD orcid.org/0000-0002-4995-736X

Catalogue record

Date deposited: 11 Jun 2024 23:55
Last modified: 15 Jun 2024 01:39

Export record

Altmetrics

Contributors

Author: Sarah J. Bury
Author: Katharina J. Peters
Author: Amandine J.M. Sabadel
Author: Katie St John Glew
Author: Clive Trueman ORCID iD
Author: M.B. Wunder
Author: Matthew R.D. Cobain
Author: Natalie Schmitt
Author: David Donnelly
Author: Sarah Magozzi
Author: Kylie Owen
Author: Julie C.S. Brown
Author: Pablo Escobar-Flores
Author: Rochelle Constantine
Author: Richard L. O’Driscoll
Author: Mike Double
Author: Nick Gales
Author: Simon Childerhouse
Author: Matthew H. Pinkerton

Download statistics

Downloads from ePrints over the past year. Other digital versions may also be available to download e.g. from the publisher's website.

View more statistics

Atom RSS 1.0 RSS 2.0

Contact ePrints Soton: eprints@soton.ac.uk

ePrints Soton supports OAI 2.0 with a base URL of http://eprints.soton.ac.uk/cgi/oai2

This repository has been built using EPrints software, developed at the University of Southampton, but available to everyone to use.

We use cookies to ensure that we give you the best experience on our website. If you continue without changing your settings, we will assume that you are happy to receive cookies on the University of Southampton website.

×